AI can be made to use the same apis that any app can use, so it is possible to make AI edit comments.
post
If I would be fresh out of Moscow uni, with an IT degree, and Putin would order me to influence voters in the western world, I would pronto create a piece of software that could just do that. So yes, and it is probably being done already; keep healthy skepticism when you’re online.
The answer is no. An llm agent can write a post as well as edit it, and it can be done without the Lemmy instance knowledge or capability to detect.
An llm agent uses a browser to act, so it's much harder than a normal bot to detect. It can also use normal user credentials if those were provided to it, so it can edit my comment: create by human and edit by ai. Also, of course, true the other way around.
(Edit note: in this case created and edited by human, if you believe me)
Your thinking is that an AI wouldn’t have second thoughts and decide to change its first response?
It makes sense, but at soon as it becomes a recognizable thing, they’ll make AIs edit their posts deliberately.
Honestly it's a good idea IMO. The thing is, if it becomes common wisdom that edited comments signal credibility, then spambot makers that want them to look human can easily program them to do that and take advantage of that common wisdom. At that point it wouldn't be a useful signal anymore. That's the nature of a cat and mouse game like this.
But for the time being? It sounds like a reasonable heuristic to me. But just like everything in this area, no single thing is 100%.
it would think
AI has no brain, it doesn't think. It is a computer program.
Not true. It create independent train of thought. If you use an agent and look it act, that's exactly what it does.
That's more thinking than my dogs. Less than a human. And not physiological thinking of course, just a bunch of mathematical processing, but it's very well capable of performing basic thinking.
It asks questions, provides answers, discusses those answers, drops them, and repeats. Still all mathematical processing indeed with a sparkle of randomness.
But it's a train of thoughts.
Does it give any truth or reality to what it thinks? No.
Saying that dogs think less than "AI" "agents" is INCREDIBLY insulting to dogs. Like, holy fuck, dude.
-- Frost
No, we cannot assume that because it is possible for an AI to edit a comment.
all 15 comments