Edit: Vent tag added; cw transphobia

I wish I could just exist somewhere as a woman without having my transness remarked upon in some way.

It's not just that I struggle to make and keep friends, but that I deeply want to be seen as myself, and I often have to choose between accepting being misunderstood or being alone.

Aside from my wife, all my friends right now are guys, and I care about them a lot and wouldn't give them up for anything, but it's very dysphoria-inducing. I don't want to be "one of the boys" all the time. There are some types of platonic interaction, girl talk, that I really miss that I don't get to have anymore.

I lost a really good friend after coming out. Like, there were initial words of support, but then she never wanted to meet up again and rarely messaged me again after that.

I used to get along great really well my best friend's wife, but she got into this conservative-leaning friend group and changed, and the only IRL example they're exposed besides me is a detrans person. Now I get misgendered constantly when I visit my friend, and was once told "I don't have a maternal instinct" the first time I held his newborn baby and everyone in the room laughed. His wife and usually one of her friends are always there when I visit, so I always feel othered, at worst like a man and at best like some third thing.

I've always been too afraid to get involved in womens' groups, so the only time I've tried is here on Lemmy, and now I think that isn't going to work out. For a while being on that community felt really nice. In general on the internet, I don't understand why every "trans women are women" post gets commentators who say "umm actually gender and sex are different and it's important to remind everyone again that you all aren't biological women for science, but trans women are women." And I've had cis people in my life tell me I'm biologically male too. Like, I get it, I know what I have down there. I know I was born with a curse, and it hurts every day thinking about how I'm not cis. I wish cis people (who aren't my doctor) could just ignore that and treat me like they'd treat any other woman. If I try to say it hurts and I don't like that, I'm told I'm silencing others and denying fact. If I ignore it, it keeps happening. I just shouldn't say anything. Social media's a dumpster fire, and I'd like to think I've gotten better at avoiding it and not letting it affect me; today was just a really bad day. Probably going to delete this later.

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] [S] 2 points 3 days ago* (last edited 3 days ago) (1 child)

It's hard to be friends with people who knew you before you officially start transitioning. Like, you love each other but that knowledge is a knife they can use to hurt you, whether they know they're doing it or not.

There's so much pressure to pass because it can be such a barrier to making friends with other women, which has honestly deferred me from trying. I've been treated like a token "gay guy" friend (despite not actually being that), a doll for them to dress up, a punching bag, and ultimately expendable. Not that I plan to give up on trying to make new friends. I guess I've got some baggage lol.

My wife's friend is both trans and a new mom, and she's genuinely the best parent I've ever met, so it's probably safe to say some people are just uninformed about maternal instincts.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • That is unfortunately all very relatable for too many people on here. Sorry I took a while to respond to this, I honestly wanted to say something that could actually be reassuring or helpful.

    One thing that is so wonderful to learn, is that the pressure to pass that you describe here is so much less prevalent around people who accept you. I honestly chose not to maintain a relationship with most people who knew me before I was out, and the ones I did keep were essentially all queer. There is a kind of dysphoria I experienced in the notion that there was some arbitrary level of femininity I had to aspire to to "earn" being recognized as trans, when in reality, I am pretty butch. I grew up in a place that was too conservative to even risk being out in my teen years without risking serious physical injury or ostracization, and I can definitely relate to the idea of being othered by women friends when so much of their experience has taught them to mistrust men, and when they've been socialized to view "men" who don't behave like other men as unserious or less valuable. I meet a lot of trans women who adopt a sort of defensive femininity to address that level of pressure, and I understand why it's necessary as much as why it can be invalidating in of itself if you don't see yourself in the mirror with all that anyway.

    I'm not sure if that's similar to what you've experienced, but I can tell you that I don't need to understand exactly what you've experienced to say that your experiences and the feelings you have about them are completely valid. These are very difficult social tensions that you are expected to navigate, and it is unfair that this expectation is put on you rather than them.

    As far as the maternal instincts element, it is fundamentally misnformed to view those as even a real thing along gender essentialist lines, since y'know, there is no gene stored in the ovaries that teaches you how to swaddle or be patient. When people refer to some sort of natural "female" inclination toward motherhood, they're evoking a history of oppression toward all women to validate an oppresive notion. Any woman who says this kind of bullshit is a traitor.

  • source
  • parent