you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] 44 points 3 hours ago (2 children)

Good move by Signal, and it's worth understanding what this actually blocks. The feature stops the OS from letting another app grab the screen contents of Signal — that's how on-device assistants like Gemini and Siri read what's on screen when you ask them about it. It's basically the same idea as FLAG_SECURE on Android, just applied to AI screen-reading instead of screenshots. It's a seperate layer from the encryption — Signal's messages are still end-to-end encrypted, this just covers what's shown on screen.

A few caveats worth knowing though:

  • It doesn't stop the other person in the chat from screenshotting on their own phone, and it doesn't help if the device itself is compromised. It's a per-device control, not end-to-end protection.
  • If you use an assistant heavily, check its own settings too — on Android, Gemini has a 'use screen context' option, and on iOS you can limit which apps Siri can learn from. Turning those off is the other half of the fix.
  • YSK this is opt-in, so if you're setting up Signal for someone less technical, it's worth turning it on for them and explaining why.

IMO this is the right direction — apps shouldn't have to rely on the OS to keep AI assistants out of private chats, but untill the OS-level controls get better, per-app blocking like this is the practical answer.

  • source
  • hideshow 2 child comments