Oh, it's you again.
comments
Facedeer, don't be a troll. You know that when people criticize AI, they aren't talking about speech-to-text .
The transcript is what the AI would be basing its summary off of.
Many of those transcripts are, themselves, generated by AI.
It doesn't, and YouTube already has an AI-free way of finding stuff in videos. It's called the transcript.
I can see the appeal but I wouldn't trust it.
Related thought: I despise how much stuff is made into video when a few paragraphs, maybe with a gif, would do just fine.
I don't know if this particular sidebar handles it, but AI summaries of youtube videos save a huge amount of time. Especially when I'm only interested in one specific bit that's buried somewhere in an hour of other stuff.
They said, on Lemmy.
Yes, they said on Lemmy. I solidly understand what it is to be in many tiny, insulated ideological minorities from decades of experience, namely that my experience is often profoundly different from most peoples'. Corporations are obviously inducing demand for large AI models, but I do speak to many people outside my anti-LLM bubble and rub up against the reality that people fucking love to use LLMs to (as an example from the OP) summarize everything for them. So many people I speak to are so fucking brainrotted from using LLMs as a crutch that they'll whine that like 300 words, for a thing they asked to have explained for them, is too long and needs a summary.
Chrome is literally worse than stock Firefox. You seem pretty out of touch with what we're talking about rn.
Yeah, I'm not going to waste my time with this one.
Also non-generative translation has existed for years just fine, just saying lol.
I have no idea what the hell you mean by "non-generative". Do you even know whay that word means? I see now that one was introduced in late 2023 and I was unaware of it. But what makes this one "generative" and that one "non-generative"? It's all tokens to tokens, regardless of if it's an LSTM (I don't know if that's what that one used) or a GPT (which I vaguely assume Firefox uses now, and is a generative pretrained transformer, but that's not really the job it's doing here; maybe a BERT? Maybe an LSTM still?)
We can actually say pretty concretely that a long page cannot be summed up by the LLM, because that is a limitation Mozilla themselves disclosed!
Up to 3,000 words with iPhone 15 Pro or later... Up to 5,000 words with other devices
If only there were ways to skim or scan text to get an idea of what it says.
I knew what you meant, to be clear. I was taking the piss.
driving people away from using stock firefox in the first place.
I cannot even express what a tiny, insulated minority that you're in. A lack of these kinds of features is what would drive people away to Chrome. Like holy merciful hell, Firefox's new LLM page translation is jank, but it's something (this is the one feature I use; it's local when you download the language pack, and my alternative would be using Argos locally – more accurate, but slow as hell and less convenient).
I cannot begin to tell you all the times I wished I had what Chrome had in the way of translation – just without the privacy concerns. I only didn't switch because of a strong resolve; I read non-English articles all the time. It's still not as good, but I'm so relieved to finally have a built-in, private translator. And I'm well on the "fuck the proliferation of LLMs" side of the spectrum.
And I can very well imagine those features I turn off because I don't want them are to a lot of people what translation was to me.
Why would someone want a page summarized?
If it's short, just read it.
If it's long, the LLM will probably fuck it up.
They're really going after the illiterate and lazy segment.
I'm sorry the Block AI enhancements toggle is impossible for you to find. I hope you'll find it easier once you sober up a bit.
No worries, I'm aware, I've just decided to stick with the defaults (on this profile) to get an idea what the average user will see, and when, and how often.
There's the block AI enhancement switch in the settings, should get rid of all this.
This is something there's an easy-to-find toggle for in the settings. A lot of people use LLM shit, and I'm in the minority – even, I'm sure, among Firefox users – so I'm not going to gripe that I have to switch it off to never be bugged about it again. (Most of these, by the way, are one-time prompts IIRC.)
Firefox does two things that are still really important, and I think the combination is unique to FF:
- Promises to (and sometimes does) make ethical improvements to the browsing ecosystem
- Gets forked into browsers that are usable by the general public
Mozilla has been captured completely already, the new bosses are just turning up the heat slowly in an attempt to not scare too many users away. Im still gonna use a firefox fork for now but there is no future for mozilla unless some heads roll in their management.
Many prompts to use AI pop up during conventional usage. This is the most egregious so far, but here is another (whenever you try putting tabs in a group).

Here is another (when Firefox could be loading provided page summaries, per Mozilla:

Here is another: the Perplexity search engine received special advertising after it was added.


It's related to Firefox, and Firefox VPN is a Firefox feature. It does not apply to Mozilla VPN, which links to a separate policy from its home page, which indeed does mention Mullvad.
And no, you never consciously initiated a service agreement with Fastly, and so its policy doesn't apply. The policy of the service you choose to use applies, this doesn't have to be difficult.
I saw that. That doesn't help because there's no detail on what the policy does! Are they even applicable, ie how about those seven years of data retention? How about everything Fastly says they store?
If you click through, you'll find no concrete answer, just a list of three vague categories of data Mozilla says Fastly gets.
- Browsing data
- Technical data (including IP address)
- Unique identifiers
What does this entail?
Is it actually related to the VPN and not other Mozilla-Fastly services (e.g. usage data collection)?
If this applies to VPNs, why isn't Mullvad mentioned on the page?
When it comes to privacy policies, these things are written by lawyers. It's dangerous to assume pure intent from a corporation. Should we really read the Fastly privacy policy - the service you connect to - and assume that it doesn't apply to us because we're using a certain browser to access it?
I'm not going to crawl through the notices now, but e.g. the Firefox Privacy Policy says:
To perform the purposes listed above, we work with partners, service providers, suppliers and contractors. We have contractual protections in place, so that the entities receiving personal data are contractually obligated to handle the data in accordance with Mozilla’s instructions. Learn more.
This includes Fastly (see also the Learn more link). That is the policy that applies, not Fastly's own policy.
macOS Nightly now has support for sharing the current tab’s URL via QR Code (Right-click tab, Share > Generate QR Code)
Confused about why only MacOS? But okay. One more extension that's migrated into the browser (I am now team Code All Exensions Directly Into Firefox, security and bloat be damned)
Special thanks to volunteer contributor 1justinpeter who just added speed unit conversion support to the AwesomeBar!
This is actually pretty useful especially because people already use search engines for this, but now it can skip the server.
Calculator next?
New Tab Sections have been enabled by default in Canada!
Gross. This is the ever-expanding "news" section that's slowly transitioning into content indistinguishable from ads. They killed Pocket to make this.
Important distinction: Mozilla is talking about their part in collecting data here. "We collect." They aren't claiming to be Fastly or to represent their privacy policy.
When you use their paid VPN, they refer to their partner Mullvad specifically. There is no clarity about the third party in their free VPN, nor any clarity about what Mozilla shares with them... Only that Mozilla claims it's necessary.
Or whether it falls under Mozilla sharing that data at all, since you are the one initiating the requests to Fastly's servers in American jurisdiction! What is your computer's relationship with fastly-masque.net when you connect to it? Even the Invisiv VPN service intentionally hid things from it, but Fastly is the exclusive proxy for web browsing on Firefox VPN.