So I love worldbuilding and have been working on a years-long passion project. I decided to use it in a campaign but a player really took issue with some of my choices with races.

I understand that having a race of wholly evil individuals can be an issue. But what if they universally have some kind of trait that isnt necessarily good or evil? For example, I have a race of what would appear to be tieflings, but occupy the space that elves might in Tolkien. One of their characteristics is that they physically change throughout the year. Their hair might change color. they may become stronger. Their magic may be more potent. Their physiology is linked to the state of the forest around them

I also have a race of lizard people. They aren't super complicated. They just live in the lizard people country because the conditions there suit lizard people needs more than other races.

Would these things make me guilty of some sort of essentialism?

all 8 comments

sorted by: hot top controversial new old
[–] 8 points 18 hours ago* (1 child)

This all depends on what kind of story you want to tell. If you're going for something mythical, or classic fantasy, then by all means, have Good vs Evil, and don't be afraid of saying "orcs are all evil". If you want to do a more nuanced alternate reality kind of story, then you'll probably need to spend a lot more time making sure things are nuanced. Personally, I prefer a mythical feel to my fantasy; I'd rather be involved in a struggle against Evil than trudging through a morally grey universe where everyone kind of sucks equally; I get enough of that IRL.

Edit to add: The important thing is to make sure that your players are interested in playing the kind of story you're interested in telling. If there's a mismatch, people won't be happy.

  • source
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] 3 points 8 hours ago

    I would also add, give a reason for the essential characteristics. Orcs are all evil is a statement that has to make internal sense. Orcs were made by the great evil Whosbar and he made them by corrupting humans. Giving a narrative history for a trait takes it out of biological essentialism and into facts within that world.

    If your divinity runs along good and evil then actually define what those mean and what parts of life are considered. Is littering evil? Is murder evil? Make it clear whether mistreating animals is evil or not. Also, many things can be morally grey without any issue. Nobody cares that you cheated on your partner, that is between the two of you, but if you take a life not in self defence then that is murder.

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 4 points 10 hours ago* (last edited 10 hours ago)

    Without specifics as to know what they took issue with, we can’t really give more than general ideas here.

    For examples of problematic racial presentations, look at Star Wars and Star Trek.

    Gungans are caricatures of the Caribbean island’s accents, while also leaning heavily into stereotypes of blacks in general.

    Neimodians are Chinese caricatures.

    Star Trek, ferengi are Jewish caricatures. Klingons are Soviet Russians.

    Interestingly, people with British accents are to be avoided in both franchises!

    It’s extremely difficult to not fall into the trap. A lot of culture was the way it was for practical reasons.

    Look at housing- places that are cold tend to have more insulated materials. Places that are temperate might instead worry about storms, places That are hot have deeper eaves. In the northern hemisphere, you might situate your house to face south to get more sunlight.

    Materials that can be sourced locally are always going to play a role. You wouldn’t have a society building with bamboo if they weren’t near bamboo forests.

    Japan’s distinctive architecture evolved as a result of the environment. As did the clothes that they wear, the tools they used and crops they grew.

    But there’s no reason to believe that a species living on something akin to the Japanese islands… would develop katanas, the distinctive bows, and spears as battlefield weapons any more than they might develop a Viking’s sword or Polynesian (forgive me… I forget what those things made out of shark teeth are called?)

    And there’s no real reason to believe they’d have the same style of governance or character flaws.

    And to be clear, no society built off deception and betrayal can last S a power for very long. Humans are where we are because we build societies. So stay away from things like Lloth-sworn drow. Just annoys me. Society requires some trust, some social framework.

    (Although, it could be an interesting narrative, presenting a race as that, but having that be propaganda to compel obedience of another society.)

    I see nothing wrong with either of the races you presented, as you presented them.

    Some thought should be given in to where the cities/settlements are built. (Usually around impasses, or safe harbors. Places people have to naturally stop.)

  • source
  • [–] 3 points 18 hours ago (1 child)

    I think it has more to do with how you treat those characters. Are they one-dimensional caricatures existing to serve the plot?

  • source
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] [S] 1 point 18 hours ago

    I mean if they're one dimmensional, it'll be because im not a good writer. I'm not out to make a caricature of anything. I just get ideas i think are neat and try to do something with them. But my player seems to be taking an ethical issue with giving unique traits to races at all.

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 2 points 15 hours ago

    I don’t think so - there’s nothing anti-lizard people about them living in their traditional homelands for environmental or maybe just historic/family tie reasons, nor is there anything problematic about a species that changes somehow with the seasons. Hares turn white in winter, bears hibernate, etc. If you tie the rationale for the change to something specific (lay lines cycling up or down in power, maybe just a cultural reason) and then upset that mechanic because of an unforeseen event or series of events, all the more interesting and conflict creating!

  • source
  • [–] 2 points 15 hours ago

    Define "problematic". What exactly did they take issue with?

  • source
  • [–] 1 point 12 hours ago

    I think evil species are fine even in nuanced stories. But world building that connects darkness with evil is in My opinion problematic.

  • source