First of all, fuck the health insurance companies. Let them die.
While I agree with the sentiment and your point would be met in an ideal society, we live in a post-Citizens United world. So, we have to ask ourselves what is the most practicable way to get to universal health insurance today? Taking a position that the established industry would spend ungodly sums to resist? Or, do we insentivise the establishment to go along with the care plan in a manner that they could swallow (read as keep their hordes of money and still subsist today)?
Also, keep in mind, a lot of the industry has a lot of employees around the country. If you were a politician who wanted to get re-elected, what would be the best political history to have? One where you voted to kill an industry that put so many people (read as "voters") out of work? Or, one that gave health insurance to the populace in a way that had them retain their jobs, more or less?
My suggestion was lets get all just get to the first step and secure the universal health insurance first, and then worry about the vested interests AFTER we get the universal insurance. I mean, look at how society reacted when the ACA was being considered. The insurance industry exploded and whipped the populace into a frenzy.
The insurance industry is caustic to society. But, if a legislator took on the cause of killing such a profitable industry in post-Citizens United world, the industry will drop a banker’s truck on them to ensure that their reelection campaign won’t go through. They did that when the ACA was first being considered, didn’t give up after a watered down version was passed, and it’s a hill the Republican party is still willing to die on years later because they’re supported by the insurance i