why-the-carbohydrate-insulin-model-of-obesity-is-probably-wrong-a-supplementary-reply-to-ebbeling-and-ludwigs-jama-article/
First things first: this article is from 2018. We have a better understanding of the field of metabolic health now, and all the advancements point towards the fact that the insulin model is a better model for dietary outcomes than the caloric model.
I invite you to look up various resources to see that what I am saying is not just an vacuous assertion. Perhaps you could start with the Low Carb Down Under conference, and in particular if you're curious about insulin I would recommend Prof. Bikman's material.
Having prefaced my position with that, let me put down some of my thoughts with regards to the points that Guyenet makes:
- Dietary fat can be fattening
This is not irreconcilable with the insulin model as Guyenet asserts. When consuming a mixed diet of all three macronutrients (fat, carbohydrates, and protein), the Randle Cycle is activated. There is a cross-inhibition of the metabolism of glucose and fat.
This results in mitochondrial dysfunction since both glucose and fatty acids flood the system, resulting in production of reactive oxygen species, glycation, and lipid metabolites. This reduces the effectiveness of insulin signalling in the body, and is in part the cause of metabolic syndrome.
See: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC2739696/ for details.
Guyenet appears to be entirely unaware of the existence of the Randle Cycle.
- Kitavans
The Kitavan diet of just starchy root vegetables avoids Randle cycle activation. The very same observation is made by Dr. Chris Knobbes in his talk about seed oils, about the Tukisenta who eat more than 90% of their diet in sweet potatoes.
However, the Tukisenta have poor dental conditions and commonly suffer from arthritis. Dr. Knobbes attributes this to poor availability fat soluble vitamins, in particular A and K2.
- Japan
In the postwar period the Japanese had no access to meat, and were eating a low fat high carbohydrate diet, once again avoiding Randle Cycle activation. Modern Japan, eating a mixed standard diet, suffers from the same metabolically associated chronic diseases as all western nations. There is little difference in the amount of dietary carbohydrates consumed in the modern Japanese diet from the west, although the Japanese do eat less ultra-processed food than the Americans, which would explain their reduced incidence of chronic disease.
Guyenet often confuses correlation with causation.
- Mouse studies
We aren't mice!
But even in mice, FIRKO mice actually support the insulin model. When insulin is unable to act on fat cells, fat accumulation is prevented. This is strong evidence that insulin signalling in adipose tissue is required for fat accumulation.
Guyenet's assertion that the brain drives obesity does not exclude nor refute the downstream mechanism of insulin.
- Acipimox
Acipimox isn't insulin!
As a result, we do not know if it fully replicates insulin's effects, and cannot claim that it does. This invalidates Guyenet's assertion. Additionally, it is only one study, and hence cannot be extrapolated to the population in general.
I am unable to access the rest of the study, but would also consider the following factors if I could: the term of the study, the follow-up period, the sample size, and confounding factors such as compensatory metabolic mechanisms in the body.
I could go on and address things like the false dichotomies Guyenet makes against the insulin model or his overemphasis on calories (a calorie isn't a calorie, see the other posts in this community) but I'm sure you've noticed that already since you also critically read papers that support your position :)
I hope that you continue to engage in good faith and not presume that we are ignoring bias. I think I speak on behalf of everyone on Lemmy when I say that condescension detracts from all our communities.