[–] [S] 0 points 1 week ago (3 children)

I feel guilty sure, but who’re you to tell me what to do?

We are just chatting, living with guilt is troublesome, i would like to see you have a healthier relationship with yourself.

Why don’t you eat something other than meat?

It's not healthy for me, i react poorly to plant based foods, but that doesn't mean other people can't enjoy them.

See how that works?

Yup! It's a wonderful way to have a conversation!

Oh and I’d be first in line for lab grown meat, so wrong again.

It's already available for sale in singapore, but its 97% plant based 3% "lab meat", but it's a start.

You just use what you believe are ‘smart’ words to disguise your illogic.

Sure please show me my illogic and i'll evaluate it to inform my future logic.

Also I specifically said no one care if you eat meat. That includes me.

I feel guilty sure

Sounds like you do care.

you don’t know what metabolism means

https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/metabolism

The dynamic energy storage and utilization throughout the human body. Including all energetic substrates, cell health (especially mitochondrial health), oxidation.. .basically anything that uses ATP, which is pretty much everything in the body.

you’re really dumb

Great, please educate me (with sources), I am happy to get better.

You used the word “trigger” then get big mad that someone matched that energy.

You are clearly triggered here, your guilt, the projection of biases and motivations i haven't demonstrated. That is ok, it's what i asked for in the post after all. I'm glad you are explaining things to me now

Pathetic. Pathetic and really stupid. You’re probably feeling guilty about being a dumb piece of shit. Should go address that.

Lots of angry energy, are you doing ok?

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] [S] 1 point 1 week ago (5 children)

    Thank you for sharing.

    The fact you express your omnivore diet in terms of 'slavery', 'shitty lives' demonstrates you have lots of guilt associated with your omnivore lifestyle. I see a few options for you - go full plant based, or purchases meat that doesn't have a bad life (i.e. meat your local regenerative farmer)

    carnivores pushing around vegetarians and vegans

    Carnivore isn't about other people, its a eating pattern, which is a powerful tool in fixing metabolic health. It's really not about what other people eat. Framing everything in a combative either or probably is also adding to the guilt you carry.

    Just be better.

    That is why we are here, to be better together. Thank you for joining us.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 2 points 1 week ago (1 child)

    I would absolutely expect a doctor to have a reasonable understanding of nutrition. It’s the source of many illnesses.

    That is a reasonable expectation, however the training doesn't cover it (see my article referenced earlier, or just ask your own doctor how my hours of nutritional training they have).

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] [S] 2 points 1 week ago

    Figure 11d - These findings suggest that microbiota depletion substantially attenuates KD efficacy.... i.e. they used antibiotics to reduce KD effectiveness. Very interesting.

  • source
  • [–] 14 points 1 week ago

    People make games not companies, if your sitting on such a huge gaming endowment hire good people and make original games.

    Buying a studio is just a name, especially a older studio with many years since it's last success, people turn over, move around...

  • source
  • [–] 2 points 1 week ago (3 children)

    a natural scientist claiming “All X is Y” with full confidence and without using a ton of qualifiers, then don’t talk to them.

    Great, I agree, common ground.

    reading individual scientific papers isn’t very useful. Talk to a doctor for nutrition advice.

    Most medical doctors don't actually get nutritional training outside of tube-feeding techniques. So they will need to either read the literature themselves, or give you their best approximation of a healthy diet based on their biases. https://discuss.online/post/40032579

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] 1 point 1 week ago* (last edited 1 week ago) (6 children)

    the anti-scientific carnivore community on here and while your take is technically correct, it just sounds like it leads into their horseshit.

    Hello! You summoned us! What papers would you like us to read? I find the people on that community are highly literate and willing to read any evidence for or against. Science means sometimes your beliefs get challenged, and possibly changed.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  •  

    Jesús talks about his journey on the carnivore diet.

    generated summary

    Venezuela: scarcity and undernourishment

    • Jesús left Venezuela about six years earlier amid its political and economic crisis.
    • Around 2016, shops ran out of food while people with government-granted access resold supplies at inflated prices.
    • At approximately 18 years old, Jesús weighed 46 kg; even corn flour could cost $10 per kilogram.

    Leaving Venezuela and regaining weight

    • While his family relocated elsewhere, Jesús lived without legal status in Trinidad and worked up to 18-hour shifts.
    • His initial diet followed conventional advice, with vegetables, grains, bread and an effort to choose organic foods.
    • His weight and wellbeing improved from their earlier lows, but he remained unwell amid long working hours.
    • After moving to Peru, he continued the same diet at roughly 54–55 kg until his health worsened in 2024.

    Fatty liver and discovering carnivore

    • Severe abdominal pain disrupted work, and testing identified fatty liver despite a low-fat diet and no alcohol.
    • Jesús ate many vegetables and peanuts, while clinicians advised reducing animal fat, which he found contradictory.
    • Jesús had completed a year of medical study in Venezuela and previously viewed carnivore as an expensive biohack.
    • An interview with Dr. Anthony Chaffee changed his view of carnivore and of contradictory nutrition advice.
    • Jesús interpreted contradictory milk, fat and nutrition research advice as evidence that mainstream guidance was wrong.

    Changes after adopting carnivore

    • Jesús felt more energetic after four weeks; a liver recheck about two months later no longer found fatty liver.
    • His family initially worried about his liver, then viewed the follow-up result as an important improvement.
    • Jesús gained approximately 6 kg of muscle and increased his athletic performance after years of low body weight.
    • Nearly three years after starting carnivore, he has sustained energy and can keep pace during demanding exercise.

    Everyday meals and family changes

    • During intensive training, his daily intake is about 1 kg beef and ten eggs, plus some butter and occasional cheese.
    • During lighter training periods, his daily intake is about 500 g beef and ten eggs.
    • His overweight relatives initially resisted his change from buying peanuts and vegetables to buying household meat.
    • His family's resistance lessened over time, and his father adopted carnivore for roughly one month.
    • His father's nighttime choking episodes have ceased for four weeks, with snoring persisting and sleep continuity improving.

    Cholesterol and medical follow-up

    • During a later medical visit for a possible infection, his cholesterol was nearly three times the local average.
    • Clinicians judged it not dangerous at his age but advised endocrinology, cardiac checks and possible medication.
    • Jesús did not disclose his diet, declined further visits there and preferred a clinician familiar with carnivore.

    Food and daily life in Peru

    • Jesús appreciates Peru's calm lifestyle but dislikes its traffic, services and lack of sunshine, and misses Venezuela.
    • He receives pasture-raised beef at home for nearly supermarket prices, despite buying quantities comparable to restaurants.
    • In his experience, everyday Peruvian meals center on rice and potatoes with little meat, unlike restaurant cuisine.
    • Jesús connects meals dominated by rice and potatoes with childhood anemia and shorter stature in Peru.
    • He estimates average height around 160 cm and encounters few severely obese people but many with low muscle tone.

    Exercise, energy and long-term plans

    • Jesús previously trained for about two hours daily, six days per week, aiming to maximize muscle growth.
    • He currently trains about once weekly, prioritizing work, and may increase to one to three sessions per week.
    • He questions whether six or seven intense training days per week are beneficial for the central nervous system.
    • Intensive exercise rarely left him exhausted; prolonged indoor inactivity brings restlessness or mild headaches.
    • Walks, sunlight and social contact improve his wellbeing during those periods.
    • As a child, Jesús especially valued meat; during Venezuelan food shortages, he sometimes ate it only monthly.
    • He prefers carnivore and expects meat to remain his dietary foundation, even if he adds other foods later.

    Advice for someone starting carnivore

    • Advice from Dr. Chaffee influenced Jesús to start his father on carnivore without a gradual transition.
    • His father experienced no anticipated 'keto flu' and had fewer nighttime breathing episodes, awakenings and bathroom trips.
    • Another friend's abrupt switch was followed by improved wellbeing, reinforcing Jesús's preference for immediate elimination.
    • Jesús allows some flexibility during a transition but ultimately advocates eliminating all non-animal foods.

     

    Objective: To evaluate the efficacy and safety of an Eastern Healthy Dietary Pattern (EHDP)-modified ketogenic diet in Chinese patients with obesity and polyendocrine metabolic ovarian syndrome (PMOS; formerly polycystic ovary syndrome [PCOS]) and to provide evidence for a culturally adapted nutritional intervention.

    Methods:

    This single-arm, self-controlled study enrolled 55 patients with PMOS and obesity (body mass index [BMI] ≥28 kg/m²) from the Clinical Nutrition Clinic of the Second Affiliated Hospital of Zhejiang Chinese Medical University between February 2024 and September 2025. Participants underwent a 12-week phased dietary intervention. Body composition, metabolic indices, reproductive hormones, and clinical symptoms were assessed before and after the intervention.

    Results: During the intervention, blood β-hydroxybutyrate concentrations remained within the target range of 0.5-3.0 mmol/L and reached 1.24 ± 0.41 mmol/L at week 12, indicating good adherence. Mean body weight decreased by 9.97 kg (10.63%), body fat mass by 7.53 kg, and visceral fat area by 35.81 cm², whereas skeletal muscle mass decreased by 1.60 kg. The homeostasis model assessment of insulin resistance (HOMA-IR) decreased by 48.8%, and triglyceride concentrations decreased from 1.60 ± 0.91 to 1.08 ± 0.49 mmol/L. Alanine aminotransferase and aspartate aminotransferase concentrations also decreased significantly, whereas low-density lipoprotein cholesterol and small dense low-density lipoprotein cholesterol did not increase significantly. Total testosterone and luteinizing hormone concentrations decreased by 35.8% and 55.5%, respectively, and the luteinizing hormone/follicle-stimulating hormone ratio approached the normal range. Serum 25-hydroxyvitamin D increased from 17.86 ± 3.52 to 23.90 ± 4.12 ng/mL. Clinical symptoms improved, with no clinically significant adverse changes in the assessed safety parameters (all P > 0.05).

    Conclusion: A 12-week EHDP-modified ketogenic diet was associated with improvements in body composition, metabolic indices, reproductive hormones, and clinical symptoms in Chinese patients with PMOS and obesity, without clinically significant safety concerns. This culturally adapted approach may offer a practical nutritional strategy for this population; controlled trials are warranted to confirm these findings.

    Full Paper - https://doi.org/10.3389/fendo.2026.1948375

     

    Maggie is an exceptional example of what a healthy 85 year old person should look like. Instead of frailty and limitations, she has a vibrance and energy that is the envy of most people in their 30s.

    generated summary

    Maggie's childhood and lifelong meat diet

    • Maggie was 82 when filmed for the documentary Healing Humanity, after at least 65 years of carnivore eating; she was 83 at the time of this conversation. [1]
    • She is an example of a person maintaining a "proper human diet" in modern society for nearly her entire life.
    • As a child, she disliked vegetables, resisted eating them, and preferred meat; her parents permitted this because she was skinny and healthy.
    • Her carnivore history may exceed 65 years because she ate predominantly or exclusively meat in childhood and stopped eating plants when independent.
    • She enrolled in veterinary school but left because she wanted her own animals and did not want to care for other people's animals.
    • She took a job on a remote ranch in Columbia, far from grocery stores, did not grow vegetables, ate the meat she raised or hunted, and raised her children similarly.

    Ranch work and physical ability at 82

    • At 82, Maggie was a very healthy working rancher, tending cattle from 5 a.m., four hours before the visitor arrived for breakfast.
    • Her looks resembled those of someone no more than half her age, and her movement resembled that of a healthy 30-year-old.
    • She moved continuously and handled objects quickly to complete the large amount of work on the ranch.
    • On a small sailboat near her home, she climbed the mast and retrieved a line faster than the visitor could have.
    • At 82, she jumped a five-foot fence to manage a large bull threatening another bull, crossing it before the visitor could open it.
    • She moved the bull away from the other animal with speed and decisiveness unusual for someone in their 80s.
    • This single case is an example of the level of health possible in a person in their 80s.

    Plant toxins, telomeres, and aging

    • Human genetics and telomere length determine a natural lifespan of about 120 years in the absence of chronic toxic exposure.
    • Immediate survival after eating salads does not establish their safety, just as people survive tobacco, alcohol, cocaine, and heroin despite their harms.
    • Plant toxins cause cumulative damage over decades and ultimately contribute to premature physical decline and death.
    • Maggie avoided those toxins and retains the capacity for a full day of work without the frailty common in people in their 80s.
    • With an expected natural lifespan of 120 years, Maggie in her 80s is middle-aged in functional terms.

    Herodotus and the natural human lifespan

    • The natural human lifespan is 120 years or more, and some native populations have reached these ages.
    • In the Herodotus account, Persians ate bread and lived around 70 years; Ethiopians ate boiled meat, drank cattle milk and water, and lived at least 120 years. [2]
    • The Ethiopian king equated bread with dirt, and the 120-year figure corresponds to the human lifespan set by genetics.
    • Reaching 120 to 130 years requires physical health and activity during the 80s, 90s, and 100s, not prolonged frailty beginning around 70.
    • Maggie is an example of a healthy and actively working person in their 80s whose functional age is middle age.
    • Cumulative toxic exposure causes earlier physical deterioration and death in the 70s or 80s, not at 120 or 130.
    • Maggie also used the words "I'm middle-aged" about herself.

    References

    1. [00:25] Healing Humanity: The Power of a Proper Human Diet — https://healinghumanity.movie/
    2. [05:47] Herodotus, Histories, Book III, 3.22–3.23 — https://penelope.uchicago.edu/Thayer/E/Roman/Texts/Herodotus/3a%2A.html
     

    Pemmican is a relatively light, high-protein, calorie-dense, meat bar with a long shelf life. If you're a hiker, camper, or backpacker, what's not to like? Well, here I try it and find out!

    generated summary

    Hiking hunger and discovery

    • After a hard hike, cravings for a greasy bacon cheeseburger indicate a need for protein and fat.
    • Pemmican offers a way to carry meat on multi-day hikes without spoilage; Colin Fletcher's The Complete Walker [1] and The Man Who Walked Through Time [2] were the initial sources.
    • Steadfast Provisions makes pemmican, which Doug and his daughter tested on several hikes for utility and taste.

    What pemmican is

    • Pemmican takes its name from a Cree word for fat or grease; Native American peoples and early explorers used it as the ultimate survival food known as the 'bread of the wilderness.'
    • Pemmican consists of smoked and dried meat pounded into powder and mixed with hot rendered fat to form a bar; dried fruit can add sweetness.
    • Pemmican is concentrated, rich meat and fat, with substantial nourishment in a small portion.

    Shelf life and nutrition

    • With little to no water, pemmican has a long shelf life: estimates reach five years, with some accounts exceeding fifty years under suitable conditions.
    • Steadfast pemmican has a maker-cited USDA shelf-stability rating of two years. [3]
    • At approximately 50% fat by volume, pemmican is lightweight and calorie-dense because water adds weight without calories.
    • Pemmican suits keto, paleo, and other low-carbohydrate diets and can be added to stir-fried vegetables or eggs.
    • Steadfast pemmican uses grass-fed beef and tallow, sources of omega-3 fats, vitamins E and B, and iron, potassium, magnesium, zinc, selenium, and phosphorus.

    Formats and flavors

    • The 3-hour bar contains 750 calories, 40 g protein, and 60 g fat; the 1 kg 3-day brick contains 6,000 calories, 340 g protein, and 510 g fat.
    • The 4 oz 'bacon butter' spread contains pork fat, 750 calories, 40 g protein, and 60 g fat, for direct eating or addition to other foods.
    • The options are unseasoned beef and tallow, salted, and seasoned pemmican; the seasoned version contains salt, pepper, onion, garlic, and a little honey.

    How to eat it

    • Small, slowly chewed bites suit pemmican's richness; one bite can contain 100 calories. [3]
    • A thousand calories of pemmican can relieve hunger without the stomach fullness of a thousand-calorie burrito. [3]
    • Water should be drunk with pemmican because the dried meat absorbs water in the stomach. [3]
    • Room-temperature tallow is solid, coats the mouth as it melts, and leaves a pleasant lingering fatty-meat taste. [3]
    • North American Native peoples obtained up to 40% of calories from saturated animal fat and were free of obesity and heart disease; this is a reason to savor tallow. [3]

    Our trail taste test

    • Doug and his daughter initially found its texture sandy and granular, unlike a soft hamburger.
    • Slow eating improved the experience; both enjoyed it, wanted more, and avoided the ravenous hunger that usually follows hiking.
    • Plain pemmican tasted like a refrigerated leftover hamburger; Doug preferred the salted one, the seasoned one resembled a homemade burger, and bacon butter was especially good.
    • Doug plans to carry pemmican on longer hikes because it enables carrying meat into the wilderness without the usual concern about spoilage.

    Packing after opening

    • The wrapper instructs refrigeration after opening, making packaging important for a longer trip.
    • Stagnant moist air and water cause spoilage; vacuum-sealing excludes air, while a paper bag or perforated plastic bag permits air circulation. [4]
    • Without refrigeration, the package can be opened several times daily, with excess air squeezed out when closing it. [4]
    • A sour smell in repackaged pemmican indicates likely rancidity and is a reason not to eat it.

    References

    1. [00:30] The Complete Walker: The Joys and Techniques of Hiking and Backpacking — https://books.google.com/books?id=S7sgAQAAIAAJ
    2. [00:33] The Man Who Walked Through Time — https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/50421/the-man-who-walked-through-time-by-colin-fletcher/

     

    Yvonne talks about her journey on the carnivore diet.

    generated summary

    Background: weight, fasting, and pain (00:00–04:45)

    • In 2013, Yvonne and her husband tried Dr. Michael Mosley's 5:2 diet after watching his fasting documentary, with approximately 500 calories on two days per week. [1]
    • Both lost weight, but her husband felt very weak during physical work on a fasting day; they gradually resumed ordinary meals, including bread and pasta, while maintaining some weight loss.
    • Earlier motel and aged-care cleaning strained Yvonne's knees and lower back; ten years of handling heavy buckets in a macadamia-processing factory also left her exhausted.
    • Medical scans found a back problem. Private care in Brisbane was expensive, and she hoped weight loss would ease the pressure.
    • Her earlier weight was roughly 90–100 kg; on 5:2 it fell as low as approximately 80 kg before stabilizing near 85 kg. Fortnightly plasma donations allowed regular weight tracking.
    • Despite the lower weight, she continued to have knee pain, hand arthritis, and lower-back problems.

    Discovering carnivore and having knee surgery (04:45–09:10)

    • Around 2020–22, her husband found a carnivore source; they initially found an all-meat diet drastic but decided to try it.
    • Doctors had recommended surgery for both knees, with the left worse and slightly bowed. Improving her knees was a major reason for the dietary change.
    • They started around their grandson's wedding in mid-2022. Her husband ate pizza toppings without crust, while Yvonne ate some crust; they adopted the diet more fully afterward.
    • They worked through unfamiliar questions about tracking protein and fat intake and adjusting established habits.
    • Her weight fell to approximately 75 kg and later stabilized around 79–80 kg. Her husband also lost weight, potentially including water weight.
    • In 2022, aged 69, Yvonne underwent a left-knee replacement because that knee was worse.
    • She walked on the afternoon of surgery and left hospital after about a day and a half. Hospital staff were impressed with her early recovery.
    • She continued carnivore eating and performed the prescribed exercises, including stair practice. Six physiotherapy visits were allocated, but she was discharged after three because her leg mobility was good.

    Walking, symptoms, and the second knee (09:10–13:10)

    • After the death of their previous dog, they adopted a rescue dog before Christmas 2022, providing a reason to exercise her operated leg.
    • Beginning in February 2023, her walks progressed from a roughly one-kilometre track to about five kilometres a day, with a 1.5-km round-trip walk to the mailbox, sometimes twice daily.
    • Her lower-back pain disappeared, and her hands felt substantially better despite earlier arthritis.
    • Her childhood eczema, affecting her hands and the backs of her knees and often aggravated by humidity, has remained absent.
    • A dentist rebuilt a broken tooth; a year later, the dentist found no detectable decay and improving gums. Yvonne associates these dental findings with her way of eating.
    • She has no recent blood-work results because she rarely visits doctors. She takes no medication and uses magnesium and iodine supplements.
    • At the three-month surgical review, she declined surgery for the other knee because it was doing well. She still has occasional mild pain, which subsides after walking begins.

    Children's dietary changes (13:10–17:50)

    • On visits to her son near Mackay, Yvonne brought bacon, a frying pan, and her cast-iron cooking routine, initially unusual to him.
    • About two years earlier, he adopted a stricter carnivore diet and stopped his regular rum-and-Coke drinking; he also eats and supplies fish through his fishing work.
    • Yvonne and her husband's staples are beef, eggs, bacon, and butter, with occasional avocado or homegrown seasonal oranges; she has not noticed problems after these exceptions.
    • Her daughter was initially concerned about dining out but began following a similar diet approximately 12 months earlier.
    • Her daughter has become slimmer around her hips, reduced her asthma inhaler use, and completed her hundredth Saturday parkrun.
    • Her son also rarely needs his asthma inhaler now; other people notice her daughter's physical change more readily than her daughter does.
    • Questions about cholesterol persist when others hear about the family's diet, alongside comments about visible changes.

    Husband's mobility and medical training (17:50–21:50)

    • Her husband continues strict carnivore eating, but his knees remain in poor condition and limit movement. He avoids doctors, has explored exercises and other options, and still wants to continue the diet.
    • They reduced habitual late-night jerky and other snacks; her husband reduced weak coffee with cream from about seven cups to three daily.
    • Yvonne generally drinks two coffees, water, and caffeine-free rooibos tea, occasionally with cream.
    • Their granddaughter is studying medicine and has been interested in cardiology; her brother is also entering university medical studies.
    • Yvonne encourages them to seek root causes and lifestyle approaches beyond prescriptions, while acknowledging pressures within conventional medical training.

    Meals, costs, and food waste (21:50–27:10)

    • They usually eat one meal a day around 2–3 p.m.; weekend breakfasts include eggs, bacon, and sometimes steak.
    • After a large breakfast they may have only cheese or salami later. Regular meals include steak, mince, and lamb chops, plus occasional fish, prawns, or crab supplied by relatives.
    • As pensioners, they find their diet cheaper overall; ribeye is outside their budget, and rump steak is their usual purchase.
    • Yvonne buys whole rump cuts on discount, cuts steaks, and smokes the rump cap for about three hours before slicing, searing, and serving it with eggs; she also smokes bacon and ham.
    • She buys approximately five dozen locally supplied free-range eggs each week, stores boiled eggs, and makes meals combining eggs with mince.
    • She experiences little food waste now, unlike the vegetables that previously spoiled in the fridge.
    • When dining out, she orders steak without side dishes and brings butter from home.

    Friends, relatives, and changing the household (27:10–33:45)

    • A South Australian friend asked Yvonne about carnivore; she sent material from Dave, Shawn, Dr. Baker, and Dr. Berry, without knowing whether he adopted the diet.
    • A former colleague interpreted her weight loss as a possible sign of cancer; Yvonne explained that she had changed her diet.
    • Yvonne's late brother developed insulin-dependent diabetes at approximately 58. She wonders whether different dietary guidance could have prolonged his life, while acknowledging uncertainty.
    • Her husband's late sister had become severely overweight, frequently ate biscuits and ready-made meals, and had ongoing chest problems. Yvonne urged her to reduce carbohydrates and sugar, but she did not do so.
    • Dave links these habits to their social normality and hormones overriding dietary intentions despite awareness of poor food choices; Yvonne agrees.
    • They cleared flour, rice, and vegetables from cupboards and the freezer, passed food to their daughter, and made room for meat.
    • Some grandchildren continue eating plenty of rice in their Thai family diet alongside Western sweets; a 14-year-old has become interested in her father's carnivore diet.

    Starting and staying with carnivore (33:45–35:55)

    • For beginners, Yvonne favors reducing foods gradually to ease the transition, while accepting that an immediate switch can work depending on the individual.
    • They had previously eaten nearly keto and reduced carbohydrates, easing their transition; neither experienced keto flu.
    • Yvonne and her husband intend to continue eating mainly meat, eggs, bacon, and butter indefinitely as their lifestyle.

    References

    1. [00:21] Horizon: Eat, Fast and Live Longer (2012) — https://era.org.uk/streaming-service-resource/eat-fast-and-live-longer-horizon/

    Matambre (en.wikipedia.org)
     

    Matambre is the name of a very thin cut of beef in Argentina, Uruguay, Rio Grande do Sul and also Paraguay. It is a rose-colored muscle taken between the skin and the ribs of the steer,[1] a sort of flank steak. It is not the cut known normally in the U.S. as flank steak. Some people refer to it as the "fly shaker", because it is the muscle used by the animal to twitch to repel flies and other flying insects.

     

    I have the opportunity to sit down with my cousin Natalie Holmes, who has been following a carnivore diet for the past three and a half years. Despite our shared family history of cardiovascular disease and diabetes, we took very different approaches to nutrition. After years of struggling with trigeminal neuralgia, debilitating nerve pain, and the side effects of medication, Natalie began exploring the carnivore diet in search of a different path forward. What started as a one-month experiment turned into a major change in how she approaches food and her health. We talk about Natalie's experience with carnivore, the changes she noticed in her brain fog, skin, joint pain, weight, and overall quality of life, and how her experience led her to rethink what she had previously believed about nutrition. We also dive into insulin resistance, inflammation, carbohydrates, cholesterol, and the relationship between metabolic health and cardiovascular disease.

    generated summary

    [00:00–01:10] Family cardiovascular history and different diets

    • Jamie Delaney's cousin Natalie Holmes has followed carnivore for years, while Jamie previously followed a plant-based diet; Natalie initially withheld this because Jamie was vegan.
    • Their family history includes an overweight grandmother with diabetes who died of heart failure at 57, a grandfather who died of a heart attack in his late 40s, and heart disease in parents and uncles; Jamie's mother lived to 90.

    [01:10–05:30] Trigeminal neuralgia and the decision to try carnivore

    • Approximately 12 years earlier, Natalie developed severe electrical pain in her right jaw. After about two years of negative dental examinations and extraction of two healthy teeth without relief, an oral surgeon identified trigeminal neuralgia, subsequently diagnosed by a Philadelphia neurologist.
    • Carbamazepine initially relieved pain at 100 mg, but the dose rose to 1,200 mg over approximately 12–18 months, accompanied by severe brain fog, word-finding difficulty, crying, and impaired functioning.
    • Natalie underwent microvascular decompression after Dr. Lee at the University of Pennsylvania evaluated her MRI; she remained pain-free for two years.
    • After approximately three weeks of severe COVID, facial pain returned. Her neurologist attributed the recurrence to COVID affecting a vulnerable nerve, and carbamazepine rose from 100 mg to approximately 400–500 mg.
    • Dr. Lee declined an early repeat of invasive brain surgery and offered other options, including radiation, which Natalie rejected; she then sought other ways to control the pain.
    • Natalie encountered accounts from Anthony Chaffee, Shawn Baker, and Ken Berry of improvements in multiple sclerosis symptoms, Hashimoto's disease, arthritis, and diabetes among carnivore followers.
    • Mike, Natalie's husband and household cook, supported a one-month trial of beef, butter, bacon, and eggs; three and a half years later she continues the diet and experiences better well-being.

    [05:30–10:10] Nerve pain, ketosis, and Natalie's changes

    • Trigeminal neuralgia affects the fifth cranial nerve and can cause disabling electric-shock pain triggered by movement or cold; surgery has variable success, and antiseizure medication can impair mental function.
    • Jamie links ketogenic or carnivore eating to increased ketone use, reduced glucose dependence, and lower inflammation, as a possible mechanism for less nerve pain.
    • Natalie had followed a less strict ketogenic diet for several years; within about two weeks of carnivore, she experienced clearer thinking and a stronger sense of smell.
    • Natalie's longstanding foot tendinitis, previously severe enough to impair walking, resolved in the first few months; her rosacea also cleared and her skin improved.
    • A dermatologist had diagnosed psoriasis by biopsy on both lower legs, previously managed with biologic injections every three months; Natalie has experienced no psoriasis on her legs for years.
    • Natalie experiences better sleep, an unintended 35-pound weight loss, and improved quality of life, which she associates with reduced inflammation.
    • A vessel contacting Natalie's trigeminal nerve had damaged its protective sheath; she attributes three and a half years without electrical pain to reduced nerve inflammation during carnivore eating.
    • Natalie initially continued carbamazepine because of concern about pain recurrence, began tapering approximately six or seven months after starting carnivore, and has not needed it since.

    [10:10–13:20] Social reactions, her physician, and screening

    • Friends questioned the adequacy of a diet without fruit, vegetables, or fiber and feared constipation; Natalie believes animal foods meet her nutritional needs and follows Steak and Butter Girl, Courtney Luna, and Laura Spath.
    • Natalie's physician Julie responded positively after observing changes in her weight and physical condition and welcomed her carnivore diet.
    • Natalie no longer undergoes mammograms, Pap smears, or colonoscopies, despite disagreement from some friends.
    • Jamie questions screening that can lead to earlier diagnosis without improved quality or length of life, says no screening test has demonstrated longer survival, and identifies possible financial incentives.
    • Abnormal findings, including incidental nodules, can create ongoing worry without a clear action; Jamie favors individualized screening decisions over uniform protocols.

    [13:20–16:55] Carnivore meals, weight, and food preparation

    • Natalie favors bacon cheeseburgers, sometimes two at dinner, along with filet mignon, ribeye, scallops, shrimp, eggs, and bacon; she usually eats after 11 a.m. and consumes substantial, satiating meals.
    • Her household uses 80/20 ground beef, marbled meat, tallow, bacon grease, and butter; Natalie does not track macronutrients, ketones, or body weight.
    • Weight Watchers, Jenny Craig, and repeated weight fluctuations preceded an unplanned 35-pound loss on carnivore, with less ongoing attention to weight.
    • Jamie's former plant-based meals involved substantial shopping, vegetable preparation, bean burgers, seitan, and salads; animal-based meals such as steak, burgers, or eggs and bacon require much less preparation.

    [17:00–20:00] Insulin, sugar cravings, and physical recovery

    • Jamie identifies elevated fasting insulin despite normal glucose and HbA1c as a metabolic concern and links insulin and inflammation to hypertension, cancer, cardiovascular disease, and mental health problems.
    • Jamie links dietary choices to chronic illness and views dietary change as a means of improving health before reliance on screening, medication, or procedures, with animal foods supplying nutrients.
    • Natalie no longer desires desserts at parties; early in the dietary change, she used an analogy she tentatively attributes to Courtney Luna, equating sugar with poison, to resist cravings.
    • Jamie experienced better performance during a run without carbohydrate intake and unusually little soreness afterward and spoke with professor Andrew Koutnik about the recovery.
    • Jamie experienced resolution of a two-year running-related ankle problem after changing diet, without the prior recurrent pain and inflammation.

    [20:00–23:30] Eating out, electrolytes, and dietary fiber

    • Natalie initially encountered confusion when ordering burgers without buns or sides and now openly identifies as carnivore; she sees greater visibility through Ken Berry on Fox News and Kennedy's meat-heavy diet with fermented vegetables.
    • Natalie uses a daily electrolyte packet, three drops of iodine for perceived thyroid support, and previously used potassium for early leg cramps.
    • Jamie experienced severe calf cramps while traveling in Alaska without the electrolyte drinks normally consumed during running.
    • Jamie links the historical belief that fiber prevents colorectal cancer to observational evidence and says subsequent testing did not confirm it.
    • Jamie associates high fiber intake with nutrient loss alongside cholesterol loss and recalls possible malabsorption in plant-based patients and in Jamie's own experience; Shawn Baker made a similar remark about vegetable waste.
    • Jamie links sufficient animal fat and hydration to bowel regularity and views animal foods as nutritionally complete without required dietary fiber.

    [23:30–27:55] Diet adaptation, insulin resistance, and satiety

    • Natalie's sister Lori experienced no weight loss during three weeks of carnivore; Natalie associates initial weight gain, malaise, and slow adaptation with a period of detoxification and recalls Steak and Butter Girl recounting a gain of about 35 pounds.
    • Natalie associates abrupt carbohydrate reduction with fatigue and "keto flu" and believes that adaptation can take time.
    • Jamie adopts Andrew Koutnik's explanation that carbohydrate intake increases insulin and limits access to stored fat until insulin decreases and glycogen is depleted, making weight loss difficult in insulin resistance.
    • Bread, pasta, and diabetes are common in the family's history; older generations relied on carbohydrate staples when meat was less available, while processed carbohydrate foods now dominate many diets.
    • Jamie previously consumed approximately 70% of calories from carbohydrate and experienced frequent hunger; patients who removed junk food still struggled with sustained weight loss, while fat-rich meals provide greater satiety.
    • Childhood pressure to finish meals contributed to Natalie's overeating in adulthood; she now stops eating when comfortably satisfied, even if food remains.

    [27:55–32:25] Blaming dietary fat and interpreting cholesterol

    • Jamie formerly linked the weight of relatives who cooked with lard to dietary fat, but now attributes more of that weight to potatoes, dumplings, pies, sweetened vegetables, and sugar.
    • Jamie recalls patients blaming meat while also eating substantial donuts and sugar and views dietary fat as unfairly stigmatized; Natalie views conventional dietary guidance as inverted.
    • Natalie's three rounds of blood testing since beginning carnivore have improved by her account except for rising cholesterol, which does not concern her.
    • Natalie's chiropractor told her that no study has demonstrated cholesterol causes heart attacks; Jamie also rejects the idea that cholesterol's presence in vascular disease alone establishes causation.
    • Jamie has seen heart attacks with cholesterol values around 150 and 220 and recalls diabetes or insulin resistance in nearly all such patients, alongside substantial metabolic illness in the family.
    • Jamie links insulin to inflammation and changes in cholesterol particles; cholesterol is synthesized by cells and abundant in the brain, while dietary carbohydrate is not essential in the same sense as essential nutrients.

    [32:25–34:55] My predominantly animal-based diet

    • Amber O'Hearn and Shawn Baker influenced the modern carnivore movement; Jamie prioritizes nutrient density over strict membership in the dietary category.
    • Jamie eats mainly animal products while retaining coffee with cream and occasional salad, broccoli, or tomato; past experiences of strict boundaries in plant-based communities influence Jamie's flexible approach.
    • Jamie focuses on dietary fat relative to protein to support ketosis, with the aim of improving previously developed insulin resistance.

    [34:55–39:00] Meatstock, a one-month trial, holidays, and heart imaging

    • Jamie and Natalie plan to attend Meatstock in Nashville and eat barbecue; Natalie finds chicken less satisfying than richer meats.
    • Natalie encourages people with arthritis, diabetes, or multiple sclerosis symptoms to try carnivore for one month, drawing on her own three-and-a-half-year experience after an intended one-month trial.
    • At Thanksgiving Natalie eats turkey and some gravy while family members eat traditional sides; Jamie has seen no meaningful glucose rise on a continuous glucose monitor after eating Addie's low-carbohydrate desserts.
    • Jamie underwent CT angiography on the day of the interview to assess cardiovascular disease risk after periods of plant-based and carnivore eating; no imaging results are provided.

     

    Comedy carbs are getting out of hand...

    generated summary

    Comedy carbs and their uses [00:00–01:41]

    • Carnivore bread, pizza, doughnuts, and ice cream mirror vegan mock meats: animal products are made to resemble carbohydrate-based foods. These are "comedy carbs."
    • These recipes omit flour, grains, seed oils, emulsifiers, and large amounts of sugar.
    • They can function as "dietary training wheels" for beginners: carnivore pizza instead of takeaway pizza, or carnivore ice cream at a party, lets families participate without deprivation or exclusion.

    Simplicity, overeating, and cravings [01:41–02:56]

    • Carnivore meals such as steak take around 10 minutes to cook with little cleanup; elaborate imitation recipes require more equipment, preparation, cooking, and washing up.
    • Natural satiety makes a fatty ribeye or scrambled eggs difficult to overeat; artificially sweetened, heavy-cream carnivore ice cream is easier to binge on.
    • Sweet tastes can trigger sugar cravings and a dopamine response, making dietary adherence harder even without sugar.
    • Recreating sweet or starchy foods sustains cravings and a sweet tooth. Needing meat to look like a doughnut indicates continuing psychological dependence on the standard modern diet.
    • A properly cooked steak is palatable without being made to resemble bread or dessert.

    Dairy load and tolerance [02:58–04:13]

    • Many imitation recipes rely mainly on dairy and casein, which are not the most beneficial or ancestrally consistent basis for a carnivore diet.
    • Dairy can be problematic with autoimmune conditions. One speaker experiences blocked sinuses, while reintroducing yogurt causes snoring and congestion for the other.
    • Dairy is not inherently bad, and many people thrive on it; excessive dairy intake is the concern.
    • Caseomorphins and their addictive effects can make cheese difficult to moderate; dairy-heavy imitation foods may interfere with losing the last bit of stubborn fat.
    • These recipes may delay freedom from cravings, called "easy mode," despite making the diet seem easier initially.
    • Large amounts of dairy, processed protein powders, and sweeteners, including stevia, can cause digestive problems and stall healing.

    Whole animal foods versus elaborate powders [04:14–05:03]

    • Eating eggs daily is not especially ancestrally appropriate because eggs would previously have been seasonal.
    • Carnivore baking may combine egg yolks, pasteurized cream, cottage cheese, milk powder, and egg-white powder, baked for half an hour at 160–200°. This differs from simple whole-food eating.
    • Powdered eggs, pork-rind dust, and whey isolate undergo substantial processing and lose the bioavailable qualities and structure of fresh ruminant meat or whole eggs.
    • A cleaner, ancestrally appropriate, whole-food approach is a reason for eating carnivore, and reliance on powders undermines it.

    Whey, insulin, and satiety [05:03–05:55]

    • Whey protein isolate delivers rapidly absorbed amino acids that cause an insulin spike without carbohydrates, temporarily slowing fat burning and ketone production.
    • Chewing steak activates satiety signals such as gut cholecystokinin; swallowing protein powder bypasses mechanical and hormonal fullness cues, making overconsumption easier.
    • Using these powders for carnivore cakes, pancakes, and breads sustains the physiological and psychological attraction to hyperpalatable sweet and starchy textures.

    Moderation and closing parody [05:56–07:52]

    • Carnivore recipe creators and cookbooks are not targets of criticism; one speaker has written a cookbook in response to audience requests.
    • Comedy carbs have a time and place, but consumption frequency matters.
    • For difficulties with stubborn fat loss, sweet-food moderation, or cravings, reducing comedy carbs and eating simple carnivore food can bring "easy mode" sooner.
    • The closing sketch parodies increasingly implausible imitations: carnivore doughnuts, chocolate, frappuccinos, soda, fruit flavors, and wine.

    References None.

    view more: ‹ prev next ›