As a parent of a 17 year old, most of whom's friends are 18-20, damage from terrible parenting regularly gets processed in my living room. These are privileged white kids and fully half of them either have checked out MIA parents or busybody, meddlesome helicopter parents. The kids with checked out parents actually seem to be happier and doing better.
post
This generation of parents are scary surveillance drones cataloging everything their kids do digitally from the moment they are born with how many will share pics and videos through social media. Add in use of tracking tools and it goes another level.
Article cuts out / is paywalled here. If you have another link, I'd like to read it.
Re: the overall topic. I'm reminded of far too many Black Mirror episodes (including, IIRC, one exactly on this scenario).
It's tough for parents out here. Probably the best outcome is to watch over your kids like a hawk when they're little, raise them in a safe environment, and give them the ability and tools to stand on their own two feet as they mature.
Then, if your kids want to stay in touch, they will. If they don't, they don't.
Mine are under 10. I unapologetically curtail social media, YouTube, internet, messaging apps etc. But I don't stick a leash up their asses. I'm tired, boss. We have the privilege of living in a quiet street, so they can go out and play with their friends 1980s style ("come back when the sun goes down").
I made the choice to move to the area about 15 years ago, knowing full well that it'd pay dividends. And look, it did. I acknowledge that not everyone has that privilege.
I've given my eldest Conversations (XMPP) so she can message me wherever and whenever she has data connection on her tablet (I host the XMPP server, not federated, so it's a family-only messaging service). I've also given her an old Moto phone with the same (data only).
I don't have GPS tracking or anything like that switched on. The tech is otherwise locked down with apps I've pre-approved, has usage timers etc.
I've said to her plain as day: "If you can hack it, try. Bring your A game, newb." I want her to try to break shit, because that's how I learned in ye olden times.
If I had more time, I'd set up breadcrumbs so that if she did X, she'd get clue Y, inadvertently picking up some technical skills on the way. This is how robotics and coding is taught in her school, via apps Scratch, WeDo and Lightbot.
But beyond that, if she wants to message me, she can. Though mostly memes, emojis and 6-7 nonsense. She leaves me on "read" too. I've had to explain what that means in terms of netiquette.
That's the best I can do on the tech front. I've got 100 other fires to deal with without needing to add 24/7/365 monitoring to the mix.
Sorry, this turned into a ramble.
My sisters do that with their kids all in their 20s. I tell them its creepy but the kids decided to keep it on. The kids these days.
The rest of my family all have those family tracker apps enabled. I don't even have my gps enabled 99% of the time.
I knew a young man who would get coverage at work, but still go in, leave his phone, and go do what he wanted while to his parent's surveillance app it looked like he was at work.
To me this looked like a failure of something. I just know my parents wouldn't have tracked my location.
paywalled :-(
30 comments about an article that you can't read on a post that links to a link of the first 2 paragraphs.
I wish you were all bots. We are fucked. u/metrlnes I see you, a beacon of light and sanity.
Not reading the article is a proud, ancient tradition and I'm happy to see a new generation keep the old ways alive.
Our Farker and Digger ancestors are smiling down at us.
If any of you want to actually read the article ... like a nerd.
Not resolving for me. I tried hitting up archive.ph earlier actually and I got a russian domain seizure notice.
That was with cloudflare's DNS. Are you visiting a cached copy/cached DNS resolution? what IP does archive.ph resolve to for you?
edit: lol now it resolves. Heisenbug: disappears when you try to show someone.
This is invasive, but I will grant you that I can see why people (both the kids and their parents) might want it. I grew up in a time when even full grown adults (college kids and working adults) would go missing and nothing would come of it. This is still a thing today (for every kid or adult you see on the news there's hundreds or thousands who don't make the media cycle ever).
On the other hand though I think having privacy and space from your parents (and from your children) is a good thing. People shouldn't live in a fish bowl.
This argument is bullshit and only leads to more extreme surveillance, see flock cameras.
I think you misunderstood. I think it's a bad idea. But just like apps that let your friends know your location in the event you go on a date, I can see why some people might want it. Hence the "this is invasive" start to my comment.
I think you made a thoughtful response stating why you could see someone else’s point of view. I think the response you got was rude, completely lacking in thought and utterly unhelpful. I’m sure their ridiculous single sentence assertion made them feel smug though. Whatever helps people get through the day.
Posting this really to make sure you know at least one person noticed.
I understand that most downvotes are coming from folks who understand that this is the privacy community. And you understand that privacy and security are at odds.
But this is NOT about a government running secret courts to quash citizen privacy. This argument is about parents of children ranging from middle school to college time wanting to ensure that they can find out if their children are safe without looking like the nosey parent. Very often, those children have full control and ability to turn the feature off, and you’ll see from most comments of people who use this that their kids keep the feature off. You can call that conditioning, but I would call your inability to see a parent’s concern as conditioning as well.
To my mother, it was a deep comfort to see my little dot moving on the highway and she would call me when she saw I was in the car. That way, she wouldn’t disturb me when I’m getting out of the house. That was once we’d established that I’m an adult and don’t need to be looked at from the safety perspective.
Before that, when I was in college, I’ve had my parents question why I wasn’t in class when I should have been. They’re paying for the fucking education. They have a right to know that my labs are done and a paper is due, so I’m at home working through that.
This is not privacy, but this is responsibility. Please, downvote it if you disagree. But do not equate privacy with a parent relinquishing their responsibility towards their child or a child relinquishing their responsibility, of studying and working and not dying in a ditch, towards their parent.
At odds? Privacy is security.
Yeah, I’m going to put a hard disagree on this. Because this is being a nosy parent. Just because the parents can do it behind the scenes doesn’t make it less nosy. In fact, since they can surveil their kid more completely, I’d say it’s worse.
And really, if by college your kids aren’t mature enough to understand why they should be there and studying, that’s on the parents for not teaching them the value of education, and a tracking app is not a fix.
It really sounds like your parents never learned to trust you, tbh.
The divergence in opinions here is really interesting. I'm a childless Gen X, so for me it seems crazy to allow that kind of tracking; it's like the antithesis of latchkey kids. I feel like a lot of people my age reacted against being raised like we were (by the TV), and are really invested in their kids' lives to the point that tracking them seems reasonable. I guess that's sitting for them to work out with their kids; it would make me uncomfortable, but I'm not them.
Location data doesn't tell a student's parents anything about their academic performance at college. Why is it so unreasonable for a student's phone to be in their dorm room during an exam? That's what I always did, given that my tests always had a no phone policy and I feared getting in trouble for accidentally bringing it to the exam.
As a tool for measuring the parents investment value or whatever, it's entirely insufficient for the task. My school had a system where parents could sign up to receive independent transcript copies each enrollment period, which seems like a much better metric given that grades are what determine graduation.
Yes. Have 'find my phone' locating on for my 20-something kids. And they can see where I am. What's the problem?
It's not a problem if it's based on mutual consent.
Mutual consent can’t really exist in a relationship where one is dependent on the other.
Yeah, and with that dependence comes guidance and parental concern. Now, if your parent is abusive, sure, cut and run. But if they’re a concerned parent, no need to act like this is an invasion of privacy. Just set clear boundaries about it being a safety and responsibility feature. Not a tracking feature.
Just set clear boundaries about it being a safety and responsibility feature. Not a tracking feature.
The last sentence is absolutely false and the statement itself makes no sense. What "boundaries" are you respecting tracking your family? You may have conditioned your children to accept your invasion as some sort of parental right, but that in no way justifies it.
The only time I look to see where my daughter is is when she's supposed to be heading my way and I want an eta without harassing her to make her feel bad about being late. She could turn it off if she wants. She 'spies' on me when she wants to call about something and waits until I'm moving away from work or the gym. Occasionally I get a 'why were you (eg at the Toyota dealer across town)' and we have a laugh. It's just a handy tool and I've got nothing to hide. I also have an AirTag on my dad's keys. He calls me when he can't find his keys (he's not so good at managing the tech himself). And that means I usually could tell where he is if I wanted to.
False? Maybe to you it’s false. To me, my parents who have always had a way to track me, and my children who will always be tracked by me, it absolutely IS a safety feature.
Your definition of “invasion of privacy” is a stark example of what western “individualism” thinking you’re conditioned under.
People with slightly more conservative views about technology and its role to play in family life understand that this tech is a nice way to ensure your kid (or you) aren’t dead in a ditch somewhere.
Treat it like that, instead of some evil invasion of “privacy”.
It’s very telling that half the comments on this post agree with me and half do not.
They're 20 something. If they didn't get enough guidance by now for you to trust them (which should have finished years ago), nothing you do is gonna fix that until they get out from under your thumb.
I agree with you, my 20 something kids trust me and know exactly how to turn it off, and had it off for a while, but they share their location because they wanted too, and if something happens to them I can see their last location. My oldest lives on the other side of the country and knows I don’t spy on him and like to share the places he is visiting or traveling too.
We all have location services turned on. All of us know where each other are. Nobody cares.
The problem isn’t the location service, the problem is parent’s use of location as a threat.
Folks, this may come as a shock to everyone, but your parents do often want what’s best for you. Do they want to make sure you get to your classes on time? Yes. Do they want to make sure you don’t get raped in one of these stupid college rituals? Yes.
So people need to cool it acting as if this is the worst thing in the world.
Throughout my life, I’ve made sure my parents have multiple avenues to see my location - Google Maps, Apple find my. We don’t talk about it. We don’t acknowledge it, but it’s a safety feature and it’s ON.
Have they sometimes used it to ask why I was at home when I should have been in college which they paid for? Yes. Did they stop it once they understood my frontal lobe has developed? Also yes.
I'll be completely honest with you. I know my parents really tried to do their best, but most of their decisions that they made for me past about age 10 were mistakes that I'm still paying for to this day. If my parents had demanded to know my location at all times, I would rather have thrown my phone away than allow that. (Smartphones became popular after I was already an adult.)
all 6 comments