After 9/11 America had a choice. Bin Laden himself named the Palestinian cause and US troops in Saudi Arabia as his grievances. So Washington could have pressured Israel to end the occupation and pulled troops back. There was precedent. Reagan pulled US troops out of Lebanon after a suicide bomber killed 241 marines. Carter and Bush Sr. both made peace progress only by putting pressure on Israel.
Instead the Israeli lobby pushed the opposite. The pitch was simple. Israel is a critical ally in the war on terror. Israel enemies are America enemies. So America should take aim at Hezbollah, Iran, Iraq, and Syria.
It worked. The Bush administration adopted Israel policy preferences toward the Palestinians, Iran, and the rest of the region. It even adopted Israel justifications. American and Israeli leaders began to sound as if they were speaking from the same page.
And it was not automatic. Bush clashed with Sharon in his first year. The State Department, the intelligence community, and the uniformed military backed the alternative path. Bush also differed with Israel on Syria. On both the Palestinian and Syrian issues the Israeli lobby pressured Bush to change course. He changed.
When public figures said the Iraq war was partly for Israel, they got called antisemites.
My analysis is this is the trick in one move. Take America own trauma from 9/11 and turn it into a reason to fight Israel war. The dead from 9/11 became the argument for invading Iraq. And the people who pointed it out got smeared.
Source: The Israel Lobby and U.S. Foreign Policy, 2007, a book written by John Mearsheimer and Stephen Walt