[–] 3 points 1 week ago* (last edited 1 week ago) (3 children)

It's ok to fundamentally disagree with someone and still be civil and polite when speaking with them.

It's ok not to win a discussion, just participate until it doesn't bring you joy, then stop.

Lemmy, and the fediverse, is stronger with diverse people, opinions, communities - even if you disagree with them. Even normies of mainstream political parties you disagree with.

Downvotes are not a disagree button. Lemmy is not training a personal algorithm to provide a echo chamber, downvotes should mean content is harmful to the community its in.

  • source
  • [–] 3 points 1 week ago

    They also resemble vegan diets in how certain proponents seem to be on a mission to promote them.

    Pretty much any eating pattern other then the standard western diet will see improvements, people get excited about a tool that fixed whatever problem they had.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] [S] 3 points 2 weeks ago

    This interview really spoke to me, it explains the journey so well, its crazy, but maybe ill try it, oh shit - it actually works, and all these other things got fixed to.... now I sound crazy.

  • source
  • [–] 2 points 2 weeks ago* (2 children)

    Yup! no such thing as a carbohydrate deficiency, its in the foundational literature as you demonstrated, yet somehow that gets lost on the way to the food pyramid

    You might also enjoy this paper

    Application of nutrient essentiality criteria to dietary carbohydrates - https://doi.org/10.1017/S0954422420000050

    Although sources of dietary carbohydrates can provide beneficial micronutrients, no signs of micronutrient deficiencies have been reported in clinical trials of low-carbohydrate ketogenic diets.

    They also have a great writeup on fibre

    The National Academy of Medicine defines dietary fibre as intact plant non-digestible carbohydrates, functional fibre as isolated non-digestible carbohydrates that have beneficial effects in humans, and total fibre as the sum of dietary fibre and functional fibre(1,Reference Otten, Hellwig and Meyers31) . Dietary and functional fibre are not essential nutrients, so potential health benefits were instead used to determine the recommended intake

  • source
  •  

    In this episode of The Feldman Protocol, how should researchers and clinicians weigh insulin resistance against lipid markers when assessing cardiovascular risk? Dave Feldman sits down with Sameer Dossani (PhD, anthropology; health coach specializing in autoimmune and gut conditions) to explore human evolutionary dietary history, the origins of metabolic disease across ancient cultures, the lean mass hypersponder phenotype and ketone production, challenges in science communication, and the role of AI in personalized health.

    generated summary

    Personal history and the turn toward nutrition (01:05-14:40)

    • My health coaching centers on autoimmune disease, especially gut conditions; a recently completed anthropology PhD and personal history shape this approach.
    • A South Asian Khoja Ismaili family history runs through Gujarat, Calcutta and modern Bangladesh; the 1971 war preceded the family's long residence in the US and a Washington, DC, childhood.
    • Human origins are African, with migrations out of Africa tens of thousands of years ago; mixed South Asian ancestry and a trading family history illustrate human mobility.
    • An unhappy elite-school experience preceded university in Canada, philosophy and religion studies, participation in punk and vegan communities, and activism against international economic institutions.
    • Roughly two decades in international economics and NGOs, including ActionAid, involved work across several countries; the 2015 move to South Africa, layoffs, and family health problems led toward doctoral work and health coaching.
    • Medical-library reading contradicted earlier beliefs about plant-based nutrition; repeated failure to correct medical and dietary advice became more troubling than isolated error.
    • Entrenched training, institutional incentives, and inherited assumptions can perpetuate a hypothesis despite contrary data, without requiring a coordinated group of individuals.

    Diabetes before modern dietary guidelines (14:40-25:05)

    • Medical training depends heavily on memorization, while anthropology and philosophy of science add questions about the origins and historical development of medical ideas.
    • Ancient Indian descriptions of madhumeha associated diabetes with sweet urine and carbohydrate restriction; Chinese medical advice attributed to Sun Simiao also included avoidance of carbohydrates and alcohol.
    • Carbohydrate restriction has a long history in diabetes care; modern diabetes organizations have also supported carbohydrate-inclusive diets and invoked the brain's carbohydrate requirements.
    • A childhood type 1 diabetes diagnosis in North Africa or West Asia involved immediate restriction of bread, an emphasis on meat and above-ground vegetables, and concurrent insulin therapy.
    • Carbohydrate restriction for children with type 1 diabetes can provoke concerns over social inclusion and quality of life, alongside the practice of dosing insulin for carbohydrate-containing foods.
    • Food pleasure, social convenience and disease prevention can pull in different directions; a culturally popular food can still aggravate an existing health condition.

    Comfort foods, ancestral diets and evolutionary hypotheses (25:05-48:30)

    • Concern about eating disorders can lead to broad acceptance of every food; differentiating highly processed food-like substances from traditional foods is distinct from viewing all restrictions as disordered.
    • A doughnut is a modern comfort food, not an ancestral necessity; enjoyment, dietary balancing and family tradition do not establish a health benefit.
    • Highly rewarding processed foods and widespread social participation normalize consumption, with historical parallels to the social acceptance of smoking.
    • Blood-pressure concerns coexist with strong family and Bangladeshi sweet-food traditions; allulose and homemade lower-carbohydrate ice cream are practical ways to accommodate these habits.
    • Human brain expansion and a smaller gut began roughly 1.3-1.5 million years ago; cooking and greater consumption of animal fat are two explanations, while securely dated fire use occurs later in this chronology.
    • Evolutionary diets provide the starting hypothesis; modern hunter-gatherer dietary variety supports a generalist model, while a specialist model centers large, fatty prey.
    • [1] A July archaeological analysis across the Americas yields estimates of roughly 90-99% or more of edible animal biomass from megafauna; mammoths and other large prey anchor the specialist-hunter model.
    • Megafaunal extinction around 12,000 years ago may have forced dietary diversification; the specialist-hunter account remains a working hypothesis about prehistory.
    • Human gut proportions, stomach acidity, forward-facing eyes and sweating are compatible with a meat-oriented evolutionary account; persistence hunting among modern San communities can also have ritual or tourist functions.
    • The evolutionary loss of fur and reliance on sweating increased the importance of skin pigmentation; melanin offers solar protection, while lighter skin supports vitamin D production under weaker sunlight.

    Famine cuisine, dietary dependence and communication (48:30-01:03:00)

    • Stress encourages self-soothing through food and other comforts; older recipes differ from modern products, and a diet useful during famine need not optimize health during abundance.
    • Repeated South Asian famines under British rule form part of the history of inherited susceptibilities and starch-centered food customs, complicating current dietary change.
    • Sweet cravings and prior stress can persist during dietary change; coffee and lower-carbohydrate substitutes can displace other foods, while a Quest cookie and eggs differ nutritionally and emotionally.
    • Public communication connecting metabolic health with the 2020 infectious-disease crisis encountered platform restrictions; earlier videos were deleted after channel growth stalled, and roughly one in nine podcast episodes required removal from YouTube.
    • Metabolic health was a correlate of severity and outcome during the infectious-disease crisis; opportunities for preventive dialogue existed amid polarized public reactions.
    • Scientific uncertainty requires precise language; the evolutionary dietary model is a revisable starting hypothesis, and public audiences can imitate incidental choices such as diet soda or snack foods.

    Veganism, personal illness and LDL (01:03:00-01:22:50)

    • Veganism began around age 18 within a Montreal punk community, followed by ethical, environmental and health commitments; eggs and dairy entered the diet later, with intermittent returns to vegan eating.
    • Vitiligo stabilized during part of the vegan period, while asthma did not improve alongside smoking; a vegetarian pregnancy was complicated by gestational diabetes.
    • By 2015-2016, a largely plant-based diet coincided with knee pain, reduced night vision, severe reactions to milk, very low vitamin D, HbA1c around 6.5 and weight gain; other family members also had health problems.
    • South African interest in Banting and Tim Noakes revived an earlier conflict between carbohydrate-centered and dietary-fat-centered explanations of metabolic illness.
    • [2] A Gerald Reaven study separated participants by measured insulin resistance; clinical events clustered in the most insulin-resistant group, with none in the least-resistant group, while LDL had little discriminatory value within that analysis.
    • Initial changes included elimination of seed oils, a five-day water fast, carbohydrate restriction, sun exposure and greater intake of animal foods; that abrupt sequence is not suitable for unprepared imitation.
    • Weight fell from roughly 98 to 78 kg, with improvements in vitamin D and other measures; LDL increased to roughly 350 mg/dL and later above 400, creating concern despite concurrent improvements.
    • A CAC score of zero and improved well-being coexist with markedly elevated LDL; the preferred starting point is physiological adaptation and evidence of disease rather than an isolated laboratory value.
    • LDL responses to ketogenic eating vary even within a family; substantial subjective gains can bias interpretation of a laboratory marker moving in an unfavorable direction.
    • [3] The identical-twin vegan-versus-omnivorous trial used LDL as its main outcome and found a between-group difference of roughly 14 mg/dL, a modest absolute change given its prominence in public debate.
    • Work on religious influence within dietetics associations offers one explanation for persistence of plant-based assumptions; much nutritional epidemiology has small effect estimates and possible confounding.

    Epidemiology, anomalies and unreleased trial data (01:22:50-01:41:15)

    • [4] Bradford Hill's 1965 causality criteria include strength of association; doubling the relative risk of a rare disease can yield a small absolute increase.
    • Relative risks around 1.15 often underpin headlines about meat and cancer; observational associations are useful for generating hypotheses without automatically establishing causation.
    • Nurses' Health Study and Physicians' Health Study dietary analyses use questionnaire-based dietary intake and face healthy-user confounding through smoking, alcohol, exercise and related behaviors.
    • [5] A Harvard doctoral analysis found an inverse association between ice-cream consumption and cardiovascular outcomes among people with diabetes, complicating attempts to isolate benefits of yogurt.
    • The ice-cream association could involve dairy fat, intake-recording behavior, confounding or chance; post hoc analyses can preserve a favored yogurt hypothesis without resolving the anomaly.
    • [6][7] Chris Ramsden reanalyzed recovered Minnesota Coronary Experiment and Sydney Diet Heart Study data; an original investigator withheld findings because the results were unwelcome.
    • Incomplete publication of unfavorable trial findings undermines trust in nutrition research; falsifiable hypotheses, attempts at disproof and publication of negative results are central to scientific practice.
    • [8] Metformin's interference with resistance-training muscle gains preceded a reversal in Peter Attia's personal use; confidence in earlier pharmaceutical interventions warrants scrutiny alongside willingness to update them.
    • LDL goals often sit below the levels common in adults, sometimes with recommendations for early lowering; LDL had been mildly elevated even during a vegan diet and could be lowered with oatmeal.
    • A large breakfast of oats, berries and honey preceded disabling hunger during tennis and a second large meal; dietary LDL reduction can coexist with undesirable glucose and appetite effects in insulin resistance.
    • The full effects of an intervention matter beyond one biomarker; better LDL values can coexist with worsening glycemic control and other health indicators.

    Medical institutions and the KETO-CTA results (01:41:15-02:08:30)

    • Professional guidelines carry institutional authority, while the term fad diet can dismiss patient-led dietary changes undertaken after unsatisfactory diabetes management.
    • Ketosis probably occurred repeatedly during human history under limited food availability; modern highly processed diets are more novel than periodic ketosis.
    • A physician initially concerned about LDL later adopted low-carbohydrate eating; other doctors in the practice also changed habits, illustrating shifts in clinical assumptions through experience.
    • [9] The KETO baseline analysis compared carbohydrate-restricted people with high LDL and favorable HDL and triglycerides against matched Miami Heart participants; this phenotype differs from insulin-resistant atherogenic dyslipidemia.
    • [10] The longitudinal KETO-CTA analysis found an association of baseline plaque with later progression but no within-cohort association of LDL or ApoB with progression; average LDL was roughly 254 mg/dL following years of elevation.
    • Lean mass hyper-responders are increasingly recognized in clinical practice but remain heterogeneous, with some individuals developing plaque or faster progression.
    • [11] PARADIGM linked annualized percent atheroma volume growth around or above 1% to higher event risk; average progression was about 0.93% in event cases and 0.32% without events.
    • In KETO-CTA, 21% under QAngio and 29% under HeartFlow exceeded the 1% threshold, while median progression was about 0.23% and 0.27%; individual outcomes cannot be inferred from the cohort median.
    • A model in which cumulative ApoB exposure alone predicts individual plaque progression is incompatible with the absence of a direct ApoB-progression association within this cohort; additional factors remain relevant.
    • [12] Maasai observations in George Mann's research include low recognized coronary mortality alongside arterial plaques at autopsy; plaque burden and clinical events are distinct outcomes.
    • Insulin resistance changes HDL, triglycerides and LDL particle patterns while influencing cardiovascular risk, creating confounding in simple LDL-outcome associations.
    • Statin therapy has beneficial outcomes in some high-risk populations, and PCSK9 therapy has relevant data; statins also influence inflammation and nitric oxide pathways, complicating mechanistic attribution.
    • Antibiotics can be worthwhile during a serious infection, while preventive medication and population-wide exposure involve tradeoffs, informed consent and patient choice.

    Muscle, exercise and dietary self-assessment (02:08:30-02:23:20)

    • Resistance training is central to preserving muscle in older adults; increased meat, reduced carbohydrate intake and improved insulin sensitivity can accompany better DEXA measurements in coaching experience.
    • Protein intake near one gram per pound of ideal body weight and slow-to-failure resistance sessions lasting roughly 15-20 minutes twice weekly form Dave's muscle-building routine.
    • An L1 compression fracture during weight use underscores injury concerns; machines and regular lower-intensity exercise address safety and mental well-being alongside muscular strength.
    • A dietary trial can reveal previously normalized symptoms; knee pain, dandruff and longstanding bowel irregularity improved following dietary change.
    • A strict 30-, 60- or 90-day ancestral-style dietary trial offers a way to observe changes in symptoms and well-being against habitual eating.

    Fiber, bowel health and autoimmune gut disease (02:23:20-02:34:15)

    • [13] A 2012 chronic-constipation intervention compared differing fiber intakes and found complete relief in the no-fiber subgroup, challenging the assumption that increased fiber always helps.
    • A high-fat, hypercarnivorous pattern combines meat with additional fat to approximate the fat content attributed to large wild prey.
    • Abrupt fasting and carbohydrate restriction can produce digestive distress; a gradual four- to six-week transition to higher fat intake can reduce diarrhea and bile-related symptoms.
    • Major carbohydrate restriction changes electrolyte needs; insufficient sodium, potassium or magnesium can accompany fatigue, nausea and malaise.
    • Inflammatory bowel disease, including Crohn's disease and ulcerative colitis, is a focus of dietary coaching; multiple sclerosis also has a body of dietary intervention research.
    • Childhood vitiligo worsened during stress and later improved during a period of carnivore eating, with continued improvement during a high-fat, animal-dominant diet that includes vegetables and spices.
    • During inflammatory bowel disease flares, puréed meat, soup and broth can reduce the burden of large solid meals; two or three smaller meals can be easier than one large meal.
    • Large late meals can disrupt sleep; food intake ending at least two to three hours before bed, or three to four hours in Dave's routine, supports better nighttime rest.

    AI, expertise and limits of diagnosis (02:34:15-02:46:30)

    • AI-assisted symptom analysis can expand the diagnostic possibilities for rare diseases but can also produce alarming, unlikely explanations and unnecessary medical visits.
    • Refsum syndrome in two brothers involved impaired handling of phytanic acid from foods including beef and dairy; earlier identification could reduce cumulative exposure and related visual damage.
    • AI outputs depend on training data, clinical guidelines and developer constraints; sustained dialogue can expose neglected factors while also generating agreement with a user's assumptions.
    • An anthropology inquiry involving nitrogen-isotope evidence for omnivores initially produced an incorrect exclusion of a paper; more specific bibliographic clues corrected the retrieval, demonstrating the importance of domain expertise.
    • Continuous AI-assisted debate about carbohydrates does not itself change diet or health; action requires a workable decision despite uncertainty.

    Lean mass hyper-responders, ketones and VLDL (02:46:30-02:52:45)

    • [14] The lipid energy model connects high LDL in lean, carbohydrate-restricted individuals to fatty-acid mobilization, hepatic VLDL production and delivery of triglycerides to peripheral tissues.
    • Hepatic fatty acids can enter ketone production or triglyceride-rich VLDL synthesis; a modest shift toward VLDL can coexist with high LDL and low circulating beta-hydroxybutyrate.
    • A highly fat-adapted person can have beta-hydroxybutyrate near 0.2-0.5 mmol/L while oxidizing fatty acids; ketone concentration alone does not quantify overall fat use.
    • A respiratory quotient near 0.70-0.75 would be consistent with substantial fat oxidation despite low ketones; this mechanism remains testable and not universal.

    Research corrections, interpretation and changing medicine (02:52:45-03:04:19)

    • [10] The April 7 longitudinal KETO-CTA paper required a significant correction and was subsequently retracted after anomalies in the Cleerly plaque data; acknowledgment and correction of errors are essential to scientific practice.
    • Anonymized raw Cleerly data contained implausible patterns; repeated requests for paid, blinded quality control were declined, while QAngio and HeartFlow provided independent plaque analyses.
    • The independent plaque analyses also linked baseline plaque with subsequent progression and found no detectable LDL/ApoB-progression association within the cohort; anonymized data were released for external analysis.
    • Several prominent critics continued to dispute the work without accepting the Cleerly anomalies; Steven Quartz subsequently acknowledged a problem, making consistency in data scrutiny a central concern.
    • Publication alone does not rapidly change entrenched clinical beliefs; institutional communication and repeated conversations have increased recognition of the lean mass hyper-responder phenotype.
    • Premature cardiovascular disease in a wider family motivates concern about risk prioritization; severe hyperglycemia and high LDL can coexist, making metabolic dysfunction a major therapeutic priority.
    • With HbA1c initially at 10 and elevated LDL, reducing HbA1c to five yields a different metabolic risk pattern from lowering LDL while HbA1c stays at 10; persistent severe hyperglycemia remains consequential.
    • Clinical emphasis on LDL and ApoB can overshadow insulin resistance, whose association with disease is especially important outside special lipid disorders such as homozygous familial hypercholesterolemia.
    • Recognition of lean mass hyper-responders is growing among clinicians, with research debates progressing at a pace faster than some academic expectations but slower than engineering expectations.

    References

    1. [00:40] Hemisphere-wide evidence of Early Paleoindian megaherbivore specialization — https://doi.org/10.1126/sciadv.aef9628
    2. [01:12] Insulin resistance as a predictor of age-related diseases — https://doi.org/10.1210/jcem.86.8.7763
    3. [01:20] Cardiometabolic Effects of Omnivorous vs Vegan Diets in Identical Twins: A Randomized Clinical Trial — https://doi.org/10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2023.44457
    4. [01:23] The Environment and Disease: Association or Causation? — https://doi.org/10.1177/003591576505800503
    5. [01:28] Dairy Products and Cardiometabolic Health Outcomes — https://dash.harvard.edu/bitstreams/90ef08c0-57ce-4ff9-b6ef-3dc7cdc4f7a3/download
    6. [01:33] Re-evaluation of the traditional diet-heart hypothesis: analysis of recovered data from Minnesota Coronary Experiment (1968-73) — https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.i1246
    7. [01:33] Use of dietary linoleic acid for secondary prevention of coronary heart disease and death: evaluation of recovered data from the Sydney Diet Heart Study and updated meta-analysis — https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.e8707
    8. [01:34] Metformin blunts muscle hypertrophy in response to progressive resistance exercise training in older adults: the MASTERS trial — https://doi.org/10.1111/acel.13039
    9. [01:53] Carbohydrate Restriction-Induced Elevations in LDL-Cholesterol and Atherosclerosis: The KETO Trial — https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jacadv.2024.101109
    10. [01:53] RETRACTED: Longitudinal Data From the KETO-CTA Study: Plaque Predicts Plaque, ApoB Does Not — https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jacadv.2025.101686
    11. [01:55] Progression of whole-heart atherosclerosis by coronary CT and major adverse cardiovascular events — https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jcct.2020.12.007
    12. [02:00] Atherosclerosis in the Masai — https://doi.org/10.1093/oxfordjournals.aje.a121365
    13. [02:23] Stopping or reducing dietary fiber intake reduces constipation and its associated symptoms — https://doi.org/10.3748/wjg.v18.i33.4593
    14. [02:47] The Lipid Energy Model: Reimagining Lipoprotein Function in the Context of Carbohydrate-Restricted Diets — https://doi.org/10.3390/metabo12050460
     

    Whole-Food Plant-Based Daily Menu

    Breakfast

    • Boiled potatoes: 350 g
    • UV-exposed mushrooms: 200 g (raw weight)
    • Orange: 200 g (edible portion)
    • Ground flaxseed: 20 g

    Lunch

    • Calcium-set firm tofu: 400 g
    • Cooked lentils: 180 g
    • Cooked kale: 80 g
    • Red bell pepper: 150 g

    Dinner

    • Tempeh: 120 g
    • Cooked shelled edamame: 120 g
    • Cooked broccoli: 250 g
    • Cooked cauliflower: 400 g
    • Carrots: 150 g

    Snacks and Supplements

    • Unsalted sunflower seeds: 85 g
    • Iodized salt: 3.8 g
    • Vitamin B12 (cyanocobalamin): 100 µg
    • Vitamin D: From verified UV-exposed mushrooms, or 20 µg supplement if needed

    Daily Nutritional Totals

    Metric Amount
    Calories 2,233
    Total protein 147 g
    DIAAS-style adjusted protein ~110 g
    Carbohydrates 248 g
    Fat 94 g
    Fiber ≥77 g
    Food weight 2.71 kg
    Daily cost $13–20

    70/30 Ground Beef Daily Menu

    Daily Food

    • Ground beef: 70% lean / 30% fat
    • Quantity: Approximately 0.50 kg
    • No additional foods or supplements

    Daily Nutritional Totals

    Metric Amount
    Calories ~2,300
    Protein ~100 g
    Food weight ~0.50 kg
    Daily cost ~$3–5

    the menus are taking into account bioavailabilty, diaas - and are nutritionally complete.

    Yes its a best effort generated visualization

    I have written on food menu weights before - https://discuss.online/post/39914520

     

    Inverse associations of vegetarian diet with morbidity and mortality have been observed; however, the role of vegetarian diet on exceptional longevity remains unrevealed.

    Objectives - This study aims to examine the association between a vegetarian diet and likelihood of becoming a centenarian in adults aged ≥80 y.

    Methods - This prospective nested case-control study included 5203 participants aged 80+ y from the Chinese Longitudinal Healthy Longevity Survey, a nationally representative cohort initiated in 1998. Participants were classified as omnivores and vegetarians, and further into vegetarian subgroups (pesco-vegetarians, ovo-lacto-vegetarians, and vegans) based on consumption of animal-derived foods. The primary outcome was living to 100 y old by the end of follow-up (2018). Multivariable unconditional logistic regression models were used to evaluate the association analysis.

    Results - The study identified 1459 centenarians and matched them with 3744 noncentenarians (who had deceased before reaching 100 y). Relative to omnivores, vegetarians had a lower likelihood of becoming centenarians [odds ratio (OR): 0.81, 95% confidence interval (CI): 0.69, 0.96], and similar patterns were observed for vegans (OR: 0.71, 95% CI: 0.54, 0.98), but not for pesco-vegetarians (OR: 0.84, 95% CI: 0.64, 1.09) and ovo-lacto-vegetarians (OR: 0.86, 95% CI: 0.67, 1.09). The significant association was seen in individuals with BMI <18.5 kg/m2 (OR: 0.72, 95% CI: 0.57, 0.91), but not for those with BMI ≥18.5 kg/m2 (OR: 0.92, 95% CI: 0.73, 1.17) (P-interaction = 0.08).

    Conclusions - Targeting individuals of advanced age (80+ y) in China, we found that individuals following a vegetarian diet had a lower likelihood of becoming centenarians relative to omnivores, underscoring the importance of a balanced, high-quality diet with animal- and plant-derived food composition for exceptional longevity, especially in the underweight oldest-old.

    https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ajcnut.2025.101136 - Not open access, but....

    Full text - https://waltersport.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/02/Vegetarian-diet-and-likelihood-of-becoming-centenarians-in-Chinese-adults-aged-80-y-or-older-Li-et-al.-2026.pdf

     

    Livestock wrecks the climate! Meat is the problem you can easily solve at dinner - so what’s stopping you? You have heard the line so often, it now seems self-evident. We are told the Science is settled. But what if it is not? This page cuts through the half-truths and oversimplified narratives.

    The food system is responsible for anything between one fifth and one third of human-induced greenhouse gas emissions. Agriculture and fisheries contribute about 40% of these food system emissions, while the remainder is split equally between associated land use and land-use changes (30%) and supply chain activities (30%).

    Within the food system, livestock represent the largest source of agricultural emissions, impacting climate and emission budgets. On average, animal-sourced foods have a higher carbon footprint than crops, which is why dietary policies often encourage a shift toward more plant-centric diets.

    However, directly comparing individual foods is simplistic and can lead to misguided interventions. Dietary change can involve both benefits and trade-offs. Carbon tunnel vision, focusing solely on carbon reduction, risks ignoring other critical factors, such as water scarcity, biodiversity loss, ecotoxicity, and social impacts, which may arise from prioritizing low-carbon foods. A more effective approach is to assess overall dietary patterns, considering their broader ecological, nutritional, and societal consequences.

    ...Continued at the url...

    • Global data should not be used to evaluate local contexts
    • Further mitigation is possible and ongoing
    • Restricting animal-sourced foods only leads to small gains (1-6%)
    • Dietary focus distracts from more impactful interventions
    • Nutrition should be factored in when comparing foods
    • Co-product benefits of livestock should be accounted for
    • Livestock farming also sequesters carbon
    • Rewilding comes with its own climate impact
    • Large-scale afforestation of grasslands: not a panacea
    • Methane should be evaluated differently than CO2
     

    ADHD is often described as a problem with attention or hyperactivity, but psychiatrist Dr. Georgia Ede argues that the condition is much more complex, involving executive function, dopamine regulation, and potentially brain energy metabolism.

    In this episode of Metabolic Mind, Dr. Bret Scher and Dr. Georgia Ede take a deeper look at ADHD, from how it is diagnosed and treated to emerging research on nutrition and glucose metabolism, including questions about ketogenic therapy

    Dr. Ede draws on years of experience treating ADHD, including her time at Harvard University, Smith College, and the Hallowell Center. She explains why some people living with ADHD can focus intensely on things that interest them while struggling with everyday tasks, why stimulants can be so effective for some people, and where lifestyle strategies may fit alongside conventional care.

    generated summary

    Background and what ADHD is

    • Georgia Ede worked in college mental health for 13 years at Harvard and Smith and for over two years at the Hallowell Center, an ADHD specialty clinic. ADHD also occurs in her family.
    • The name Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder is misleading because attention can be intense for interesting activities and hyperactivity occurs in only about half of cases. The difficulty is directing attention to the needed task at the needed time and sustaining it.
    • ADHD is a neurodevelopmental disorder beginning in childhood that affects executive function: motivation, decisions, planning, prioritization, task initiation, follow-through, boredom tolerance, and ordinary sustained-effort work.
    • Being distracted during math yet absorbed in Star Wars is compatible with ADHD. Attention varies with context; insufficient dopamine activity and brain energy during uninteresting tasks can hinder focus. Some behavioral problems are voluntary, but ADHD itself is not merely a choice.

    Diagnosis and prevalence

    • No reliable laboratory diagnostic test exists. Symptom checklists alone have limited value, particularly when adults may rehearse criteria to access stimulants for academic advantage. Detailed childhood history and clinical judgment are more useful.
    • Inattention is the low-energy cluster: forgetfulness, procrastination, lost items, disorganization, overwhelm, poor listening, and daydreaming, often associated with girls and women. Hyperactivity is the high-energy cluster: fidgeting, restlessness, impatience, impulsivity, and disruptive behavior, more visible in boys and men. Mixed symptoms form the combined type.
    • Children must have at least six inattentive or hyperactive symptoms under the diagnostic checklist; childhood assignments, last-minute studying, messy rooms, forgotten tests, and repeated reminders give richer historical information.
    • ADHD has been diagnosed in more than 11% of US children and around 6% of US adults, and many childhood cases continue in adulthood. [1][2]

    Why diagnoses may be rising

    • Higher diagnostic rates may reflect increased awareness and help-seeking together with actual increases. Potential environmental influences include stress, deteriorating diet, toxins, heavy metals, and prenatal exposures, with their relative contributions uncertain.
    • Dietary hypotheses have long included sugar and additives. Lower iron, zinc, and omega-3 fatty acid levels are more common in children with ADHD, consistent with possible nutritional involvement. [3][4]
    • Maternal type 1 and type 2 diabetes correlate with elevated ADHD risk in offspring, raising the possibility of a glucose-regulation component. Prenatal smoking and alcohol exposure are additional potential influences. [5]
    • Dopamine dysregulation affects reward, pleasure, motivation, and concentration in ADHD. The novelty and immediate gratification of social media attract dopamine-seeking attention; repeated scrolling may increase the stimulation required to maintain attention.

    Burden, comorbidities, and strengths

    • ADHD ranges from minor challenges to serious impairment. High intelligence and motivation can coexist with difficulties meeting obligations, harming education, employment, relationships, self-esteem, and independence.
    • Divorce occurs at roughly twice the usual rate, with elevated risks of substance use, addiction, depression, anxiety, bipolar disorder, learning disabilities, accidents, and suicide. Multiple difficulties commonly coexist with ADHD.
    • Creativity, curiosity, humor, inventiveness, nonlinear thinking, and unusual conceptual connections can accompany ADHD. Stimulating or novel work is often a better match than a full day of repetitive paperwork.
    • Some adults reach diagnosis only later in life. Numerous interests can make sustained progress on a single pursuit difficult, creating a sense of being a late bloomer despite strong abilities.

    Conventional care and stimulant medication

    • Cognitive behavioral therapy, ADHD coaching, skills development, and time management can help; stimulant drugs are among the most effective biological tools used in ADHD care.
    • Adderall, Ritalin, Dexedrine, and Vyvanse are examples of amphetamine- and methylphenidate-based stimulants. They boost dopamine and norepinephrine activity, often taking effect within an hour.
    • Non-stimulant medicines act on norepinephrine without the same dopamine-linked risks of misuse, tolerance, and addiction. They usually act more slowly and succeed less frequently than stimulants.
    • Stimulants can worsen anxiety, psychosis, or mania alongside ADHD. Combining them with other drugs is sometimes possible under careful monitoring but entails risk.
    • Stimulants can calm hyperactive ADHD through increased activity in brain regions governing inhibition and self-control, while a person without ADHD may feel accelerated. ADHD is also associated with measurable frontal-brain structural and glucose-use differences, independent of intelligence or effort.

    External structure

    • Calendars, reminders, task lists, assignment schedules, and smaller work intervals with breaks, movement, or rewards supply useful external structure. They reduce functional demands without eliminating ADHD-related difficulty.
    • Some highly able students at Harvard and Smith needed two or three times the effort of peers to reach similar academic results; motivation and intelligence were not the limiting factors.

    Few-foods dietary trials

    • European groups investigated restrictive few-foods or oligoantigenic diets among children with moderate to severe ADHD, including severe cases requiring hospitalization. [6][7][8]
    • Suspected dietary triggers, including chocolate, dairy, and nuts, were excluded. Meals mainly contained poultry, fruit, and vegetables, sometimes rice, apple juice, and dairy-free margarine; the diets were simpler, though not ideal.
    • Approximately 62-82% improved within a few weeks in these studies, and some children ceased meeting ADHD diagnostic criteria. Dietary components could therefore contribute to symptoms, although the responsible foods were not isolated. [6][7][8]
    • Severe restrictions are hard to implement for families, particularly when children eat at school. These barriers and the appeal of medication may contribute to limited interest in dietary research.

    Brain energy and the metabolic hypothesis

    • In addition to dopamine and norepinephrine dysregulation, ADHD has links with brain inflammation, mitochondrial dysfunction, and disrupted energy production.
    • A 1990 National Institute of Mental Health PET study published in the New England Journal of Medicine found lower global and regional brain glucose metabolism in adults with hyperactivity since childhood, especially in premotor and superior frontal regions involved in attention and movement. [9]
    • ADHD is linked with approximately 50% higher likelihood of obesity and about twice the risk of type 2 diabetes; maternal diabetes provides another metabolic association. [5][10][11]
    • Associations and abnormalities in brain energy support a metabolic explanation, but clinical trials have not yet demonstrated that metabolic interventions improve ADHD symptoms.

    What dietary changes look like clinically

    • At the Hallowell Center, Ede used whole-food and paleo-style diets and removed junk food before incorporating ketogenic therapy. For some younger people with limited metabolic dysfunction, those changes substantially improved attention and task completion.
    • Mental clarity and calm, usable mental energy are frequently among the earliest changes after starting ketogenic therapy, sometimes within days and ahead of improvement in other symptoms.
    • A woman with persistent difficulty maintaining her home began cleaning her bathroom at 6 a.m. without planning it. She was calm, not manic, and could initiate a long-delayed activity.

    Drawbacks of stimulant medication

    • Stimulants can produce anxiety, irritability, muscle tension, restlessness, insomnia, and marked appetite suppression, especially concerning for children and underweight adults.
    • Their effects end when the drug wears off. Afternoon energy crashes can severely hinder functioning at work or while driving; some people experience diminished creativity.
    • Stimulants may create uncomfortable, wired energy, while exercise and metabolic approaches aim for calm concentration. Anxiety medicines may be added to counter stimulant effects; stimulants increase activity without correcting the underlying brain-energy and neurotransmitter dysregulation.

    Environment, nutrition, and the Oxford trial

    • Cognitive behavioral therapy, coaching, exercise, and mindfulness remain options, as do stimulating occupations aligned with ADHD abilities, including emergency medicine, journalism, art, entrepreneurship, comedy, and carpentry.
    • Whole-food changes come first in Ede's dietary approach. Ketogenic therapy is worth exploring when difficulties persist at home or work, especially with coexisting metabolic or psychiatric problems.
    • Ally Houston has a leading role in an Oxford randomized controlled trial investigating ketogenic dietary therapy for adults with ADHD and depressive symptoms, with Ede acting as an adviser. Results are expected to address questions left unanswered by clinical experience. [12]

    Ketone levels and glucose stability

    • One viewer cited feeling good at blood ketone levels of 4-7 mmol/L; no specific level has been established for ADHD, and most people do not reach that range.
    • Fluctuating or elevated glucose can disrupt brain chemistry, increase inflammation and oxidative stress, and impair attention. Some individuals improve through whole foods and carbohydrate restriction without ongoing ketosis.
    • Wearing a continuous glucose monitor for a couple of weeks can show the effects of different foods and guide changes that reduce excessive glucose elevations.
    • A greater brain-energy deficit from impaired glucose use may require higher ketone concentrations as additional fuel. Requirements vary with symptom severity, duration, the individual, and inflammatory dietary factors; the needed level cannot yet be predicted.

    Ketosis and medication adjustments

    • Ketogenic therapy changes brain and body physiology sufficiently to affect psychiatric medications. Dietary changes of this kind can function as a substantial medical intervention.
    • In Ede's clinical experience, combining ketosis with stimulants may lead to excessive energy, anxiety, jitteriness, and appetite loss. These effects can indicate that a lower stimulant dose or discontinuation is possible because dietary effects overlap with medication effects.
    • Some patients take stimulants only when outside ketosis. In many cases, stimulants permit as-needed use or discontinuation without prolonged tapering, depending on individual circumstances.
    • Dietary and medication changes require coordination with a clinician experienced in metabolic therapy. Eric Westman's term "keto medicine" conveys the intervention's substantial physiological effects.

    Final guidance

    • When attention is difficult, dietary quality is relevant regardless of whether ketosis is needed. Exercise, sleep, mindfulness, planning supports, and assistance managing demands are additional priorities.
    • ADHD is rooted in brain development, with signs usually occurring before age seven and diagnostic criteria requiring evidence before age 12. Brain anatomy and chemistry differ, making self-blame unwarranted while practical responsibility for finding useful supports remains.

    References

    1. [08:47] ADHD Prevalence Among U.S. Children and Adolescents in 2022: Diagnosis, Severity, Co-Occurring Disorders, and Treatment — https://doi.org/10.1080/15374416.2024.2335625
    2. [09:02] Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder Diagnosis, Treatment, and Telehealth Use in Adults — National Center for Health Statistics Rapid Surveys System, United States, October–November 2023 — https://doi.org/10.15585/mmwr.mm7340a1
    3. [11:15] Essential Trace Elements Zinc, Iron, Copper and Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder in Children and Adolescents: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Case-Control Studies — https://doi.org/10.3390/nu18111797
    4. [11:15] Omega-3 fatty acid and ADHD: blood level analysis and meta-analytic extension of supplementation trials — https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cpr.2014.05.005
    5. [11:35] Maternal Gestational Diabetes Mellitus, Type 1 Diabetes, and Type 2 Diabetes During Pregnancy and Risk of ADHD in Offspring — https://doi.org/10.2337/dc18-0733
    6. [26:32] Controlled trial of oligoantigenic treatment in the hyperkinetic syndrome — https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(85)91206-1
    7. [26:32] Effects of a few food diet in attention deficit disorder — https://doi.org/10.1136/adc.69.5.564
    8. [26:32] Effects of a restricted elimination diet on the behaviour of children with attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder (INCA study): a randomised controlled trial — https://doi.org/10.1016/S0140-6736(10)62227-1
    9. [30:22] Cerebral glucose metabolism in adults with hyperactivity of childhood onset — https://doi.org/10.1056/NEJM199011153232001
    10. [31:22] Association Between ADHD and Obesity: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis — https://doi.org/10.1176/appi.ajp.2015.15020266
    11. [31:27] Risk of Type 2 Diabetes in Adolescents and Young Adults With Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder: A Nationwide Longitudinal Study — https://doi.org/10.4088/JCP.17m11607
    12. [39:14] FAD - Food for ADHD and Depression (Oxford randomised controlled trial registry) — https://doi.org/10.1186/ISRCTN62698625
     

    Where India Went Wrong - and How to Fix It

    Peter Ballerstedt (PhD) explores the connections between agriculture, protein, nutrition and metabolic health. He discusses how the way we think about food production and protein can influence both human nutrition and the wider conversation around metabolic health.

    generated summary

    From forage agronomy to metabolic health

    • Forage agronomy and ruminant nutrition connect soil, plants, livestock, and food quality. Agricultural and human nutrition specialties contain complementary knowledge.
    • In 2007, at age 51, Ballerstedt was obese and prediabetic. His wife had explored low-carbohydrate diets for five years. Gary Taubes's Good Calories, Bad Calories [1] and Michael and Mary Dan Eades's Protein Power [2] helped change his outlook.
    • A subsequent Seattle metabolic-health conference for clinicians revealed gaps between agricultural expertise and clinical nutrition knowledge. Connecting the disciplines became his ongoing work.
    • Large, long-term human nutrition experiments cannot fully control genetics and food intake in ways sometimes possible in animal experiments. Findings from human nutrition research can be interpreted with more certainty than their limitations permit.
    • A concern that animal agriculture had been unfairly blamed for chronic disease led to efforts to connect agriculture, medicine, nutrition, public health, and environmental science.

    Producing calories is not the same as nourishing people

    • India combines high agricultural production with diabetes, obesity, anemia, protein inadequacy, and micronutrient deficiencies. Overfeeding and undernourishment coexist globally across income groups.
    • Food systems need to provide affordable, accessible, culturally suitable nutrition beyond calories or isolated nutrient totals. Meals also have family and community roles.
    • Packaged-food protein quantities generally measure crude protein: sample nitrogen multiplied by 6.25. This long-used proxy is comparatively easy to measure but does not establish protein quality.
    • Identical crude-protein amounts from plants and animal-source foods are nutritionally different because of amino-acid composition, digestibility, and accompanying nutrients.
    • Famine prevention and calorie supply were essential historical priorities. Calorie abundance alone does not establish nutrient adequacy or eliminate chronic illness.
    • Malnutrition encompasses inadequate, excessive, or imbalanced nourishment and associated metabolic dysfunction. The undernutrition/overnutrition distinction can wrongly reduce obesity to overeating or inactivity.
    • Food-system sustainability assessments often end at processors or retailers and use assumed healthy-diet standards. Population health and chronic-disease outcomes from therapeutic diet changes also belong in sustainability assessments.

    Liebig's barrel and the public-health limiting factor

    • Liebig's law of the minimum uses a barrel with unequal staves: its shortest stave determines capacity. Lengthening other staves does not increase capacity until the limiting stave changes. [3]
    • Low insulin sensitivity and chronically high insulin are the current public-health limiting factors in this model. Greater insulin sensitivity enables improvements previously blocked by those factors.
    • After insulin sensitivity increases, limiting factors can include indispensable amino acids, fatty-acid balance, minerals, micronutrients, environmental exposures, and chronic stress.
    • In soil fertility, adding nonlimiting nutrients wastes money and can cause toxicity. Public-health interventions also depend on finding the actual constraint and evaluating outcomes.
    • Advice favoring low-fat or largely plant-based diets influences consumer demand, agricultural output, and manufactured food choices.
    • Protein-branded Pop-Tarts advertise 10 grams of protein alongside substantial sugars and starches. Reaching around 30 grams through them also brings a large carbohydrate load, which a protein figure alone conceals.

    Agricultural production and dairy incentives

    • India's Operation Flood illustrates how policy and coordinated production expanded milk supply. India is the world's largest dairy producer, with additional potential in cows and buffaloes. [4]
    • Reducing carbohydrate-derived energy raises questions about which fats and oils provide energy. Dairy has an important role when animal fats are not automatically excluded.
    • U.S. dairy production yields roughly as much animal fat as all meat production combined. Wider application of current livestock science could increase fat production beyond existing levels.
    • Changing dietary guidance can alter consumer demand, agricultural investment, food availability, and producer incentives.

    Protein quality in rice-, cereal-, and legume-based meals

    • Protein comprises amino acids, including indispensable ones that humans cannot synthesize. Requirements vary by amino acid, so total protein is not a sufficient measure of adequacy. Ballerstedt's professional expertise is agronomy, not human nutrition.
    • When lysine is limiting, other amino acids cannot be fully used for protein synthesis and a greater share is used as energy.
    • Cereals such as wheat and rice are often limited in lysine; legumes such as lentils, peas, beans, and soybeans are often limited in sulfur-containing amino acids. Their combination improves balance, while digestion and absorption remain important.
    • Browning wheat foods such as bread, biscuits, and cookies binds some lysine to sugars and reduces its nutritional availability. Chemical amino-acid content alone does not guarantee its utilization.
    • Modest portions of dairy, eggs, meat, or another acceptable animal-source food added to rice and lentils improve amino-acid balance without large extra cereal and legume servings.
    • Dietary protein requirements formerly cited at 0.8 g/kg body weight daily may be nearer 1.2 g/kg, and a meal containing approximately 30 grams of high-quality protein may stimulate protein synthesis.
    • Achieving these protein targets with rice and lentils alone can require more than three meal-sized portions; including an egg or dairy allows a similar goal with fewer carbohydrate-rich servings.
    • More cereal and legume servings can improve protein intake while making blood-glucose control harder. Adding paneer or another acceptable animal-source food and reducing cereal or legume quantities improves the balance.
    • Minimally processed cereals and legumes are preferable. Animal-source foods also supply essential micronutrients, including some absent from entirely plant-based diets, in usable forms without certain plant antinutrients; their nutritional value goes beyond protein.

    Animal-source foods and vegetarian choices

    • Meat consumption is not mandatory. Religious and cultural restrictions can be accommodated using acceptable animal-source foods, including dairy in lacto-vegetarian diets.
    • Diets with no animal-source foods require greater attention to supplements and medical monitoring for vitamin B12, iron, and other nutrient deficiencies.
    • Individual experiences with dietary therapy sometimes conflict with official guidance. Environmental assertions about animal agriculture also require further scrutiny for better-informed choices.

    Affordability, childhood development, and food-system priorities

    • Higher costs of meat, eggs, and dairy relative to rice, wheat, and sugar can shift lower-income households toward starch-heavy diets. Affordable nutrient-dense food is a public-policy priority.
    • Childhood nourishment at critical stages affects lifelong brain development and economic capacity. Approximately 20% to 25% of children under five worldwide are stunted, with rates above 40% in some countries. [5]
    • Investment in appropriate nutrition can reduce later chronic-disease and healthcare costs. Policy must support consumer access alongside financially viable agricultural production.
    • Almost 45% of the world uses under 1,000 kWh of electricity per person annually, comparable to a large North American refrigerator. Insufficient refrigeration limits the movement and storage of perishable meat, eggs, and dairy. [6]
    • Dietary modeling estimates that around half of adults' dietary protein must be animal-derived to meet nonprotein nutrient requirements. [7]
    • An additional analysis connects animal-source foods contributing below roughly 30% of dietary energy with increased population-level micronutrient inadequacies. [8]
    • FAO food-balance figures place fewer than approximately 30% of people in populations receiving above both 30% of calories and 50% of protein from animal-source foods. Greater availability requires changes in production, distribution, marketing, and access. [9]

    Daily foods and my own meals

    • MEDS means meat, eggs, dairy, and seafood, consumed daily in culturally acceptable combinations. Dairy is included among animal-source foods.
    • The usual pattern is two meals daily, sometimes three, aiming for at least 30 grams of high-quality protein each. Actual portions do not consistently supply 1.2 g/kg across the day.
    • An omnivorous diet includes meat, eggs, dairy, and occasional seafood. Typical meals include three or four eggs with about one ounce of hard cheese, or cooked minced meat with vegetables, cheese, and sometimes olive oil.

    References

    1. [03:39] Good Calories, Bad Calories — https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/176680/good-calories-bad-calories-by-gary-taubes/9781400033461/
    2. [03:45] Protein Power — https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/44448/protein-power-by-michael-r-eades-md-and-mary-dan-eades-md/
    3. [15:22] On the Origin of the Theory of Mineral Nutrition of Plants and the Law of the Minimum — https://doi.org/10.2136/sssaj1999.6351055x
    4. [20:31] Operation Flood — https://www.nddb.org/about/genesis/flood
    5. [37:30] Levels and Trends in Child Malnutrition: UNICEF/WHO/World Bank Group Joint Child Malnutrition Estimates, 2025 Edition — https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/9789240112308
    6. [38:51] Estimating the Modern Energy Minimum Gap — https://energyforgrowth.org/article/estimating-the-modern-energy-minimum-gap/
    7. [39:26] Approximately Half of Total Protein Intake by Adults Must be Animal-Based to Meet Nonprotein, Nutrient-Based Recommendations, With Variations Due to Age and Sex — https://doi.org/10.1093/jn/nxac150
    8. [39:49] The Role of Animal-Source Foods in Healthy, Sustainable, and Equitable Food Systems — https://doi.org/10.36072/dp.5
    9. [40:08] FAOSTAT Food Balances — https://data.fao.org/catalog/iso/2f264bb6-1238-459a-bf8b-0e2d0a16804a
    view more: ‹ prev next ›