You have indeed read a bunch, but I'm not sure if you see the bias. They all already share the conclusion.
I realize I'm shouting into the wind here as it's the internet, but I'd ask to add three books to your book list. These three come at the question from different angles and don't all agree with each other, which is kind of the point.
- The Hungry Brain - Stephan Guyenet (2017)
- Spoon-Fed - Tim Spector (2020)
- Fiber Fueled - Will Bulsiewicz (2020)
There are some articles I would suggest you could read in leui of the books:
https://www.stephanguyenet.com/nutrition-science-initiative-nusi-in-retrospect/
This one in particular is interesting as it regards Gary Taubes, who you seem to favor, and the organization he create and which rebutted his conclusions.
The first study NuSI funded was a meticulous eight-week pilot trial, led by Hall, to see if a very-low-carbohydrate (ketogenic) diet causes a meaningful increase in calorie expenditure vs. a calorie-matched standard American diet with more than tenfold the sugar. Volunteers were kept in a research facility where every morsel they ate was controlled. The study design was agreed upon in advance by both the researchers and NuSI, and the diets were designed by low-carbohydrate diet researcher Jeff Volek, PhD, RD. According to Taubes, calorie intake is virtually irrelevant and insulin is everything, so his hypothesis predicts large and obvious differences in calorie expenditure and fat loss between diet periods, despite equal calories. The results showed little effect of the ketogenic diet on calorie expenditure, and an initial slowing of fat loss, despite a large and persistent decline in insulin secretion.
This one directly takes down some of the underlying carb insulin model.
And this well publized and reviewed study of inpatient controlled diets. The low-fat group spontaneously ate about 700 fewer calories per day. This is directly at odds with what your matrix predicts. Hall et al., Nature Medicine (2021)
Having said all of this, I'm entirely in favor of deep dives into topics. I appreciate that you have done some extensive reading if it is fairly narrow. Keep at it and keep learning!