The usual defense of US policy is that the president is just following the people. The polls say otherwise.
April 2002. Bush had just demanded that Sharon withdraw from the West Bank. A Time/CNN poll taken April 10 and 11 found that 60 percent of Americans felt US aid to Israel should be cut off or reduced if Sharon refused to withdraw. 75 percent thought Powell should meet Arafat on his trip. Only 35 percent found Sharon trustworthy. 35 percent called him a warmonger. 20 percent called him a terrorist. 25 percent considered him an enemy of the United States.
May 2003. A University of Maryland poll found over 60 percent of Americans would be willing to withhold aid to Israel if it resisted US pressure to settle the conflict. Among politically active Americans that number rose to 70 percent. 73 percent said the US should not favor either side. Only 17 percent agreed with the Bush and Sharon claim that the conflict is part of the war on terrorism. 54 percent saw it as a conflict between two national groups fighting over the same land. 55 percent had a positive view of the Road Map. When told its key elements, support rose to 74 percent.
Even the ADL own 2005 survey found that 78 percent of Americans believe their government should favor neither Israel nor the Palestinians.
So the public was not the obstacle. The public wanted evenhandedness. The obstacle was the Israeli lobby.
Brent Scowcroft was national security adviser to the first President Bush. In October 2004 he said Sharon had George W. Bush "wrapped around his little finger."
The authors put it plainly. "Absent the lobby, the Bush administration almost certainly would have been much more self-interested and hard-nosed in pushing for peace between Israel and the Palestinians." The US has done this to other states many times. It pressured Ukraine, Kazakhstan, and Belarus to give up nuclear weapons. It pressured Libya to give up its weapons programs. It fought an air war over Kosovo. Putting pressure on Israel would not have been unusual. It just never happened.
My analysis is this is the anti-democracy part nobody talks about. Most Americans wanted the US to pressure Israel. 60 to 78 percent depending on the poll. The Israeli lobby is a minority position. And it won every single time. So when they say America supports Israel because Americans support Israel, that is a lie. Americans wanted evenhandedness. The lobby made sure they never got it. That is not democracy. That is a foreign policy run against the voters.
Source: The Israel Lobby and U.S. Foreign Policy, 2007, a book written by John Mearsheimer and Stephen Walt
1 comment