"It's always difficult when a parent dies, and there's no simple solution for the complicated, emotionally charged situations that follow. My condolences for your loss. Some people on substack have suggested grief counseling might be able to help raise you back to baseline and others on Reddit's dungeons and dragons subreddit have suggested going in a grand adventure to kill god for their part in your misfortune."
post
It might even be healthier to talk to yourself. Wouldn’t that be a cool experiment to run.
are you saying I have an llm in my head
My brain skimmed usernames to see Z…h…ah and I was sure you and @Zephorah@discuss.online were the same person and it was a bit for a second.
except sometimes when you do that you can spiral deeper into depression. Saying this as a person that sometimes has hours-long inner mono/dialogues before sleep.
Oh no, not like that. Professional scientists. There is an ethics board. Things get reduced down to as. Few variables as possible.
The alternative would be survey data, such as it is, on people who’ve already fallen victim to both.
Not all talking to one’s self is born of psychosis. Some is the Mordin Solis type, the “glass is full” overflow type.
excuse me, what are you talking about? Like, what does it have to do with what i said? You gotta elaborate.
The only thing i understood is your last two sentences. Except even they make little sense, because all you're saying is "well actually inner dialogues can be positive", which is obvious and thus contributes nothing to the discussion, since i never even said otherwise.
I do this and so far I haven't gone crazy. And I haven't gone crazy either. Hehehe
Do you know what else is a good listener? A journal or just random sheets of paper you’ll throw away. Open notepad and type your feelings away. You don’t even have to save the document, just write.
Need a void to scream into? There are infinitely many better options than corpo LLMs
Open notepad and type your feelings away.
These days, I wouldn't trust Microslop to Copilot into my notepad and start replying (and charging me for the 'feature').
No thanks, I'll open LibreOffice or just hand jam it.
Write a letter to your past self. Write a letter to your future self. Can be good just to get thoughts out of your head.
like local LLMs
So I could write on a sheet of paper costing me 1¢ or I could run the fraud machine locally after taking out a loan to buy RAM.
Or just the stuff mentioned above...? Why waste power, and so your money, on some shit like that? If you're dumb and crazy enough to see importance in the answers an LLM is giving you there are way more important things you should focus on (like going to a psychologist).
The only people that will take internet strangers screeching stupid shit like this seriously are mentally ill.
Anyways it’s okay, people like different things than you. You’ll survive.
Never even considered that, and still wouldn't.
LLM's to me are complicated, heavily-flawed tools which I would never in a million years entrust upon personal advice.
under no doubt, using LLM for therapy is bad.
but blaming/shaming the most vulnerable people in the moment they need the most support is just evil.
So many services are unnafordable or inaccessible. and 988 sucks for just venting.
Blame companies exploiting people in crisis, not the people in crisis.
Also, the ablism in reducing schizophrenia to 'person yell at object' is very gross
Post can be read as a warning: "if you are considering talking to an llm in search for actual help, you are going one very wrong and harmful way, do not do it"
What those people need instead of that classic bashing mental illness by reducing schizophrenia to something casual is something like a doll or stuffed animal to vent to. Or if that's too childish, some other comfort object that won't further their potential mental decline. Doesn't matter what it is, so long as they just have a much safer way to vent.
It’s only schizophrenia if there’s no totem. Otherwise it’s just sparkling religion.
I tried to ask it about its opinion on terrorism and Israel. Turns out it can't say anything negative about Israel. Even when they're using the fear of uncertainty.
all 61 comments