I have the opportunity to sit down with my cousin Natalie Holmes, who has been following a carnivore diet for the past three and a half years. Despite our shared family history of cardiovascular disease and diabetes, we took very different approaches to nutrition. After years of struggling with trigeminal neuralgia, debilitating nerve pain, and the side effects of medication, Natalie began exploring the carnivore diet in search of a different path forward. What started as a one-month experiment turned into a major change in how she approaches food and her health.
We talk about Natalie's experience with carnivore, the changes she noticed in her brain fog, skin, joint pain, weight, and overall quality of life, and how her experience led her to rethink what she had previously believed about nutrition. We also dive into insulin resistance, inflammation, carbohydrates, cholesterol, and the relationship between metabolic health and cardiovascular disease.
generated summary
[00:00–01:10] Family cardiovascular history and different diets
- Jamie Delaney's cousin Natalie Holmes has followed carnivore for years, while Jamie previously followed a plant-based diet; Natalie initially withheld this because Jamie was vegan.
- Their family history includes an overweight grandmother with diabetes who died of heart failure at 57, a grandfather who died of a heart attack in his late 40s, and heart disease in parents and uncles; Jamie's mother lived to 90.
[01:10–05:30] Trigeminal neuralgia and the decision to try carnivore
- Approximately 12 years earlier, Natalie developed severe electrical pain in her right jaw. After about two years of negative dental examinations and extraction of two healthy teeth without relief, an oral surgeon identified trigeminal neuralgia, subsequently diagnosed by a Philadelphia neurologist.
- Carbamazepine initially relieved pain at 100 mg, but the dose rose to 1,200 mg over approximately 12–18 months, accompanied by severe brain fog, word-finding difficulty, crying, and impaired functioning.
- Natalie underwent microvascular decompression after Dr. Lee at the University of Pennsylvania evaluated her MRI; she remained pain-free for two years.
- After approximately three weeks of severe COVID, facial pain returned. Her neurologist attributed the recurrence to COVID affecting a vulnerable nerve, and carbamazepine rose from 100 mg to approximately 400–500 mg.
- Dr. Lee declined an early repeat of invasive brain surgery and offered other options, including radiation, which Natalie rejected; she then sought other ways to control the pain.
- Natalie encountered accounts from Anthony Chaffee, Shawn Baker, and Ken Berry of improvements in multiple sclerosis symptoms, Hashimoto's disease, arthritis, and diabetes among carnivore followers.
- Mike, Natalie's husband and household cook, supported a one-month trial of beef, butter, bacon, and eggs; three and a half years later she continues the diet and experiences better well-being.
[05:30–10:10] Nerve pain, ketosis, and Natalie's changes
- Trigeminal neuralgia affects the fifth cranial nerve and can cause disabling electric-shock pain triggered by movement or cold; surgery has variable success, and antiseizure medication can impair mental function.
- Jamie links ketogenic or carnivore eating to increased ketone use, reduced glucose dependence, and lower inflammation, as a possible mechanism for less nerve pain.
- Natalie had followed a less strict ketogenic diet for several years; within about two weeks of carnivore, she experienced clearer thinking and a stronger sense of smell.
- Natalie's longstanding foot tendinitis, previously severe enough to impair walking, resolved in the first few months; her rosacea also cleared and her skin improved.
- A dermatologist had diagnosed psoriasis by biopsy on both lower legs, previously managed with biologic injections every three months; Natalie has experienced no psoriasis on her legs for years.
- Natalie experiences better sleep, an unintended 35-pound weight loss, and improved quality of life, which she associates with reduced inflammation.
- A vessel contacting Natalie's trigeminal nerve had damaged its protective sheath; she attributes three and a half years without electrical pain to reduced nerve inflammation during carnivore eating.
- Natalie initially continued carbamazepine because of concern about pain recurrence, began tapering approximately six or seven months after starting carnivore, and has not needed it since.
[10:10–13:20] Social reactions, her physician, and screening
- Friends questioned the adequacy of a diet without fruit, vegetables, or fiber and feared constipation; Natalie believes animal foods meet her nutritional needs and follows Steak and Butter Girl, Courtney Luna, and Laura Spath.
- Natalie's physician Julie responded positively after observing changes in her weight and physical condition and welcomed her carnivore diet.
- Natalie no longer undergoes mammograms, Pap smears, or colonoscopies, despite disagreement from some friends.
- Jamie questions screening that can lead to earlier diagnosis without improved quality or length of life, says no screening test has demonstrated longer survival, and identifies possible financial incentives.
- Abnormal findings, including incidental nodules, can create ongoing worry without a clear action; Jamie favors individualized screening decisions over uniform protocols.
[13:20–16:55] Carnivore meals, weight, and food preparation
- Natalie favors bacon cheeseburgers, sometimes two at dinner, along with filet mignon, ribeye, scallops, shrimp, eggs, and bacon; she usually eats after 11 a.m. and consumes substantial, satiating meals.
- Her household uses 80/20 ground beef, marbled meat, tallow, bacon grease, and butter; Natalie does not track macronutrients, ketones, or body weight.
- Weight Watchers, Jenny Craig, and repeated weight fluctuations preceded an unplanned 35-pound loss on carnivore, with less ongoing attention to weight.
- Jamie's former plant-based meals involved substantial shopping, vegetable preparation, bean burgers, seitan, and salads; animal-based meals such as steak, burgers, or eggs and bacon require much less preparation.
[17:00–20:00] Insulin, sugar cravings, and physical recovery
- Jamie identifies elevated fasting insulin despite normal glucose and HbA1c as a metabolic concern and links insulin and inflammation to hypertension, cancer, cardiovascular disease, and mental health problems.
- Jamie links dietary choices to chronic illness and views dietary change as a means of improving health before reliance on screening, medication, or procedures, with animal foods supplying nutrients.
- Natalie no longer desires desserts at parties; early in the dietary change, she used an analogy she tentatively attributes to Courtney Luna, equating sugar with poison, to resist cravings.
- Jamie experienced better performance during a run without carbohydrate intake and unusually little soreness afterward and spoke with professor Andrew Koutnik about the recovery.
- Jamie experienced resolution of a two-year running-related ankle problem after changing diet, without the prior recurrent pain and inflammation.
[20:00–23:30] Eating out, electrolytes, and dietary fiber
- Natalie initially encountered confusion when ordering burgers without buns or sides and now openly identifies as carnivore; she sees greater visibility through Ken Berry on Fox News and Kennedy's meat-heavy diet with fermented vegetables.
- Natalie uses a daily electrolyte packet, three drops of iodine for perceived thyroid support, and previously used potassium for early leg cramps.
- Jamie experienced severe calf cramps while traveling in Alaska without the electrolyte drinks normally consumed during running.
- Jamie links the historical belief that fiber prevents colorectal cancer to observational evidence and says subsequent testing did not confirm it.
- Jamie associates high fiber intake with nutrient loss alongside cholesterol loss and recalls possible malabsorption in plant-based patients and in Jamie's own experience; Shawn Baker made a similar remark about vegetable waste.
- Jamie links sufficient animal fat and hydration to bowel regularity and views animal foods as nutritionally complete without required dietary fiber.
[23:30–27:55] Diet adaptation, insulin resistance, and satiety
- Natalie's sister Lori experienced no weight loss during three weeks of carnivore; Natalie associates initial weight gain, malaise, and slow adaptation with a period of detoxification and recalls Steak and Butter Girl recounting a gain of about 35 pounds.
- Natalie associates abrupt carbohydrate reduction with fatigue and "keto flu" and believes that adaptation can take time.
- Jamie adopts Andrew Koutnik's explanation that carbohydrate intake increases insulin and limits access to stored fat until insulin decreases and glycogen is depleted, making weight loss difficult in insulin resistance.
- Bread, pasta, and diabetes are common in the family's history; older generations relied on carbohydrate staples when meat was less available, while processed carbohydrate foods now dominate many diets.
- Jamie previously consumed approximately 70% of calories from carbohydrate and experienced frequent hunger; patients who removed junk food still struggled with sustained weight loss, while fat-rich meals provide greater satiety.
- Childhood pressure to finish meals contributed to Natalie's overeating in adulthood; she now stops eating when comfortably satisfied, even if food remains.
[27:55–32:25] Blaming dietary fat and interpreting cholesterol
- Jamie formerly linked the weight of relatives who cooked with lard to dietary fat, but now attributes more of that weight to potatoes, dumplings, pies, sweetened vegetables, and sugar.
- Jamie recalls patients blaming meat while also eating substantial donuts and sugar and views dietary fat as unfairly stigmatized; Natalie views conventional dietary guidance as inverted.
- Natalie's three rounds of blood testing since beginning carnivore have improved by her account except for rising cholesterol, which does not concern her.
- Natalie's chiropractor told her that no study has demonstrated cholesterol causes heart attacks; Jamie also rejects the idea that cholesterol's presence in vascular disease alone establishes causation.
- Jamie has seen heart attacks with cholesterol values around 150 and 220 and recalls diabetes or insulin resistance in nearly all such patients, alongside substantial metabolic illness in the family.
- Jamie links insulin to inflammation and changes in cholesterol particles; cholesterol is synthesized by cells and abundant in the brain, while dietary carbohydrate is not essential in the same sense as essential nutrients.
[32:25–34:55] My predominantly animal-based diet
- Amber O'Hearn and Shawn Baker influenced the modern carnivore movement; Jamie prioritizes nutrient density over strict membership in the dietary category.
- Jamie eats mainly animal products while retaining coffee with cream and occasional salad, broccoli, or tomato; past experiences of strict boundaries in plant-based communities influence Jamie's flexible approach.
- Jamie focuses on dietary fat relative to protein to support ketosis, with the aim of improving previously developed insulin resistance.
[34:55–39:00] Meatstock, a one-month trial, holidays, and heart imaging
- Jamie and Natalie plan to attend Meatstock in Nashville and eat barbecue; Natalie finds chicken less satisfying than richer meats.
- Natalie encourages people with arthritis, diabetes, or multiple sclerosis symptoms to try carnivore for one month, drawing on her own three-and-a-half-year experience after an intended one-month trial.
- At Thanksgiving Natalie eats turkey and some gravy while family members eat traditional sides; Jamie has seen no meaningful glucose rise on a continuous glucose monitor after eating Addie's low-carbohydrate desserts.
- Jamie underwent CT angiography on the day of the interview to assess cardiovascular disease risk after periods of plant-based and carnivore eating; no imaging results are provided.