you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] 26 points 7 hours ago (2 children)

I feel like people are ignoring huge parts of information in this.

Why not move it out first? -they can't. Litterally one of the first things they normally do. It has degraded too much and has become unstable.

Why not only do small explosions instead if the whole thing at once? -again, they can't. They can't move it it all.

Why blow it up at all? -because it is unstable and has a chance to blow up on its own, uncontrolled and at an unknown time.

Why can't they do anything to mitigate the lead? -they are. They have over 2ft of concrete surrounding it, and have close to two stories of sandbags covering it. And they are going to water down all the soil around it to prevent as much dust as possible, and run water on the explosion when they detonate it.

What is the EPA doing about this? -the Army has worked with the EPA to make the mitigation plan and minimize environmental impacts. They also took aver 130 soil samples from homes and land around the base to monitor lead levels and will be testing random sites after the explosion at randomized intervals. They also worked with the EPA on planning the date to coincide with wind and weather patterns to minimize where the cloud will drift over populated areas.

Why didn't the Army warn the local? -the did. There were even small, uninformed protests of people refusing to understand the situation and insist they could just ignore it and not blow it up. The army even worked with the city to shut down schools for the day and warn businesses to close for the day, and issued a warning to stay indoors or even voluntarily evacuate for the weekend for the dust to settle.

The dumbest part in all of this is the new court order to delay it after all the planning for this specific date. This ammo is getting blown in place whether people want it to or not. The only question is when and on whose terms: the people planning it, or the unstable nature of it. People act like the army doesn't care about the environment, but then anyone who served can tell you that we would get environmental impact breifing before anything we would do and would always do what we could to mitigate impacts. There are huge military regulation on environmental impacts. Private corporations get away with ecocide and most of the time get away with it. In the military they will end people's careers for touching a protected birds nest.

  • source
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] 0 points 2 hours ago (1 child)

    Valid, but:

    were given just a month’s notice

    But the dust plume’s potential 100-mile path extends far beyond Middletown, and the other communities in its path —as well as Iowa’s governor—only became aware of the plan on Monday, after the Army made a public announcement

    This invalidates everything. With proper notice crop planning can occur, people, even low income, can prepare. This has been brewing for years, and if it was your home, you would feel different.

    "Hose down your stuff" is ridiculous.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] 2 points 1 hour ago*

    You are again, ignoring the imminent issue just like everyone else- the material is unstable and can blow on its own at any time. The fact that they are getting more than 24 hours notice is already more than anyone can truly ask for. Planning??? You can't plan for unstable explosives that will explode on their own any day. They have literally already jumped into quick reaction mode and are doing what they can. Do you really think this was intentional? Have you ever spent a day in the military? I am willing to bet people are going to lose rank over this reaching this level. And as far as the "hose it down" thing, do you have a secret de-leading machine? Do you have a better solution that can feasibly and realistically take place right now that the EPA and Army core of engineers don't know about? Or is this just one of those keyboard warrior comments that demands people to "do stuff" but can't articulate what the "stuff" is?

  • source
  • parent