I’m not sure if you see the bias. They all already share the conclusion.
I absolutely see the bias, but that is why i read the original papers when i can. I read extensively, and I hope broadly, but of course you and I both have our biases.
This one in particular is interesting as it regards Gary Taubes, who you seem to favor, and the organization he create and which rebutted his conclusions.
I don't feel the need to defend Taubes, he is more then capable of defending himself. If you want to talk about a specific paper saying fibre is a essential nutrient I'll read it
https://doi.org/10.3945/ajcn.116.133561 - Energy expenditure and body composition changes after an isocaloric ketogenic diet in overweight and obese men
If we look at the study it was only a 4 week intervention - It takes about 12 weeks to get fully fat adapted, ketones were not measured, but you don't have to take my word for it!
https://doi.org/10.3945/ajcn.116.142182 - Raising the bar on the low-carbohydrate diet - In a direct response to Hall's paper
According to the clinical trials registry, this study was designated a pilot, presumably with the aim of acquiring preliminary data for a future study. By definition, pilot studies are not powered to make precise estimates of effect sizes or rigorously test a hypothesis. Thus, it is surprising that the authors dismissed the importance of the primary outcome: an increase in energy expenditure on the KD on the basis of 2 independent state-of-the-art methods. A fairer interpretation would be to reject the null hypothesis (i.e., all calories are alike from a metabolic perspective)—a remarkable finding for a pilot.
the pilot study likely underestimated the true effect of the KD because of several fundamental methodologic limitations, most importantly the nonrandomized (technically observational) design. Because the baseline diet was given first to all participants, any factor that changes with time could confound outcomes.
In addition, the protocol failed to measure energy losses from ketones and fat in the breath, urine, and stool, which would have been greater when consuming the KD.
metabolic chamber respirometry was shown to be inferior to doubly labeled water in the detection of adaptive thermogenesis, according to a comparative study involving several coauthors of the present investigation (6). Therefore, the doubly labeled water measurements collected during the final 2 wk of the assessment period flatly contradict the authors’ inferences about time course.
the authors overinterpret the initial reduced rate of change in fat mass after initiation of the KD. For individuals who habitually consume a high-carbohydrate diet, it may take several weeks for fat oxidation to reach steady state after they increase fat intake (9, 10). Although disregarded, their data actually support this possibility, with an apparent acceleration in fat-mass loss in the final 2 wk of the KD (as visually demonstrated in Figure 2B of the study).
The conventional “calories in, calories out” approach to obesity has been largely unsuccessful in practice throughout the last 40 y, as evidenced by the continuing high prevalence rates and the difficulty of most individuals in maintaining weight loss over the long term. The carbohydrate-insulin model proposes an alternative approach to obesity treatment that is based on considerable theoretical and clinical data. Properly controlled and adequately powered randomized controlled trials are urgently needed to test this model.
https://doi.org/10.1038/s41591-020-01209-1 - Effect of a plant-based, low-fat diet versus an animal-based, ketogenic diet on ad libitum energy intake
This paper isn't open access, so I can't read it directly - would you mind sharing it with me so I can actually respond in detail?
I can see from the abstract the crossover design without adequate adaptation/washout window - Rapid diet switching can produce carryover effects; metabolic and hormonal adaptations require time. Short periods bias results against low-carb/keto when no keto-adaptation phase is allowed. (same issue as with the above paper on cico)
Since the Hall paper isn't open access, but Soto's response is, let's dive into the identified issue with Halls second CICO paper: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tjnut.2023.12.017 - Physiologic Adaptation to Macronutrient Change Distorts Findings from Short Dietary Trials: Reanalysis of a Metabolic Ward Study
We found that energy intake on the LCD was much lower when this diet was consumed first compared with second (a difference of −1164 kcal/d, P = 3.6 × 10-13); the opposite pattern was observed for the LFD (924 kcal/d, P = 2.0 × 10-16). This carry-over effect was significant (P interaction = 0.0004) whereas the net dietary effect was not (P = 0.4). Likewise, the between-arm difference (LCD - LFD) was −320 kcal/d in the first period and +1771 kcal/d in the second. Body fat decreased with consumption of the LCD first and increased with consumption of this diet second (−0.69 ± 0.33 compared with 0.57 ± 0.32 kg, P = 0.007). LCD-first participants had higher β-hydroxybutyrate levels while consuming the LCD and lower respiratory quotients while consuming LFD when compared with LFD-first participants on their respective diets. Change in insulin secretion as assessed by C-peptide in the first diet period predicted higher energy intake and less fat loss in the second period. These findings, which tend to support rather than oppose the CIM, suggest that differential (unequal) carry-over effects and short duration, with no washout period, preclude causal inferences regarding chronic macronutrient effects from this trial.
Two papers from Hall in a row, I think Hall has a bias too!
What I think is demonstrated here is that CICO has not been proven by Hall, and the Carbohydrate Insulin Model still stands viable. Clean studies will be most welcome here. I can point you at interesting hypercaloric feeding case series where we see a strong signal of the CIM!
Update - I saw that WALTER WILLET, the man himself, called this study "worse then useless because its misleading"...... If Walter Willet the king of weak epidemiology is against you..... man.... you got problems. https://youtu.be/tIPX_TnUAWQ - I'd really love to read this full paper!
I'm a little confused first you discussed fibre, and the main thrust of your last post was about CICO. Could we limit each thread to a single topic so our goal posts don't get moved around too much.
I’m entirely in favor of deep dives into topics. I appreciate that you have done some extensive reading if it is fairly narrow. Keep at it and keep learning!
Fantastic, me too, I'm wrong about many things. Please don't be arrogant and diminish my reading of the literature through negative framing such as "extensive reading if it is fairly narrow". I actually read quite a lot of papers for and against my positions. If you only know one side of a argument, you don't know much. No need for sniping here, we can all be friendly. I could use the same to describe your positions, but I don't - I entertain the possibility I'm wrong - I hope you can offer me the same grace going forward.
Keep at it and keep learning
You too buddy, you too.