The problem with Vance is that people don't actually like him at all. Even conservatives I talk to say he skeeves them out. Everybody seems to recognize that he's a political snake with no real true convictions or principals, he says whatever he needs to in the moment to get a step ahead.
Trump has a certain turn of phrase and flavor of charisma that seems to resonate with at least a third of the country at any given time. Vance does not, he's awkward in face to face settings and generally comes off as a big dork. I don't know that Vance can command the same loyalty in his party, much less his voting base. There will hopefully be enough cracks in the party and enough blood in the water to make things really messy on that side of the aisle.