Wonderful collagen!

Yes, some celery in the broth... still getting everyone onboard with no-plants. The person who added the celery into the broth doesn't even like celery, they were just following a guide. Baby steps.

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] 3 points 5 months ago (1 child)

Tl:Dr I'm very skeptical of the carnivore/zerocarb diet, but I'm not here to argue I am just genuinely curious about it.

I am going to have to disagree with you and @xep@discuss.online about the origins of carnivore. It did appear as a reaction to vegan prosteletyzing online, in my opinion, as an own to vegans.

That said, I don't think that necessarily delegitimizes it if it turned out to be good for folks.

And also, I do agree the vegans are quite obsessed with pushing vegan on folks. Completely transparently, I am convinced by their philosophy personally but I'm not a vegan myself. I'm just going vegetarian as part of a ritual I'm trying to perform for my friends wedding.

I am genuinely curious and wanted to talked to zerocarb/carnivore diet practitioners because I do genuinely want to understand. Not to like argue against you or convince you otherwise. I'm not really the guy for that. It feels rude as hell to try and convince somebody who feels good health wise and attribute that to their diet that their diet is bad and wrong.

I don't think I could practice carnivore personally because of my own experiential evidence and incredibly weird philosophical beliefs, but I'm still very interested in this basically brand new diet and community. I'd rather know it from real people practacicing than from characters like Liver King or Jordan Peterson who have done a lot of damage to the idea off the bat.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] [S] 3 points 5 months ago

    Tl:Dr I’m very skeptical of the carnivore/zerocarb diet, but I’m not here to argue I am just genuinely curious about it.

    You should be! Nutritional literature is very weak - for every diet, the most studied dietary intervention has been keto. The case and literature for keto is very strong. The literature for carnivore is weak, however, the advice to avoid meat and fat is even weaker. carnivore is a mechanistic upgrade of keto. People try it, and if works for them they keep doing it.

    I am going to have to disagree with you and @xep@discuss.online about the origins of carnivore. It did appear as a reaction to vegan prosteletyzing online, in my opinion, as an own to vegans.

    Humans have been eating meat since before recorded history (cave paintings of high fat animals and the like). Herodotus described meat only diets in 500 BCE. Inuit were documented in European literature in 1700s. zero-carb has been a documented medical treatment for type 2 diabetes since 1797, and let's not forget Banting in in the 1860s.

    That said, I don’t think that necessarily delegitimizes it if it turned out to be good for folks.

    Great, if it works it works, and if it doesn't work we should change. I totally agree with this philosophy

    Completely transparently, I am convinced by their philosophy personally but I’m not a vegan myself. I’m just going vegetarian as part of a ritual I’m trying to perform for my friends wedding.

    I have nothing but respect for people who make their life more difficult and trade health outcomes for a philosophical goal.

    I am genuinely curious and wanted to talked to zerocarb/carnivore diet practitioners because I do genuinely want to understand. Not to like argue against you or convince you otherwise. I’m not really the guy for that. It feels rude as hell to try and convince somebody who feels good health wise and attribute that to their diet that their diet is bad and wrong.

    We are pretty open, ask anything you like, feel free to poke holes in anything we present as well. We are not philosophical, we are experimental.

    I don’t think I could practice carnivore personally because of my own experiential evidence

    Let me guess, you went from the standard diet to more low fat plant based and saw benefits? That makes sense! Honestly, the standard western diet is so bad ANY dietary intervention does better. The major lever in that approach is reducing randle cycle inhibition, if you also removed processed food that is another big lever.

    However, for some people those two levers are not enough to get back to healthy symptom free life! Keto adds fat metabolism to the mix (no randle cycle, no processed food, ketone metabolism) - which is even more power. And honestly that's enough for most people. However, Carnivore gets to a subset of nutritionally complete food, simplifying the diet, and removing lots of variables, inflammatory compounds, and plant interactions - think of it as a very CLEAN version of keto.

    The only thing with more healing leverage than carnivore is fasting, but you can't fast forever - at some point you have to eat.

    incredibly weird philosophical beliefs

    No worries, we are here just to let you know of your options, and if you choose another path we are happy for you.

    I’d rather know it from real people practacicing than from characters like Liver King or Jordan Peterson who have done a lot of damage to the idea off the bat.

    The liver king is a influencer, not a doctor - he uses steroids and should not be considered a health role model. Jordan Peterson is famous part time user of zero-carb but he doesn't represent the ongoing research and given his other problems isn't a good health role model either.

    There are about 3-6 of us zero-carb carnivores here on lemmy, living the life day in and day out - ask away.

  • source
  • parent