Yvonne talks about her journey on the carnivore diet.
generated summary
Background: weight, fasting, and pain (00:00–04:45)
- In 2013, Yvonne and her husband tried Dr. Michael Mosley's 5:2 diet after watching his fasting documentary, with approximately 500 calories on two days per week. [1]
- Both lost weight, but her husband felt very weak during physical work on a fasting day; they gradually resumed ordinary meals, including bread and pasta, while maintaining some weight loss.
- Earlier motel and aged-care cleaning strained Yvonne's knees and lower back; ten years of handling heavy buckets in a macadamia-processing factory also left her exhausted.
- Medical scans found a back problem. Private care in Brisbane was expensive, and she hoped weight loss would ease the pressure.
- Her earlier weight was roughly 90–100 kg; on 5:2 it fell as low as approximately 80 kg before stabilizing near 85 kg. Fortnightly plasma donations allowed regular weight tracking.
- Despite the lower weight, she continued to have knee pain, hand arthritis, and lower-back problems.
Discovering carnivore and having knee surgery (04:45–09:10)
- Around 2020–22, her husband found a carnivore source; they initially found an all-meat diet drastic but decided to try it.
- Doctors had recommended surgery for both knees, with the left worse and slightly bowed. Improving her knees was a major reason for the dietary change.
- They started around their grandson's wedding in mid-2022. Her husband ate pizza toppings without crust, while Yvonne ate some crust; they adopted the diet more fully afterward.
- They worked through unfamiliar questions about tracking protein and fat intake and adjusting established habits.
- Her weight fell to approximately 75 kg and later stabilized around 79–80 kg. Her husband also lost weight, potentially including water weight.
- In 2022, aged 69, Yvonne underwent a left-knee replacement because that knee was worse.
- She walked on the afternoon of surgery and left hospital after about a day and a half. Hospital staff were impressed with her early recovery.
- She continued carnivore eating and performed the prescribed exercises, including stair practice. Six physiotherapy visits were allocated, but she was discharged after three because her leg mobility was good.
Walking, symptoms, and the second knee (09:10–13:10)
- After the death of their previous dog, they adopted a rescue dog before Christmas 2022, providing a reason to exercise her operated leg.
- Beginning in February 2023, her walks progressed from a roughly one-kilometre track to about five kilometres a day, with a 1.5-km round-trip walk to the mailbox, sometimes twice daily.
- Her lower-back pain disappeared, and her hands felt substantially better despite earlier arthritis.
- Her childhood eczema, affecting her hands and the backs of her knees and often aggravated by humidity, has remained absent.
- A dentist rebuilt a broken tooth; a year later, the dentist found no detectable decay and improving gums. Yvonne associates these dental findings with her way of eating.
- She has no recent blood-work results because she rarely visits doctors. She takes no medication and uses magnesium and iodine supplements.
- At the three-month surgical review, she declined surgery for the other knee because it was doing well. She still has occasional mild pain, which subsides after walking begins.
Children's dietary changes (13:10–17:50)
- On visits to her son near Mackay, Yvonne brought bacon, a frying pan, and her cast-iron cooking routine, initially unusual to him.
- About two years earlier, he adopted a stricter carnivore diet and stopped his regular rum-and-Coke drinking; he also eats and supplies fish through his fishing work.
- Yvonne and her husband's staples are beef, eggs, bacon, and butter, with occasional avocado or homegrown seasonal oranges; she has not noticed problems after these exceptions.
- Her daughter was initially concerned about dining out but began following a similar diet approximately 12 months earlier.
- Her daughter has become slimmer around her hips, reduced her asthma inhaler use, and completed her hundredth Saturday parkrun.
- Her son also rarely needs his asthma inhaler now; other people notice her daughter's physical change more readily than her daughter does.
- Questions about cholesterol persist when others hear about the family's diet, alongside comments about visible changes.
Husband's mobility and medical training (17:50–21:50)
- Her husband continues strict carnivore eating, but his knees remain in poor condition and limit movement. He avoids doctors, has explored exercises and other options, and still wants to continue the diet.
- They reduced habitual late-night jerky and other snacks; her husband reduced weak coffee with cream from about seven cups to three daily.
- Yvonne generally drinks two coffees, water, and caffeine-free rooibos tea, occasionally with cream.
- Their granddaughter is studying medicine and has been interested in cardiology; her brother is also entering university medical studies.
- Yvonne encourages them to seek root causes and lifestyle approaches beyond prescriptions, while acknowledging pressures within conventional medical training.
Meals, costs, and food waste (21:50–27:10)
- They usually eat one meal a day around 2–3 p.m.; weekend breakfasts include eggs, bacon, and sometimes steak.
- After a large breakfast they may have only cheese or salami later. Regular meals include steak, mince, and lamb chops, plus occasional fish, prawns, or crab supplied by relatives.
- As pensioners, they find their diet cheaper overall; ribeye is outside their budget, and rump steak is their usual purchase.
- Yvonne buys whole rump cuts on discount, cuts steaks, and smokes the rump cap for about three hours before slicing, searing, and serving it with eggs; she also smokes bacon and ham.
- She buys approximately five dozen locally supplied free-range eggs each week, stores boiled eggs, and makes meals combining eggs with mince.
- She experiences little food waste now, unlike the vegetables that previously spoiled in the fridge.
- When dining out, she orders steak without side dishes and brings butter from home.
Friends, relatives, and changing the household (27:10–33:45)
- A South Australian friend asked Yvonne about carnivore; she sent material from Dave, Shawn, Dr. Baker, and Dr. Berry, without knowing whether he adopted the diet.
- A former colleague interpreted her weight loss as a possible sign of cancer; Yvonne explained that she had changed her diet.
- Yvonne's late brother developed insulin-dependent diabetes at approximately 58. She wonders whether different dietary guidance could have prolonged his life, while acknowledging uncertainty.
- Her husband's late sister had become severely overweight, frequently ate biscuits and ready-made meals, and had ongoing chest problems. Yvonne urged her to reduce carbohydrates and sugar, but she did not do so.
- Dave links these habits to their social normality and hormones overriding dietary intentions despite awareness of poor food choices; Yvonne agrees.
- They cleared flour, rice, and vegetables from cupboards and the freezer, passed food to their daughter, and made room for meat.
- Some grandchildren continue eating plenty of rice in their Thai family diet alongside Western sweets; a 14-year-old has become interested in her father's carnivore diet.
Starting and staying with carnivore (33:45–35:55)
- For beginners, Yvonne favors reducing foods gradually to ease the transition, while accepting that an immediate switch can work depending on the individual.
- They had previously eaten nearly keto and reduced carbohydrates, easing their transition; neither experienced keto flu.
- Yvonne and her husband intend to continue eating mainly meat, eggs, bacon, and butter indefinitely as their lifestyle.
References
- [00:21] Horizon: Eat, Fast and Live Longer (2012) — https://era.org.uk/streaming-service-resource/eat-fast-and-live-longer-horizon/
no comments (yet)