Rules are enforced differently for corporations than they are for the rest of us.
post
Even if it's not copyright eligible, they still don't have any obligations to release the sources
Even if it can't be copyrighted anymore, it's still under trademark. And it's a shit OS, so why bother rebranding a forked version?
Doesn't trademark just protect the name "Microsoft Windows®" and slogans ("Just Bing it®")?
And yeah, i don't think anyone who knows enough about computers to make an operating system wants to just fork Windows. I'm more curious about how much MS could be hurting themselves by having a robot write important code.
There's still someone mapping out the features, designs etc b4 the AI goes to create it. Also saying 30% of code was AI generated hides cost of making the correct input: Planning, already existing code, Testing & Feedback loop, Reviewing. Its like saying Roofers aren't needed because 100% of nails were done with a nailgun.
Some tasks are easy with AI, others aren't but even when the code itself was 100% autonomous AI generated, the features, design was mapped out by someone is probably sufficient to retain copyright.
An image created by a five word prompt does not have a creative depth in creation like an image created by AI but with many refinement steps to get something truly unique.
I think this would be a case where copyright can only be held over some parts of whatever is being made.
Like Zarya of the Dawn. The text and panel layouts were done by a human author, but all the visuals were done by AI. The author got it copyrighted, bragged about the AI part, and had that copyright revoked. The author owns the dialog and layout and everything else that's not a picture, but nobody owns the visuals.
Let me give you an example that can help answer your question.
I, a shitbag "entrepreneur", find and open source project I like that does 95% of what I want. I proceed to feed the code, design docs, and anything else I can find from the project to an AI. I then ask the AI to write the application from scratch using what I fed it as "inspiration", and add the 5% functionality I want. Now, let's say the AI gets it pretty close to working. Close enough that I can hire a dev to clean it up and get it going.
At the moment, that project is not covered by the open source license since the original code is gone and I used my own resources to "develop" it. I state "at the moment" because there is much debate around this.
AI gets it pretty close to working. Close enough that I can hire a dev to clean it up and get it going.
This simply just isn't how that works. 95% working can very, very easily be 100% shit. Because of the lack of professional guidance and structure, the last 5% could be very difficult or impossible without a complete restructure and rewrite or the whole code base.
This has been true since outsourcing code become popular. So many times I've been asked to "just finish the last 5%" just to have to explain that the last 5% is actually 150% the amount of work (now I have to untangle this mess).
At the moment, that project is not covered by the open source license since the original code is gone
That's not how most open source licenses work. Which is really the crux of the issue. If the new code was based on the open source code in any way it is now open source (at least for GPL code).
If you took a popular open source project, looked at the code and rewrote it by hand, the resulting code is open source. Even if you wrote it in a totally new programming language. I don't see how AI reading and reproducing the code is much different in this sense.
If you took a popular open source project, looked at the code and rewrote it by hand, the resulting code is open source. Even if you wrote it in a totally new programming language.
I completely agree with you BUT this is the mess that is literally playing out now. We need legal clarity because the scenario I wrote is not theoretical, it is happening now.
Also, I am sad to say that I have already seen Claude Fable 5 spit out code to spec that a mid level dev got working in less than 30 minutes by fixing a few connection assumptions the model made. Afterwards, every iteration has been done with the less powerful Claude Opus.
I refuse to believe that the LLM designed everything from scratch and I can almost guarantee that whatever it "knows", it pulled from open source projects. It also explains why it is so good at Java, Bash, and Python, and absolute garbage at PL-SQL.
They're probably safe until some governmental organization builds up enough motivation and money to try and investigate it. And given the reaming they gave the IRS I doubt anyone is up for it.
Beyond that, I can't imagine the sheer legal nightmare it would be, given that MS will hire the best fucking lawyers money can buy. How do you quantify how much is AI generated and how much isn't? How much involvement of AI makes it "AI code"? You could spend years in court arguing about where that particular line is.
It's a fun hypothetical, but unlikely to matter to any real degree, at least for a company their size. Maybe it could be used against some startup making dumb public statements.
If you can get at the 30% of the code without any human modification, then that may be in practice public domain.
Now you have to figure out which 30%, without any human modification, and have the ability to prove the specific code is AI generated.
This is why the companies do not sweat the detail that the output of the LLM might not qualify for copyright, the only way it is a problem is if they label it as such and pass it through without modification.
In the cases proving only humans can hold copyright, the human that wanted copyright had essentially bragged that the works in dispute were 100% not created by humans. One a human has done almost anything to the output, that modification is subject to copyright.
So if the company keeps the details secret and/or mixes it with human output, the copyright issue is moot.
all 16 comments