At least you get the panic part. At best I seem to get idk like an attempt to comfort me, as if I’m crazy and upset about something that isn’t a big deal.
post
There's not a whole lot of reason for individuals to concern themselves with collapse. Really. Sure, educate yourself on issues and do what you can to vote for leaders that will hopefully move the needle. But there's not much any one individual can do about it. And if we do hit a hard collapse, there's realistically not much you can do to prep for it. Foisting conversations of collapse onto people seems a lot like repeatedly striking up conversations about the inevitability of death. Sure, death is inevitable, but it's also not socially acceptable to continuously mention that all the time. Yes, everyone dies eventually. You can sit around lamenting that fact, or you can go out and live the one life you'll ever have to live. Socially, we've developed a convention where while we all admit death is real, it's also impolite to bring that fact up constantly.
By introducing all these people to the topic of collapse...what exactly are you hoping to gain by doing so? What do you actually want them to do with that information? What good does collapse awareness actually do for someone, unless they're just interested in the topic from an intellectual perspective? If you like studying history and seeing the parallels between the past and the present, then sure, being aware of collapse has some value. But just trying to broach the topic with random people?
It would be like walking up to a mother holding a recently born infant and telling her, "there's a 15% chance your baby will die from cancer." You're not wrong in that case. You're not lying to her. That is about the lifetime chance for someone to die from cancer. But you just don't talk to people like that. Unless there's some actual benefit from sharing such bad news, or some action they could take, why bother? You're just causing people emotional pain for no reason.
Idk why that other person had an issue cuz this comment is a perfect response to OP's question.
You’re establishing yourself as party to the boot. Politeness and decorum are the masters tool. Make them realize the situation. We all have to live on this planet, “traumatizing” a person with grim fact will drive change.
Yeah, and the change it will drive is a change in the people they hang out with.
They dont care, they know billions of people in coastal cities around the world will die and get swallowed up by the rising ocean levels.
It's a very distressing and in some ways confrontational topic, especially for people who have families to worry about. What reaction exactly are people hoping for?
What reaction exactly are people hoping for?
Galvanised into acting in the best interest of the biosphere and thus humanity in self, particularly if they have family to worry about.
and yet most either ignore it, deny it or helo hasten collapse via their actions
What sort of actions are you thinking of?
Yeah. Honestly even with those that get it. Sorta don't. Like im a doomer but not much of a prepper. Im older and a city boy and if and when things get to a point where cities just can't function I would rather take a pill then close up in a bunker. Its like even with day to day life its like. Hey as an individual it can be better due to vagarities but in general things are going to be worse. Don't get me wrong. If society reduces wealth disparity and works very efficienctly and renwewably, it can be a lot better but. Well. We seem to keep going along the worse case scenario path.
Yeah, I'm not sure what kind of pill it would be, but I keep asking my folks to get me some for Christmas. Don't plan on using them, but sure wouldn't mind having a vial of them around for a collapse scenario or just getting too old to function in the way that I want to.
pretty much the same. I saw my father spend the last decade or so of his life with alzheimers and severe demetia. Thats a time period I can do without.
That is a tough one because it can be hard to realize that you're in losing those cognitive capacities. Many people with dementia don't feel any different experientially. Their sense of self feels intact to them because of the way our brain fills in the interruptions in consciousness.
yeah basically by the time quality of life becomes so bad any sane person would want to exit out you are no longer competent to make the decision. This is the real trap of the whole thing. Its the closest thing to like a zombie type movie. If you want to maximize your life before turning into one than you already turned into one. Its impossible unless you go early.
I guess you need to decide what it is that you want to talk about? What is your goal for the discussion? Are you trying to assess their disaster-readiness? Are you trying to have some sort of shared catharsis, sharing thoughts of the approaching horrors? Are you trying to encourage them to be more prepared? All of the above will have wildly different approaches that will be most useful.
In my own life, discussions about state of/improvements to preparedness are the only ones I see as worth having. And I find people (that I care about) are more likely to have the mental capacity to talk things through and make plans and solutions if I approach the topic gently and not as a (very true, but less helpful) "we're totally and entirely fucked if we don't get a plan together for climate collapse".
Several responses in this thread are why collapse is inevitable and sustainable significant change will never happen again without calamity
all 21 comments