If I recall Ukraine had a similar polling, but that all changed when the Invasion happened for real.
post
Even in full mobilization during wartime, you would usually expect 10% or less of the populace to be actively involved in fighting. Germany hit 30% during WWII but that was a major outlier.
And it's not like tactics haven't changed either, wars can now continue with a very low proportion of the population's participation.
Even though it means less direct casualties to use robots, I suspect it will lead to problems when wars don't need the public's consent or participation to continue.
In the world wars it took something like 5 workers working to field 1 soldier. They are participating too. Obviously that factor has been increasing with technology, and is even higher now, as you are saying.
In an actual World War 3 conflict the number of combatants you had would be irrelevant anyway. It would be a war fought with drones and nukes, that'd be very little human on human fighting.
Makes sense, people are picking between food and utilities while the rich are going richer. People are getting arrested for opposing the evils of the world while being terrified of leaving their houses because actual crime is running rampant. Rascism, misogyny and otherisms are growing again.
It should be mentioned - particularly in the context of the topic of this article - that 41% of the so-called Independent is owned by this guy:
Let me know when half are willing to fight with the invaders. It won't be long.
Okay so as suspected the question isn't really the one that should have been asked.
Obviously I would prefer the government to use the military we already have to fight Russia. Especially considering that as far as I'm aware Russia barely even has a military at this point. So they shouldn't need conscription.
However that's not really the scenario that they should be asking about.
The question should have been, would you fight from your country in the scenario in which the military had been defeated and the nation occupied. In which case obviously the answer is yes.
Asking people if they would support a hypothetical conscription is stupid because the military have already stated they don't want to ever do that again because conscripts are useless. So the question should be phrased accordingly. Otherwise it's a pointless pole.

all 38 comments