Wonderful collagen!

Yes, some celery in the broth... still getting everyone onboard with no-plants. The person who added the celery into the broth doesn't even like celery, they were just following a guide. Baby steps.

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] [S] 2 points 5 months ago* (24 children)

What’s the harm in cooking your broth with vegetables? It adds flavors to it that you otherwise won’t get.

If your on a diet that allows for veggies and you can tolerate them, then its fine. Plants in general add oxalates, lectins, plant sterols, and other anti-nutrients - some people are sensitive to them and they can cause issues.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 24 child comments
  • [–] 3 points 5 months ago (12 children)

    Yeah the only stuff I can find when googling plant sterols is generally good sources saying theyre good for lowering cholesterol. The only occasion its bad is if you have a rare genetic disorder.

    Clevelandclinic

    Pre-RFK USDA

    I can't find anything on lectins being good, but that's the substance that makes the long cook time of beans necessary. Wikipedia says cooking makes them inactive and not a problem.

    (Also said the guy pushing anti-lectin diets doesn't have any science to back it up, which isn't a problem for me, but I'd avoid using it as a health argument)

    Interesting, the only concern with oxalates seems to be excessive amounts can hurt Calcium and Magnesium intake and cause kidney stones if eaten in excess. Says WebMD at least but you're fine so long as you're cooking your vegetables which is the case for all of that so far.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 12 child comments
  • [–] [S] 3 points 5 months ago

    (Also said the guy pushing anti-lectin diets doesn’t have any science to back it up, which isn’t a problem for me, but I’d avoid using it as a health argument)

    You didn't ask for science, but I can provide it, but you also say

    That paper is useless to me. I’m not a food scientists or medical nutritionist.

    So... you don't want science - you want someone in authority to give you a opinion, no problem - I can do that too. https://www.diagnosisdiet.com/full-article/grains-beans-nuts-seeds

    Lectins are not a essential nutrient, you can be healthy without them. If you have health problems its a worthwhile lever to pull.

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 3 points 5 months ago (10 children)

    Plant sterols lower LDL, a lipoprotein. Why would you want to lower cholesterol? It's important for our health.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 10 child comments
  • [–] 2 points 5 months ago (9 children)

    Not all forms of cholesterol are good and excess of it is certainly bad.

    My average american diet produced high bad cholesterol that my gastrointestinal doctor and my dietician both agreed was fixed by my switching to a high vegetable diet. Coming from a family of folks with heart disease issues, that's important for me to be aware of and, statistically, average Americans need to also be aware of it.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 9 child comments
  • [–] [S] 3 points 5 months ago (8 children)

    Not all forms of cholesterol are good and excess of it is certainly bad.

    Cholesterol is not a disease. Elevated cholesterol can be a indicator of a metabolic problem, but it did not cause the problem, it is just a symptom.

    My average american diet produced high bad cholesterol that my gastrointestinal doctor and my dietician both agreed was fixed by my switching to a high vegetable diet

    YES! Plant sterols (seed oils, plant fats) will lower your LDL - it does this by impairing both your cholesterol rafts and interfering with your normal hormonal signaling. This is not healthy, this is chasing a intermediate metric. The infamous oreo LDL lowering case study illustrates this well.

    Coming from a family of folks with heart disease issues, that’s important for me to be aware of and, statistically, average Americans need to also be aware of it.

    A far better indicator of CVD risk and outcomes is looking at your metabolic health in totality - Check your TG/HDL ratio you want that to be less then 2, and ideally less then 1. Get a fasting insulin test if possible, and you can see exactly how insulin sensitive you are. Chasing low LDL will not improve your all cause mortality, improving metabolic health will.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 8 child comments
  • [–] 3 points 5 months ago (7 children)

    You're using a lot of terms I don't know and disagreeing with medical professionals who have helped me lose weight and feel a lot better while managing my own gastro disease (crohns).

    I want to know more about pure carnivore, but there are people in my life a lot smarter than me who are medical professionals, I spend a lot of time with my own doctors because of my health issues, and by following their advice of a high plant diet I've felt a lot better.

    Is there somewhere to read more on it s benefits with even a tenantive medical backing? Something I, a simpleton, could veryify? A lot of people I've met who were into carnivore just seemed to be anti-vegan and then working backwards to justify it. Or they were folks trying to sell supplements so people on a carnivore diet could get all the nutrients that were being missed or likely just scamming them.

    The LDL thing seems good when a diet is well balanced and there's all the benefits of the fiber, the nutrients, and the flavor it adds to food. I'm not convinced this is bad. The body is quite complicated and capable of balancing out things at the individual nutrient issue. It makes me think of the alkaline water thing. Our bodies already balance the PH a lot. Drinking water that's more basic than acidic doesn't change much at all.

    I have no idea what TG/HDL is let alone how to measure it. What is a fasting insulin test?

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 7 child comments
  • [–] 3 points 5 months ago* (last edited 5 months ago) (3 children)

    Sorry, I misjudged you for someone not engaging in good faith and decided to stop responding. I'm glad Jet responded.

    medical advice

    We got here because the medical advice from our doctors hasn't helped. If what you're doing has worked for you, then that's fantastic and you should keep going. What zero carb is good for is finding problematic things, since it's an elimination diet. Since the simplest version of it is beef, salt, and water, every other dietary variable is eliminated, making it easier to figure out what the problem is.

    cholesterol

    There's only one form of cholesterol, which is cholesterol. The confusion comes from the carriers that move it around in our body, since cholesterol doesn't dissolve into water on its own. The different forms that you're probably referring are Low Density Lipoprotein and High Density Lipoprotein, popularly referred to as Bad Cholesterol and Good Cholesterol. But they aren't good, nor bad, they're required for our bodies to work, which is why our body makes them all the time.

    If you're curious, there is a talk about LDL here, from Dr Paul Mason:

    Short video: Should I be worried about high LDL cholesterol on a low carb diet? Feat. Dr Paul Mason

    Longer video: Dr. Paul Mason - 'The truth about high cholesterol'

    verify

    If you'd like to try low/zero-carb, a highly verifiable method is by wearing a continuous glucose monitor. I can recommend the Freestyle Libre 2/3, which is what got me started. Keep a food journal and what the reading is on the CGM after eating something. If it goes up above ~120, try not eating it for a while.

    Crohn's Disease

    As Jet has mentioned, there are many testimonials of zerocarb alleviating Crohn's Disease, as well as many other gastro-intestinal conditions.

    anti-vegan

    It's the other way around, unfortunately, the vegans are anti-carnivore. We get people coming in here pushing "common sense" and "ethics", neither of which are actually scientifically backed or verifiable. Case in point, there is no scientific evidence for LDL being causal for heart disease.

    Carnivore is a community about health and primarily metabolic health, and I'm really glad that you're curious and asking questions.

    alkaline water

    That's another contentious subject that people who're anti-zerocarb like to bring up, but I agree with you - the body is fantastic at regulating itself and all we need to do is get out of its way.

    Jet has already described Tg/HDL and fasting insulin. You should be able to get the tests from your doctor, they're generally regularly available tests.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 3 child comments
  • [–] [S] 2 points 5 months ago (2 children)

    It’s the other way around, unfortunately, the vegans are anti-carnivore.

    It's kinda weird their identity is rooted in what other people do.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] 3 points 5 months ago (1 child)

    Tl:Dr I'm very skeptical of the carnivore/zerocarb diet, but I'm not here to argue I am just genuinely curious about it.

    I am going to have to disagree with you and @xep@discuss.online about the origins of carnivore. It did appear as a reaction to vegan prosteletyzing online, in my opinion, as an own to vegans.

    That said, I don't think that necessarily delegitimizes it if it turned out to be good for folks.

    And also, I do agree the vegans are quite obsessed with pushing vegan on folks. Completely transparently, I am convinced by their philosophy personally but I'm not a vegan myself. I'm just going vegetarian as part of a ritual I'm trying to perform for my friends wedding.

    I am genuinely curious and wanted to talked to zerocarb/carnivore diet practitioners because I do genuinely want to understand. Not to like argue against you or convince you otherwise. I'm not really the guy for that. It feels rude as hell to try and convince somebody who feels good health wise and attribute that to their diet that their diet is bad and wrong.

    I don't think I could practice carnivore personally because of my own experiential evidence and incredibly weird philosophical beliefs, but I'm still very interested in this basically brand new diet and community. I'd rather know it from real people practacicing than from characters like Liver King or Jordan Peterson who have done a lot of damage to the idea off the bat.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] [S] 3 points 5 months ago

    Tl:Dr I’m very skeptical of the carnivore/zerocarb diet, but I’m not here to argue I am just genuinely curious about it.

    You should be! Nutritional literature is very weak - for every diet, the most studied dietary intervention has been keto. The case and literature for keto is very strong. The literature for carnivore is weak, however, the advice to avoid meat and fat is even weaker. carnivore is a mechanistic upgrade of keto. People try it, and if works for them they keep doing it.

    I am going to have to disagree with you and @xep@discuss.online about the origins of carnivore. It did appear as a reaction to vegan prosteletyzing online, in my opinion, as an own to vegans.

    Humans have been eating meat since before recorded history (cave paintings of high fat animals and the like). Herodotus described meat only diets in 500 BCE. Inuit were documented in European literature in 1700s. zero-carb has been a documented medical treatment for type 2 diabetes since 1797, and let's not forget Banting in in the 1860s.

    That said, I don’t think that necessarily delegitimizes it if it turned out to be good for folks.

    Great, if it works it works, and if it doesn't work we should change. I totally agree with this philosophy

    Completely transparently, I am convinced by their philosophy personally but I’m not a vegan myself. I’m just going vegetarian as part of a ritual I’m trying to perform for my friends wedding.

    I have nothing but respect for people who make their life more difficult and trade health outcomes for a philosophical goal.

    I am genuinely curious and wanted to talked to zerocarb/carnivore diet practitioners because I do genuinely want to understand. Not to like argue against you or convince you otherwise. I’m not really the guy for that. It feels rude as hell to try and convince somebody who feels good health wise and attribute that to their diet that their diet is bad and wrong.

    We are pretty open, ask anything you like, feel free to poke holes in anything we present as well. We are not philosophical, we are experimental.

    I don’t think I could practice carnivore personally because of my own experiential evidence

    Let me guess, you went from the standard diet to more low fat plant based and saw benefits? That makes sense! Honestly, the standard western diet is so bad ANY dietary intervention does better. The major lever in that approach is reducing randle cycle inhibition, if you also removed processed food that is another big lever.

    However, for some people those two levers are not enough to get back to healthy symptom free life! Keto adds fat metabolism to the mix (no randle cycle, no processed food, ketone metabolism) - which is even more power. And honestly that's enough for most people. However, Carnivore gets to a subset of nutritionally complete food, simplifying the diet, and removing lots of variables, inflammatory compounds, and plant interactions - think of it as a very CLEAN version of keto.

    The only thing with more healing leverage than carnivore is fasting, but you can't fast forever - at some point you have to eat.

    incredibly weird philosophical beliefs

    No worries, we are here just to let you know of your options, and if you choose another path we are happy for you.

    I’d rather know it from real people practacicing than from characters like Liver King or Jordan Peterson who have done a lot of damage to the idea off the bat.

    The liver king is a influencer, not a doctor - he uses steroids and should not be considered a health role model. Jordan Peterson is famous part time user of zero-carb but he doesn't represent the ongoing research and given his other problems isn't a good health role model either.

    There are about 3-6 of us zero-carb carnivores here on lemmy, living the life day in and day out - ask away.

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] [S] 3 points 5 months ago* (last edited 5 months ago) (2 children)

    managing my own gastro disease (crohns).

    Are you aware Crohns is the flagship best use case of a carnivore diet? the stomach fully digests fat and protein allowing the intestines fully rest (kent carnivore has a colostomy bag and demonstrates this)

    feel a lot better

    If your feeling good, I don't think you need to change anything, carnivore is a tool if you need it, but not everybody needs it.

    I want to know more about pure carnivore, but there are people in my life a lot smarter than me who are medical professionals, I spend a lot of time with my own doctors because of my health issues, and by following their advice of a high plant diet I’ve felt a lot better.

    Fair enough, I'm happy to answer any questions you have.

    Is there somewhere to read more on it s benefits with even a tenantive medical backing? Something I, a simpleton, could veryify?

    That is the trouble, carnivore is very niche, so I can send you literature but it might be difficult to understand. like this one - Case report: Carnivore–ketogenic diet for the treatment of inflammatory bowel disease: a case series of 10 patients. For the most part the evidence with Crohn's is mostly case studies and testimonials.i.e.

    Basically people who tried it, and it worked for them.

    A lot of people I’ve met who were into carnivore just seemed to be anti-vegan and then working backwards to justify it.

    Not us zero carb carnivores. We are outcome based, if something works, do it! If it's good enough, don't change it. If the vegans are happy and healthy, great - I'm happy for them and I want to see their data. The only friction happens because they keep attacking our diet, but I truly am not bothered.

    Or they were folks trying to sell supplements so people on a carnivore diet could get all the nutrients that were being missed or likely just scamming them.

    Yeah, the fun thing about carnivore / ketogenic is you buy everything from your local grocery store, just replace carbs with fat. Some people need extra salt, but you can also get that at the store.

    The LDL thing seems good when a diet is well balanced and there’s all the benefits of the fiber, the nutrients, and the flavor it adds to food. I’m not convinced this is bad.

    Fair enough, there is lots of debate with doctors on both sides. I think its reasonable to say LDL in isolation is not a strong predictor of cardiovascular outcomes, metabolic health is (hypertension, hba1c, etc); when in doubt with a high LDL you can always get a CAC score to measure your 5 year risk if the score is zero then the concern for risk is moot.

    The body is quite complicated and capable of balancing out things at the individual nutrient issue. It makes me think of the alkaline water thing. Our bodies already balance the PH a lot. Drinking water that’s more basic than acidic doesn’t change much at all.

    Agreed on the complication, thats why zero-carb people just try to get the least complicated nutritionally complete state - remove all the variables make things simple. I've seen no supporting evidence for alkaline water having a benefit, your body regulates your PH very finely, this just makes pee expensive for no benefit.

    I have no idea what TG/HDL is let alone how to measure it.

    On your last lipid panel, the cholesterol panel, they give you different measurements TG (Triglycerides) and HDL (high dense lipoproteins) - if you take the TG number and divide it by the HDL number, that ratio gives you a pretty good approximate reading on how insulin sensitive your body is... i.e. your metabolic health. Since this is a test nearly everyone gets every year, its data you probably already have.

    What is a fasting insulin test?

    It measure the blood insulin levels directly (like a more accurate TG/HDL ratio), the less insulin your body needs to maintain baseline the healthier your metabolism is. Insulin is actually the main driver of most metabolic issues (Ben Bikman's book "Why we get sick" explains this really well in a easy to read format).

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] 3 points 5 months ago (1 child)

    I wrote a longer post replying to jet and I tagged you, but I really do appreciate the chat.

    I do appreciate you two responding to my push backs. I completely understand the hesitancy as the forum system is absolutely destroyed with sycophantic circle jerking or bad faith trolling. It makes skeptical but honest discussion really hard sometimes. And I am skeptical, to be clear, but I'd rather understand the best possible version of zerocarb before I make any moral or ethical claims. I'm not a nutritionist, so I cannot make effectiveness claims either way either. I can only speak on my experience.

    You have given me a lot to look over and I will look it over. I'll probably be back with some better thought out questions.

    Thanks again for being a good sport!

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] [S] 1 point 5 months ago

    best possible version of zerocarb

    Ruminant meat (red meat), salt, water - is the gold standard nutritionally complete "best possible" version of carnivore. Lots of people add in coffee/tea, spices etc. It's a spectrum, and since it's not a philosophy but a practice, it's about progress and outcomes not being perfect to a ideal. i.e. if you are getting the outcomes and health you want, keep doing whatever your doing.

    I’m not a nutritionist, so I cannot make effectiveness claims either way either.

    Nutritionists can't either, they are not researchers. Almost all nutrition accrediting organizations were founded by, or have significant ties to, philosophically plant based groups (7th day adventists are the largest).

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 3 points 5 months ago (10 children)

    What is an anti-nutrient?

    Also do those get transfered over in broth?

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 10 child comments
  • [–] 3 points 5 months ago (9 children)

    Phytic acid is one with a well known interaction with zinc: https://hero.epa.gov/reference/56527/

    Paper itself can be found here: https://bvssan.incap.int/local/I/I-1025.pdf

    As to whether it'll leech into soup, why risk it? It's a lot of work to make a good broth.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 9 child comments
  • [–] 2 points 5 months ago (8 children)

    That paper is useless to me. I'm not a food scientists or medical nutritionist.

    If its well known why aren't there regular sources to communicate the perks of this nocarb diet? Sources like mine. Meant for regular people who don't participate in the academics.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 8 child comments
  • [–] 3 points 5 months ago* (last edited 5 months ago) (5 children)

    The diet/lifestyle itself is not well known nor mainstream.

    Phytic acid's interaction with zinc is well understood. It's on Wikipedia:

    Phytic acid and phytate have a strong binding affinity to the dietary minerals calcium, iron, and zinc, inhibiting their absorption in the small intestine.

    Here's a chart from the paper I linked about zinc absorption:

    The chart describes the change in the amount of zinc in the blood of the subjects of the study, after they ate some oysters.

    After eating 120g of oysters and nothing else, plasma zinc peaks at ~150 ug/dl in 3 hours. If the oysters are eaten with black beans, it peaks at ~40 ug/dl, and if the oysters are eaten with tortillas it barely goes up above 0 at all!

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 5 child comments
  • [–] 3 points 5 months ago (4 children)

    I mean, its cool that we can measure such changes, but what does that mean for me?

    Why should I care about phytic acid and zinc interactions?

    Does a normal diet include enough phytic acid to cause problems in average people? I'm sure theres people who do benefit from reducing or eliminating it, but I'm not sure why I, an already healthy individual, should consider eliminating it as I feel fine and I eat corn and flour tortillas regularly.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 4 child comments
  • [–] [S] 2 points 5 months ago (2 children)

    I mean, its cool that we can measure such changes, but what does that mean for me?

    I’m not sure why I, an already healthy individual, should consider eliminating it as I feel fine and I eat corn and flour tortillas regularly.

    That is the key, if you are fully healthy then yeah - you don't need to change anything - you are fine.... but.... you mentioned you had Crohn's - is that fully in remission without flareups or medication? If not, then removing plants temporarily and seeing if your symptoms or health improves is a tool you should be aware of.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] 2 points 5 months ago (1 child)

    Fully in remission. Flair ups stopped with increasing fiber intake, avoiding grease, and red meats.

    In my experience the only thing that triggers a flair up is dropping my fiber regiment or consuming milk or soft cheeses. Well aged cheese and yogurt is fine.

    But that's me and my body. My fiance can't have fiber and has to greatly watch fat due to a different gastro issue called gastro paresis.

    We did actually do an elimination diet and they only ate chicken and steak for a week before we found slowly what carbs and veg we could add back in. We also found out that fatty steak wasn't good either, but we had like a dozen frozen steaks when the diagnosis came in.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] [S] 3 points 5 months ago

    Fully in remission. Flair ups stopped with increasing fiber intake, avoiding grease, and red meats.

    That is great! I'm glad your happy and healthy.

    In my experience the only thing that triggers a flair up is dropping my fiber regiment or consuming milk or soft cheeses. Well aged cheese and yogurt is fine.

    This makes sense, at least to my crazy brain -

    dropping fibre will reduce short chain fatty acid in the intestines (on keto/zero carb this isn't as issue as the fermented SCAs are replaced with whole body ketones which are more abundant and go to the whole body).

    Dairy has casomorphins, which will have a impact on gut motility.

    My fiance can’t have fiber and has to greatly watch fat due to a different gastro issue called gastro paresis.

    https://whycarnivore.com/#Gastroparesis

    The literature is light here as well, but testimonials are in abundance, and one imagines for the same reason IBD resolves - fat/protein fully resolve in the stomach resting the gut.

    We did actually do an elimination diet and they only ate chicken and steak for a week before we found slowly what carbs and veg we could add back in.

    Oh great! Then you already know everything you need to know about carnivore (though chicken might not be ideal).

    We also found out that fatty steak wasn’t good either, but we had like a dozen frozen steaks when the diagnosis came in.

    What was the issue with fatty steak? Was it only fatty steak for two weeks? From my understanding of typical gastroparesis protocols fat is reduced to increase gut motility, but on a zero-carb elimination diet there isn't fiber and carbohydrates in the gut anyway.

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 2 points 5 months ago*

    Without extrapolation, it means you shouldn't eat oysters with beans or tortillas.

    Does a normal diet include enough phytic acid to cause problems in average people?

    Since the required amount of tortillas is very small (120g), the answer is yes. And this is just one anti-nutrient, plants make a multitude of compounds, most of which we don't fully understand.

    In my opinion, best avoid all plants since they're unnecessary.

  • source
  • parent