Nah man China is like a utopia or something.
post
Genocide bad
Shitting on the CCP in any ML community will get you banned for "orientalism"
I specifically said the people of China are nice but the CCP can go fuck itself
I met couple of Chinese who acknowledge the party is tyrannical but they avoid delving deeper into politics. Despite having emigrated, it's a learned response I guess for many Chinese not to talk about politics.
I met couple of Chinese who acknowledge the party is tyrannical but they avoid delving deeper into politics.\
This is because it's illegal to criticize the CCP in China. You can get arrested for this.
We in the west talk a lot of crap about freedom of speech but don't realize how precious a thing it truly is.
That's a totally understandable response. What's not understandable is denying any wrongdoing from the CCP.
Yep. Ate a 3 day ban recently from /c/memes for exactly that before I realized I was on lemmy.ml/c/memes.
The thing is china has a bunch of legit cool stuff about it but its never even the stuff that gets highlighted and instead these communities just infinitely recite the propaganda that is thought to them. Its one thing to like china(which is already a red flag cause you shouldnt like a huge imperialistic dictatorship) but another thing to mindlessly recite it.
China is awesome. Its people are awesome. Its philosophy/culture is great. Its government is doing some awesome things.
The notion that shame should be felt over that view is absurd.
That doesn’t mean they don’t have problems.
One can admire/envy/enjoy China and acknowledge they are an authoritarian state, have some worrying cultural issues, a strongman leader, a bloody history, censored discourse and so on.
These views aren’t mutually exclusive.
And as for the “western imperialist” rhetoric, that has precisely nothing to do with China’s problems. It’s irrelevant whataboutism.
And it’s especially ironic given most of it on Lemmy is spouted from users in western nations.
For reference: Lemmy.ml is banned in China.
I dunno it's pretty easy to think China has some really cool things but also acknowledge it's a terrible place
This is why I personally like to use the cool shit Yugoslavia did. Obscure by western standards and the only ones who get weird about it are Serbs.
China seems to have positive and negative characteristics. For the non-rich it seems slightly better than the US and worse than (say) Norway. They’re still imperialist although they seem more inclined to use soft power and economic relationships rather than warfare.
The point is not that you need to unquestioningly think that China is the most evil country on earth. The point is that there absolutely are a notable subset of leftists (just wander over to .ml if you want to find them) who will dismiss literally any criticism of China as "Western propaganda" and basically act like they're absolute paragons of good. Those are the people being called out here.
Turns out geopolitics isn't simple.
Unless we're talking about nuking France.
Carful, France is the only nuclear power with an explicit nuclear first strike doctrine.
Greetings from Hanoi. China kills Vietnamese and Philippine fisherman and other mariners each year using their paramilitary shadow fleet. China is also a big place and the difference between non-rich in a developed province and non-rich in the rural provinces is extreme. In the last decade, the size of the middle class in places like Shanghai has shrunk dramatically and was arguably never even on par with similar level workers in the USA.
I appreciate the perspective. I knew the Chinese government was not allied with Vietnam but I didn’t know about the killings. And your point about the difference between non-rich in rural areas vs urban areas is true in the US as well. In fact, there was a UN delegation that reported finding some of the most extreme poverty in the world in places like rural West Virginia.
Not sure how accurate the numbers are but this seems to show suicide rates per 100,000 are at 8.9 for China, and 15.6 for the U.S.
That might actually be more about the guns than the despair
True, but people who want to die will find a way. When I was younger I remember there was a sudden influx of people who realized you could speed into the back of an 18 wheeler and the hood/bottom of your car would go under, and the payload crate would crush your head/upper body near instantly.
Human behaviour is formed by both individual traits and their environment. When there are easy and effective suicide options available, suicide numbers tend to be higher. See e.g. https://www.healthdata.org/news-events/newsroom/news-releases/about-740000-global-deaths-suicide-occur-annually-thats-one
When you're really depressed, simple barriers like that can make a big difference. I believe antidepressants can sometimes cause suicide because the patient finally feels ready to go out of their daily routine and get it done. And I can tell you anecdotally that if my mom kept a gun in my house I'd have been dead for over 20 years now. But all my options were unreliable or painful, so I just hid in my hole instead.
Hope you're doing better now. Depression and suicide fucking suck, I've lost too many close family and friends to it. I'm fighting that black dog now too.
I agree. I've been 18 for near 19 years now, and have owned at least 1 gun for 17 of them. The 1 year was a choice when I was depressed, not the only time I was... But I understand your thoughts there.
I also wonder if drugs are as widely available? Some people just take a bunch of pills.
That number probably doesn't even count the suicide by cop. Lots of black men do stupid shit to get people to shoot them too, Ive heard it said
Yep. Twice I've had black dudes try to suicide-by-cop on me and twice they failed to achieve it. They apologized afterward, admitting that they assumed the stereotype was true and not only was their death guaranteed but I wouldn't feel anything about it.
Both would have likely just been recorded as "attempted murder" on me and "justified shooting" without their words after the fact indicating they were attempting suicide.
Quit your job, you fucking pig
Oof, sorry but you're about 6 years late, dipshit.
In your defense Lemmy doesn't feature "stickying" self-posts like Reddit does so you likely had no idea I had a very contentious background where my agency and peers vilify me for refusing to follow illegal orders.
But in your offense, you jumped to a lame-brained conclusion so you earned a block for it <3
Yeah, that was 16 years ago and I think that was actually highly publicized and ended up changing things in favor of workers.
China also has a very fast justice system where there's no jury so they just put you in front of a judge and then shoot you out back.
But I've just read stuff on the internet and don't have much first hand experience so hopefully people with more first hand knowledge can correct this. Also open to new kinds of propaganda, both sides ya know
Yes, I'm sure their workers rights are so much better now. I'm sure BYD in China is totally different from the near slavery from BYD in Hungary.
Definitely no wage slavery in the US
We have problems to work on. Things here are far from ideal.
But China is not the right direction. I'd rather be here than China.
I doubt working for BYD is any worse than working for Amazon. China just has more manufacturing jobs which tend to suck more than other jobs and exploit workers in more visible ways. It is still the case that by most metrics (quality of life, affordability of homes, income inequality, etc.) China is better. That doesn't mean they don't exploit workers or that we should adopt their system, because it has flaws of its own that we can learn from. IMO it was a mistake to require that all labor unions be formalized under the ACFTU (All-China Federation of Trade Unions). By banning independent unions the state becomes a magnet for corruption and a barrier to working class progress. The business community forms relationships with government and is able to exert influence over the ACFTU to control workers. That being said, even a bureaucratic union constrained by the state is better than no union at all because they at least have to maintain the appearance of protecting the interests of the working class.
Contractors hired to build BYD’s factory in Hungary allegedly kept thousands of employees working seven days a week, with shifts lasting more than 12 hours a day,
84 hours a week is worse than anything Amazon has done. And we need to fix Amazon.
This is a perfect analogy. Amazon is bad. BYD is much worse.
A lot of CCP trolls would say that the Uyghur genocide isn't happening and that witness testimony is from a one woman or couple of people who defected to propagandise for the West. But there is a point made that there are too many complains from hundreds, if not thousands, of Uyghurs to dismiss the accusation of genocide as merely from a handful of individuals. Because most people would rather get on with their lives than waste time making accusations.
Egriaga@lemmy.ml Banned
welp
CCP bootlickers run Lemmy like reddit? Damn thats a bummer
What is the suggested process for genocide claim?
Is a (or multiple?) third party inspector needed to be proven innocent?


top 63 comments