(While the issue of gendered toilets doesn't only impact trans people, this community feels like a useful place to ask such a gender-focused question)

There is support around progressivists for the abolition of gender-segregated toilets, which neatly resolves the complexities of fitting non-binary humanity into legally-segregated binary restrooms (as well as removing their role in reactionaries' suppression of trans people). Unisex toilets have been common and normal in all societies I've visited. It also seems more efficient from a building design perspective, increasing available space and decreasing wait times. Ideally, removing sex/gender restrictions on toilets makes sense.

However, in your own societies you live in, would this ideal solution work if implemented immediately? Imagine the government and all businesses agree to remove sex/gender labels from bathrooms and anyone can go in any of them.

For example, one of the mainstream rationales for restroom segregation is that it protects women from abuse by men. In your societies, do you believe immediate desegregation would materially change the amount of abuse faced by people? Have restrooms served as a useful safe(r) space? Or is this rationale unrealistic?

all 11 comments

sorted by: hot top controversial new old
[–] 9 points 7 hours ago

It's fairly common here (Auckland, NZ) in smaller boutique restaurants and bars.

Unsurprisingly it works perfectly.

You know, like the toilet in your house.

  • source
  • [–] 6 points 6 hours ago (1 child)

    Not trans myself. I've been working in local government policy about school buildings and pushing gender neutral toilets everywhere. On top of preventing harassment of trans youths, they prevent gender-oriented issues such as fights in boy's toilets and extreme makeup sessions in girl's toilets. They teach kids that they can share health-related infrastructure without stigma or violence.

  • source
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] 5 points 8 hours ago (1 child)

    If you have toilets packed in at the highest possible density then you can have many stalls and far fewer basins for washing hands, with a single door for the room and then "doors" for the cubicals, along with urinals for the men's toilets. This is good from a capitalist perspective because it is more cost efficient even though the overall experience is not very good. This type of room does not make me feel safe and in fact feels quite distinctly unsafe, with other people able to intrude on my private time.

    The best alternative is not to have that but without gender segregation. It is to have fully enclosed rooms with a door and a toilet and hand basin. If someone goes in the door is closed and locked. They use the facilities however they need to and then waash their hands and leave. Whether they were one gender or not doesn't matter, they are just a person using a bathroom.

    The less awesome alternative is like my experience of European toilets. The stalls are floor to ceiling and have individual locks on them, the hand basins are in the middle, and if there are urinals they are individual rather than a wall and have dividers.

    I think businesses should be required by law to have bathrooms as part of the facility they occupy. For example, and independent building away from any others would need internal bathrooms, whereas a shop in a shopping centre would have the centre toilets. The number should be proportionate to the maximum number of people there at any time and should have a meaningful number be more accessible than the others for people with mobility support needs.

    But yes, culturally, if you got rid of big rooms with lots of shared toilets and instead had individual doors for each toilet I think you could get rid of the gender entirely overnight. If you wanted to have genderless toilets with shared spaces it would have a lot of difficulties and I don't think it would be worth pushing for. Pushing for the individual toilet rooms solves most of the problems together without introducing more problems and is something that feels more like the toilet at home, just a room you use that could have people of any gender and proper privacy.

  • source
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] 1 point 4 hours ago

    I think businesses should be required by law to have bathrooms as part of the facility they occupy. For example, and independent building away from any others would need internal bathrooms, whereas a shop in a shopping centre would have the centre toilets. The number should be proportionate to the maximum number of people there at any time and should have a meaningful number be more accessible than the others for people with mobility support needs.

    You described the situation in Finland quite precisely. Except for the exemption that restaurant with no more than 6 places for the customers along tables are allowed to not have a toilet at all.

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 5 points 7 hours ago

    Gendered toilets are made up by big Bathroom to sell more toilets.

    No but seriously you can analyze the shit out of this. Eventually you will get to something like Judith Butler wrote. Fascinating stuff.

  • source
  • [–] 3 points 8 hours ago

    Unisex toilets will never be the norm in the US. Will not happen. There might be some businesses that do it, but they will be the extreme minority. If it becomes popular, the conservatives will use it as a rallying cry to further push Trans people outside of society, and legally enforce “traditional” gender roles in more areas of public and private life.

    Bonus! Women will lose rights and autonomy in the process of protecting…uh, women and little girl’s rights?

  • source
  • [–] 2 points 7 hours ago* (1 child)

    would this ideal solution work if implemented immediately? Imagine the government and all businesses agree to remove sex/gender labels from bathrooms and anyone can go in any of them.

    In America, absolutely not. This would be the worst of all possibilities.

    Toilet stalls in America have a 61cm gap at the bottom walls all the way around, they only go up to about 2m from the floor, and they have 1cm gaps along all seams where the walls meet.

    There would be a huge increase in peeping, voyeur recording, public masturbation, and sexual assault. Bathrooms would no longer be safe for women.

    Here is an image that shows the wall and gap problem. Note, that solid wall on the right is highly unusual. Usually both the side walls are exactly like that door. So someone can peep from the "privacy" of the stall next door.

    Google some images if you're curious.

  • source
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] 1 point 5 hours ago (1 child)

    i believe abuse but much more so discomfort would probably increase. for most people here sharing a bathroom with people of a differen gender seems to be a big taboo. also there seems to be a discomfort with people of different gender hearing/smelling one using the toilet. i think its the natural consequence of how segregated toilets are... also most men's toilets here currently just have urinals out in the open which i believe is allost an act of sexual harassment in itself, even without having them be used by everyone? i don't know how men stand it... ig it also goes back to what one is raised with?

    but we also can't contune as it is right now. i believe the men/woman segregated toilets both help to uphold sexism and exclude and invalidate nonbinary people (such as myself) and are often used to harass all trans people. something needs to be done about it and adding nonbinary toilets is not the solution (even purely logistically, adding a third toiler is not really possible in most buildings)

    so i believe in the medium term, restrooms should be refitted with completely sealed off cabinats per individual toilet or urinal (or idk keep the urinals together in one big separete room, if it's users are into that) not this thiny wooden walls on stilts bs. this would drastically improve comfort and safety i believe. maybe panic buttons that call security staff and sound an alarm could also be a good idea just to make sure? idk.

    in the short term, and this is a pretty easy one that i see in many progressive spaces, the former men's toiler could become a all gender/gender neutral toiler and the former women's toilet could become a toiler for everyon other than endo cis men. this allows people with a higher need or desire for safety to receive a similar amount of protection as women's toilets provide rn, just for more people. of course this idea kind of also points out the strangeness of the whole gender segregation of toilets. like why would gender be the only categorie in which people need protection on toilets? what about gender nonconforming, visibly queer, or otherwise marginalized endo cis men? i believe these incoherences becoming more obvious might be a positive tho, towards fixing them.

    in the long term i would hope that our societies stop being sexist and patriarchal and move away from gender as a meaningful distinction and no one will be abusive in a specifically gendered way and no one will give a fuck anymore who they use a toilet with. it is still far away, especially with reactionaries trying to turn back what progress was already made in the last decades, but i believe it is possible. believing anything else is just depressed doomerism, resigning human societies to never improve and escape the pits that they or others dug for them.

    (btw me wishing for a sociery where gender is no longer a meaningful distinction does not mean that i want everyone to renounce their gender, just for it to become something a lot more individual and without grearer social importance, instead of the great social power that it is right now, where everyone is categorized, judged, discussed, and segregated based on it.

  • source
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] 1 point 1 hour ago

    I think the urinals are probably not a big issue because as it stands they're built in places where an alternative (what is currently the women's toilet) exists. Could honestly just relabel them "toilet with urinals" and "toilet without urinals" and then in new buildings they could be in a seperate room.

    Though I can't tell you how most men would feel about it, I wouldn't give a shit but I'm closet transfem and just overall if anything have fewer issues being naked around women. My guess is that most here still wouldn't care though.

    From the one place I've been to that had gender neutral toilets, virtually all the women came out of the former women's toilet, and the men out of the former men's toilet. But the option being there is nice. Some transfems might also like the option to use urinals so that's another upside.

  • source
  • parent