[–] 2 points 4 months ago

There is no one best diet!

The great thing about runners is they measure against a objective metric, so they know how impactful their diet and lifestyle is against a metric they record over a long period of time.

  • source
  • [–] 1 point 4 months ago

    you were using protein grams, which is the protein content of a steak, not the raw weight of the steak.

    Meat does cause sweating if you eat horrifying amounts and clog up your digestive system.

    meat is fully consumed in the stomach, it doesn't clog up digestion.

    I was causing my liver to hate me and building a caloric surplus vault ending up at around 50% in excess of sensible reserves.

    Meat doesn't stress the liver.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] [S] 2 points 4 months ago (3 children)

    will satisfy you.

    You don't have to satisfy anyone but yourself. If your at peace with your choices - great.

    I haven’t had any health issues for decades. Nor have I needed any supplements.

    fantastic! keep doing whats working for you!

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] [S] 2 points 4 months ago* (7 children)

    Bioengineer yourself into Zaan from farscape? a intelligent plant species

    If I kill an animal myself and eat its flesh vs accidentally trampling or eating a worm trapped in an apple. I would feel worse by the former and try to minimize such circumstances.

    Let me try to square this circle -

    I'm sure you have seen the previous posts on the calculus of death in food production - if your goal is to minimize deaths in total rather then as direct intentional acts - eating one cow a year or two appears to win by a wide margin. However, if you want to say "i don't intend these deaths" you still have to acknowledge the unintentional deaths that are inevitable consequences of the choice even if they are not "intentional".. i.e. drink drivers don't intend to kill people in motor collisions, but its inevitable if they do it enough.

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  • [–] [S] 2 points 4 months ago (9 children)

    In your ideal world, how do you eat food?

    You can't use any soil, because that would impact worms and insects

    You can't use pesticides, because that would impact the insects and also the birds

    You're left with hydroponics? But where do you get the inputs for the hydroponics? They have the same problem.

    It kinda sounds like your going to be Doug Forcett in the good place

  • source
  • parent
  • context
  •  

    Dave Feldman sits down with renowned science journalist Gary Taubes, author of groundbreaking books including "Good Calories, Bad Calories" and "The Case Against Sugar." This first part explores Gary's four-decade journey from physics journalism to becoming one of the most influential critics of nutritional research. The conversation delves deep into the philosophy of science itself, examining why he believes nutrition research has failed so spectacularly. Gary shares his evolution from covering physics breakthroughs at CERN to exposing the fundamental flaws in epidemiological studies that have shaped dietary guidelines for generations. Dave and Gary discuss the challenges of falsifiability in nutrition science, the dangers of emotional investment in hypotheses, and why the field attracts researchers more interested in confirmation than discovery. Gary provides a case for scientific skepticism, and how institutional biases, funding pressures, and cognitive blind spots have led to decades of misguided public health advice that may have caused more harm than good.

    summerizer

    Summary

    This comprehensive discussion with Gary Taubes, an investigative science journalist, delves deeply into the complexities, challenges, and misinterpretations surrounding nutrition science, obesity research, and the broader scientific method. Taubes shares his extensive experience spanning over four decades investigating scientific controversies, including cold fusion and nutrition epidemiology, exposing how deeply ingrained biases, poor experimental design, and sociopolitical factors can distort scientific progress.

    Taubes begins by recounting the cold fusion episode as a case study in bad science—initially hyped discoveries that diminish over time but never fully disappear due to human belief and financial incentives. This example sets the stage for understanding similar dynamics in nutritional science, where simplistic hypotheses like “gluttony and sloth” dominate despite anomalous observations that suggest more complex physiological mechanisms govern fat storage and obesity.

    He reflects on his evolution from physics journalism to nutrition and public health, highlighting the stark contrast between the rigor and falsifiability of physical sciences versus the murky, politically charged, and often poorly controlled world of nutritional epidemiology. Taubes emphasizes the importance of hypothesis testing and notes that many nutrition studies fail to rigorously disprove hypotheses or openly acknowledge negative results due to funding pressures and cultural biases.

    Taubes then provides a detailed historical overview of obesity research, tracing shifting paradigms from 19th-century ideas about energy balance toward more nuanced fuel partitioning and neuroendocrine models of fat storage. He explains how political, cultural, and historical events—especially post-World War II American dominance and the rise of psychological explanations—pushed the field toward simplistic energy balance and behavioral models. These models obscure the reality that fat accumulation can occur independently of calorie intake, governed instead by hormonal and neurological regulation.

    The conversation explores the carbohydrate-insulin model as a modern iteration of the fuel partitioning hypothesis. Taubes and his interlocutor discuss how insulin’s role in fat storage, carbohydrate quality, and metabolic health underlie obesity and related chronic diseases. They highlight the failures of the calorie-centric “energy balance” hypothesis, which is tautological and unable to explain many clinical observations.

    Taubes shares personal anecdotes about his own weight struggles and how low-carbohydrate, high-fat diets profoundly altered his physiology and hunger cues, challenging prevailing dogma. He also discusses the psychological and sociological dimensions of scientific belief systems—how people see and interpret evidence through their cognitive biases and cultural lenses, making paradigm shifts difficult.

    The interview concludes with reflections on the need for better scientific practices, transparency, preregistration of hypotheses, and humility to accept negative results. Taubes underscores the importance of engaging with dissenters thoughtfully and testing hypotheses rigorously, illustrating this with historical cases from physics and medical research.

    Highlights

    • 🔥 Cold fusion exemplifies how scientific hype can persist despite disproven claims due to human belief and financial incentives.
    • ⚖️ The energy balance model of obesity is tautological and fails to explain many anomalous observations about fat storage.
    • 🧬 Fat accumulation is regulated by complex neuroendocrine and hormonal mechanisms, not simply by how much one eats.
    • 🍞 The carbohydrate-insulin model links dietary carbohydrates, insulin secretion, and fat storage, providing a compelling alternative hypothesis.
    • 🧠 Scientific paradigms are strongly influenced by cultural, political, and psychological factors that shape what evidence is accepted.
    • 📉 Nutrition science often suffers from poor experimental design, funding biases, and reluctance to publish negative results.
    • 💡 Rigorous hypothesis testing, preregistration, and open critique are essential for scientific progress but are often lacking in nutrition and epidemiology.

    Key Insights

    • 🔬 Science’s Messy Reality: Cold Fusion and Nutrition as Case Studies
      Taubes uses cold fusion as a metaphor for how scientific enthusiasm can outpace evidence, leading to premature claims that persist despite refutation. This mirrors issues in nutrition science where initial simplistic models (e.g., gluttony causes obesity) dominate despite contradictory physiological evidence. The human tendency to believe in “miracle” explanations and the financial incentives surrounding such narratives impede objective evaluation.

    • ⚖️ Energy Balance Hypothesis: A Circular and Inadequate Explanation
      The calorie-in-calorie-out model is fundamentally tautological: weight gain is assumed to result from overeating because weight gain is observed, not because overeating is objectively measured first. This circular reasoning prevents meaningful falsification. Taubes highlights historical metabolic studies showing that obese individuals often do not eat more than lean individuals, challenging the core premise of energy balance.

    • 🧬 Fuel Partitioning and Neuroendocrine Regulation: The Forgotten Paradigm
      Before WWII, European scientists understood obesity as a disorder of fuel partitioning regulated by hormones and the nervous system, where fat cells’ tendency to store or release fat is governed by insulin and other signals. This nuanced understanding was lost in the post-war American focus on behaviorism and psychological explanations (gluttony and sloth), leading to the dominance of simplistic calorie-centric models.

    • 🍞 Carbohydrate-Insulin Model and Its Implications
      The carbohydrate-insulin model posits that high carbohydrate intake elevates insulin, which promotes fat storage and reduces fat mobilization. This model better explains the rise in obesity and diabetes seen during global nutrition transitions involving increased processed carbohydrate consumption. It also aligns with observed metabolic syndrome features, insulin resistance, and the clinical success of low-carb diets.

    • 🧠 Scientific Belief Systems and Paradigm Entrenchment
      Taubes emphasizes that what scientists observe is filtered through preexisting beliefs, cultural norms, and funding pressures. Paradigm shifts are resisted because new models challenge deeply held assumptions and threaten reputations and funding. This is compounded by the “you have to trust the science” mantra that discourages critical scrutiny and open debate.

    • 📉 Limitations of Nutritional Epidemiology and Publication Bias
      Nutritional epidemiology relies heavily on observational cohorts with self-reported data, leading to confounding and unreliable associations. Further, negative findings are often hidden or spun positively to justify funding, impeding true scientific progress. Taubes advocates for preregistration of hypotheses and transparent reporting of both positive and negative results to improve rigor.

    • 💡 Personal Experience and Empirical Evidence in Shaping Beliefs
      Taubes shares his own experience with weight loss on a low-carb diet, illustrating how personal observation can challenge prevailing dogma. He notes that those who have not experienced obesity often resist alternative models because they lack motivation or evidence from lived experience. This highlights the importance of integrating both scientific data and individual clinical outcomes in forming health guidelines.

    Extended Analysis

    Gary Taubes’ narrative is a powerful critique of the scientific process as practiced in nutrition and public health. His investigation illuminates how sociology, psychology, and politics can distort what should be an objective search for truth. The cold fusion story is a cautionary tale about premature scientific claims driven by excitement and financial gain rather than reproducible evidence. Similarly, the simplistic “energy balance” explanation for obesity has been entrenched for decades despite mounting contradictory evidence.

    Taubes’ detailed historical account reveals that early scientists understood obesity as a complex neuroendocrine disorder influenced by hormonal control, particularly insulin’s dominant role in fat storage. This understanding was sidelined due to geopolitical and cultural shifts, including the rise of behavioral psychology in America post-WWII, which framed obesity as a moral failing (gluttony and sloth). This reframing shaped decades of research funding and public health messaging, limiting exploration of alternative hypotheses.

    The carbohydrate-insulin model emerges as a robust alternative that explains numerous clinical and population-level phenomena, including the rise of obesity and diabetes during nutritional transitions around the globe. It also explains why low-carb and ketogenic diets can lead to effortless weight loss and reduced “food noise” or intrusive hunger thoughts—an experience Taubes personally attests to.

    Importantly, Taubes critiques the current research culture that prioritizes positive findings, often due to funding incentives, and discourages publication of negative results. This creates a confirmation bias that perpetuates flawed theories. His call for preregistration of hypotheses and transparent reporting could greatly improve scientific rigor.

    His reflections on scientific belief systems highlight how difficult it is to change entrenched paradigms because what scientists “see” is shaped by what they expect or want to see. The example of how political ideology shapes media consumption—and thus worldview—provides a useful analogy for scientific communities. Scientists and laypeople alike may be trapped in echo chambers that confirm their biases.

    Finally, Taubes’ personal journey underscores the role of experience in shifting beliefs. Those who have struggled with obesity and found success in low-carb diets are often more open to alternative explanations than those who have not. This experiential evidence complements scientific data and is crucial for changing public health narratives.

    In sum, this discussion is a masterclass in the sociology of science, the history of obesity research, and the challenges of nutrition science. It advocates for humility, transparency, and openness to new ideas to overcome decades of entrenched, simplistic thinking that have impeded progress in understanding and treating obesity and chronic disease.


    This detailed exploration provides a nuanced understanding of why obesity science remains controversial, why simple explanations fail, and what might be done to advance the field with more rigor, honesty, and openness. Taubes’ insights are invaluable for scientists, clinicians, policymakers, and anyone interested in the complex science of nutrition and health.

     

    Diagnosed with anorexia nervosa at age 12, Michelle was hospitalized and tube-fed.

    Though she regained weight, her mental health never stabilized. Over the years, Michelle cycled through psychiatric medications, battled anxiety, OCD, depression, and even suicidal ideation, despite doing everything right according to conventional wisdom.

    While preparing for the Olympic marathon trials in her late 20s, she suffered a devastating health collapse. After taking the advice to increase carbs and eat a diet packed with whole grains and vegetables, her body and mind began to break down.

    After a night of desperation and an ice bath at 3 a.m., she made a radical decision: to try a ketogenic diet.

    In this raw, eye-opening interview, Michelle shares:

    Her experience inside the eating disorder treatment system Why she questioned the nutrition guidelines she was trained to teach What happened to her anxiety, suicidal thoughts, and physical performance on a carnivore diet Her journey to becoming an ultrarunner and author of The Dietitian’s Dilemma

    If you’ve struggled with conventional treatment for anorexia or other mental illnesses—or you're a provider looking for new tools—this conversation is for you.

    summerizer

    Summary

    Michelle Karn, a registered and licensed dietitian and ultrarunner, shares her deeply personal and professional journey through severe anorexia nervosa, traditional dietetic training, and ultimately, her transformative experience with ketogenic and carnivore diets. Diagnosed at age 12 with anorexia nervosa, Michelle endured extreme malnutrition, psychiatric symptoms, and standard medical treatments that relied heavily on the conventional American diet and medications. Despite achieving weight restoration, her mental health struggles continued with anxiety, depression, and body dysmorphia.

    As a dietitian, Michelle initially adhered to and promoted conventional nutrition guidelines focusing heavily on carbohydrates as the foundation of a healthy diet. However, during her career, she observed the limitations and failures of this approach, especially in managing chronic illnesses like type 2 diabetes and mental health disorders. Personal health crises in her late twenties, including severe fatigue, anxiety, and performance decline as an athlete, led her to question the traditional carbohydrate-heavy dietary recommendations.

    Driven by intuition and desperation, Michelle adopted a ketogenic diet followed by a carnivore diet, despite initial skepticism from her partner and concerns tied to her history of eating disorders. The dietary shift resulted in profound improvements in her mental health, anxiety levels, and physical well-being, enabling her to return to ultrarunning and reclaim her life. Michelle critiques the current healthcare system’s handling of mental health and eating disorders, highlighting the influence of processed food industry sponsorships on dietary guidelines and the deep-seated dogma around carbohydrate consumption in dietetics.

    Michelle emphasizes the metabolic underpinnings of psychiatric diseases, arguing that effective treatment must address metabolism alongside traditional psychiatric interventions. She advocates for ketogenic diets as a powerful, evidence-backed approach to improving mental health and metabolic function, encouraging patients and clinicians to remain open-minded and willing to integrate metabolic therapies. Her story culminates in a hopeful message about the human body’s incredible capacity for healing when provided with the right nutritional inputs.

    Highlights

    • 🏃‍♀️ Michelle’s journey from severe anorexia nervosa at age 12 to becoming an ultrarunner and registered dietitian.
    • 🍞 Questioning the carbohydrate-centric nutritional paradigm ingrained in traditional dietetics.
    • 🍖 Personal transformation through ketogenic and carnivore diets, leading to significant mental health improvements.
    • 💊 Critique of the healthcare system’s failure to adequately treat metabolic aspects of mental illness.
    • 🔬 Evidence supporting ketogenic diets for reversing type 2 diabetes, traumatic brain injury, and mental health conditions.
    • 🧠 The importance of addressing metabolism to enable neuroplasticity and effective psychiatric treatment.
    • 💡 Encouragement to approach nutrition and mental health with humility, openness, and individualized experimentation.

    Key Insights

    • 🧩 Eating disorders and mental health are deeply intertwined with metabolic dysfunction. Michelle’s early experience with anorexia and subsequent mental health challenges highlight that traditional approaches focusing solely on weight restoration and psychiatric medication often fail to address underlying metabolic imbalances. This suggests a need for integrated treatment paradigms that incorporate metabolic therapies.

    • 🥖 The entrenched carbohydrate dogma in dietetics can hinder patient outcomes. Michelle’s training and early career were dominated by the belief that carbohydrates are essential for energy and health, leading to recommendations that sometimes worsened patients’ conditions. This reflects a systemic issue within dietetics where dogmatic adherence to outdated guidelines prevents personalized care and innovation.

    • 🥩 Ketogenic and carnivore diets can dramatically improve mental health and physical performance for some individuals. Michelle’s shift to a low-carb, high-fat diet after years of struggling with anxiety, depression, and athletic decline was a turning point. Her experience aligns with growing clinical evidence that ketosis and reduced carbohydrate intake can reduce inflammation, stabilize blood sugar, and provide neuroprotective benefits.

    • 🏥 Current healthcare systems often fail to integrate metabolic treatments for psychiatric disorders. Michelle critiques how mental health is often treated only with medications and therapy without addressing metabolic dysfunction. She argues this oversight leads to poor outcomes and relapse, as the brain cannot effectively engage in neuroplasticity without proper metabolic support.

    • 💡 There is a significant conflict of interest influencing nutritional guidelines. Michelle points out that major dietetic organizations receive funding from processed food companies and sugar industries, which can bias dietary recommendations and suppress emerging evidence supporting low-carbohydrate diets. This raises ethical concerns about guideline development and patient care.

    • 🔄 Personal intuition and open-mindedness are crucial in navigating nutrition and mental health. Michelle’s willingness to challenge conventional wisdom, try alternative diets, and learn from emerging research was essential to her recovery. This highlights the importance of humility in healthcare providers and patients, fostering experimentation and individualized treatment.

    • ⚙️ Metabolism is fundamental to brain function and mental health recovery. Michelle emphasizes that to benefit from therapy and psychiatric interventions, the brain must be metabolically healthy. Ketogenic diets provide an alternative fuel source (ketones) that may improve brain metabolism, reduce anxiety and depression, and facilitate neuroplasticity, offering a promising adjunct or alternative to pharmacological treatments.

    Expanded Summary and Analysis

    Michelle Karn’s narrative begins with a harrowing experience of anorexia nervosa diagnosed at just 12 years old. Severely underweight and malnourished, she was hospitalized and subjected to tube feeding formulas composed of maltodextrin, soy protein, canola oil, and corn syrup—the very components of a standard American diet high in sugars and refined carbohydrates. This aggressive refeeding precipitated intense gastrointestinal distress, psychiatric symptoms including OCD, anxiety, and depression, and a reliance on multiple medications to manage side effects, reflecting the challenges and shortcomings of conventional inpatient care for eating disorders.

    Despite achieving weight restoration, Michelle’s mental health remained precarious. She describes a persistent internal battle with anxiety, depression, and body dysmorphia, feeling as though she was on the sidelines of her own life. Her early exposure to nutrition inspired her to become a dietitian, driven by the hope that food could be a key to healing both body and brain. However, during her dietetic training, she encountered a rigid orthodoxy emphasizing carbohydrates as essential energy sources. This framework conflicted with her intuition, especially when witnessing the adverse health trajectories of patients with metabolic diseases like type 2 diabetes, where carbohydrate restriction could logically be beneficial.

    Michelle’s critical turning point came in her late twenties when she faced a severe decline in athletic performance, accompanied by worsening anxiety, fatigue, and other systemic symptoms. Traditional medical evaluations and nutritional advice failed to yield improvement, and increasing carbohydrate intake only exacerbated her symptoms. Desperate and disillusioned, she experimented with a ketogenic and eventually carnivore diet, drastically reducing carbohydrates and increasing fats and proteins. Although initially challenging due to side effects and a lack of proper guidance on electrolyte balance, this dietary shift brought profound improvements in her mental clarity, anxiety reduction, and physical health.

    Her partner’s observation that Michelle’s anxiety was the lowest it had been in over a decade underscores the dramatic impact of this change. Michelle’s experience is supported by a growing body of scientific literature documenting the anti-inflammatory, neuroprotective, and metabolic benefits of ketogenic diets in conditions ranging from diabetes to bipolar disorder and traumatic brain injury. She also highlights the potential for ketones to serve as a more efficient brain fuel, particularly in individuals with impaired glucose metabolism, which is common in psychiatric disorders.

    Michelle critiques the healthcare system for its failure to integrate metabolic interventions into mental health treatment, often relying solely on medications and therapy that do not address the underlying biological dysfunction. She stresses that the brain must be metabolically healthy to engage effectively in neuroplasticity and benefit from therapeutic interventions. Without addressing insulin resistance, dysregulated blood sugar, and metabolic inflammation, patients are likely to relapse or experience suboptimal recovery.

    A significant insight Michelle offers is the influence of industry funding on nutritional guidelines, which perpetuates carbohydrate-centric recommendations despite mounting evidence to the contrary. She calls for humility and openness within the dietetic profession and among health practitioners to consider alternative dietary approaches tailored to individual metabolic needs.

    As an ultrarunner now, Michelle has integrated a strategic use of carbohydrates to fuel her athletic performance while maintaining a primarily ketogenic dietary framework. She acknowledges the powerful hold of sugar addiction both personally and societally, emphasizing the importance of discipline and saying no to foods that trigger mental health symptoms.

    Ultimately, Michelle’s story is one of resilience, transformation, and advocacy for a paradigm shift in how mental health and nutrition are approached. She encourages others to explore metabolic therapies with an open mind and asserts the human body’s extraordinary ability to heal when given the right nutritional inputs.

    Conclusion

    Michelle Karn’s journey from a severely malnourished adolescent with anorexia to a thriving ultrarunner and dietitian who has embraced ketogenic nutrition provides a compelling case for reevaluating the role of metabolism in mental health treatment. Her experience challenges entrenched dietary dogmas, exposes systemic conflicts of interest, and advocates for more integrative, individualized approaches to care that address both brain and body. Her insights emphasize the critical need for metabolic health in achieving lasting recovery from psychiatric and eating disorders, offering hope and a roadmap for others facing similar struggles.

     

    This video is a little silly. On the other hand, the thing it reviews is also a little silly, as well as impressively epic. Lord of the Rings is not a history book - it just feels like one.

    Summerizer

    Summary

    The video presents a humorous yet insightful exploration of fortress design inspired by the legendary Helm's Deep, blending medieval military architecture lessons with personal anecdotes and modern ergonomic insights. The speaker outlines strategic architectural features crucial for creating an impregnable mountain fortress, emphasizing practical defensive elements like drawbridges, moats, crenellations, and portcullises. These components are carefully chosen to thwart siege tactics such as battering rams, ladders, and mass cavalry charges. Alongside the fortress design discussion, the speaker shares a candid personal experience with back pain caused by prolonged editing sessions, highlighting the struggle to find an ergonomic chair. The solution comes in the form of a highly adjustable office chair, the C7 Morpher by Flexispot, which offers customizable lumbar support, armrests, and seating positions to alleviate discomfort during long working hours. The video concludes with further tactical fortress design advice, focusing on optimizing defensive positions, commanding archers efficiently, and selecting a strategic location that prevents enemies from exploiting natural terrain advantages. The narrative is peppered with humor and practical wisdom, merging ancient military strategy with modern lifestyle challenges.

    Highlights

    • 🏰 Strategic fortress design prioritizes defensive features like drawbridges and moats to counter siege equipment.
    • 🛡️ Crenellations and banister rails on battlements improve archer protection and reduce accidental casualties.
    • 🏇 Avoiding tactical errors such as charging through narrow gateways or poorly timed archery commands enhances defense effectiveness.
    • 💺 The speaker’s journey to find ergonomic seating emphasizes the importance of comfort and adjustability during long work sessions.
    • 🔧 The Flexispot C7 Morpher chair offers extensive customization, including adjustable lumbar support, armrests, and seating positions.
    • 🔥 Using precise commands like “loose” instead of “fire” prevents confusion among archers during battle.
    • 🌄 Fortress location must prevent enemies from gaining high ground to avoid rock attacks and siege advantages.

    Key Insights

    • 🏰 Fortress defense depends on layered protection: The video underscores the importance of multiple defensive barriers, such as ditches, moats, drawbridges, curtain walls, portcullises, and murder holes. This multi-tiered defense complicates enemy siege efforts by forcing attackers to overcome successive obstacles, thereby buying defenders time and maximizing their chances of repelling assaults. The inclusion of arrow slits and murder holes ensures attackers face continuous threats even if they breach initial defenses, demonstrating the value of overlapping defensive fields of fire.

    • ⚔️ Practical battlefield communication enhances combat efficiency: The choice of command words like “loose” or “release” for archers reflects a nuanced understanding of historical combat dynamics. The speaker highlights that using “fire” could confuse troops not equipped with firearms, showing how clarity and context-specific language can optimize military discipline and prevent unnecessary fatigue or errors during combat.

    • 🛡️ Architectural design must avoid isolated or ineffective defenses: Positioning curtain walls or gates where they defend useless or inaccessible terrain is a tactical blunder. The fortress elements must guard vital assets like the main keep or key access points. Otherwise, enemy forces will ignore these defenses, concentrating their attack on more critical, less protected areas. This insight stresses the importance of strategic placement rather than simply adding more walls or gates.

    • 🏇 Cavalry charges require careful terrain and timing consideration: Charging uphill or through confined spaces like narrow gateways risks catastrophic pileups, which can cause chaos and weaken the attackers’ momentum. The speaker’s advice to avoid starting charges indoors or on steep slopes highlights the logistical challenges of coordinating mounted units and the importance of terrain analysis in battle planning.

    • 💺 Ergonomics significantly impact productivity and health for creatives: The speaker’s prolonged back pain from editing reveals how poor seating can hinder work efficiency and well-being. The trial-and-error experience with various chairs, including an ill-fitting office chair and an unconventional bicycle seat, illustrates the struggle many face in finding suitable ergonomic furniture, especially when body type or gender-specific design considerations come into play.

    • 🔧 Adjustability in office chairs is critical for personalized comfort: The Flexispot C7 Morpher’s multiple adjustable features—lumbar support, armrest height, width, recline, and footrest—demonstrate how tailored ergonomics cater to diverse user preferences and body types. The ability to switch seating positions, such as cross-legged or reclining, promotes movement and reduces strain during long work hours, potentially preventing chronic pain and enhancing focus.

    • 🌄 Fortress location selection is as crucial as design: The speaker advises against situating a fortress where the enemy can easily exploit natural advantages, such as steep valleys or high ground above the fortress. Ensuring that attackers cannot rain down rocks or surround the fortress from difficult-to-defend angles is a fundamental strategic consideration. This insight reflects the broader military principle that geography often dictates the success or failure of a defensive position.

    Together, these insights blend medieval military wisdom with modern occupational health concerns, demonstrating how thoughtful design—whether of a fortress or a workstation—can dramatically influence effectiveness and resilience in very different contexts.

     

    Article on the 1535 diving apparatus: researchgate.net/publication/355187395_A_new_hypothesis_on_Francesco_De_Marchi_1504-1576_and_his_dives_in_Lake_Nemi_in_1535

    More info on the 1930s draining of Lake Nemi and salvage of the ships: penelope.uchicago.edu/encyclopaedia_romana/miscellanea/nemi/nemiships.html

    Summary Provided By AI LLM NoteGPT.io

    Summary

    This video recounts one of the earliest documented cases of underwater archaeology, centered around the extraordinary mega yachts of the Roman Emperor Caligula. These two massive floating palaces, stationed on Lake Nemi near Rome, were marvels of ancient engineering, boasting luxurious features such as orchards, marble floors, and even hot and cold running water. After Caligula’s assassination, the ships eventually sank and remained submerged for over a millennium.

    Interest in the wrecks was rekindled during the Renaissance, with early attempts to raise and explore them dating back to 1446. Although the initial salvage efforts failed due to the immense size and weight of the ships, they inspired further underwater exploration. In 1535, Italian inventors and explorers used one of the earliest diving helmets to explore the wrecks in unprecedented detail, making this one of the first examples of underwater archaeology aimed at learning, not treasure hunting.

    Despite further attempts in the 19th century to raise the ships, it was not until the Fascist era under Mussolini that the lake was drained in the late 1920s and early 1930s to expose the wrecks on dry land. The ships were carefully excavated and housed in a dedicated museum near the lake, opening to the public in 1939. Tragically, the museum and the ships were destroyed by fire during World War II in 1944 under unclear circumstances.

    The video highlights the technological challenges faced in underwater exploration over centuries, the historical significance of the yachts, and the fascinating intersection of ancient luxury, Renaissance innovation, and modern archaeology.

    Highlights

    • ⚓ Caligula’s mega yachts were massive floating palaces with orchards, marble floors, brass roofs, and running water.
    • 🤿 The 1535 expedition used one of the earliest diving helmets, marking a pioneering moment in underwater archaeology.
    • 🌊 Early salvage efforts in the 1400s and 1800s failed due to the ships’ immense size and being embedded in mud for centuries.
    • 🏞 Mussolini ordered the draining of Lake Nemi in 1929 to expose and preserve the wrecks on dry land.
    • 🏛 A museum was built to house the recovered ships, opening in 1939, showcasing ancient Roman luxury and craftsmanship.
    • 🔥 The museum and ships were destroyed in a 1944 fire during World War II, with unclear responsibility for the blaze.
    • 🛠 Recent efforts have focused on reconstructing the ships and preserving their legacy.

    Key Insights

    • ⚓ Caligula’s Ships as Symbols of Roman Engineering and Excess: The construction of two enormous mega yachts, each over 200 feet long, challenges previous assumptions about Roman shipbuilding capabilities. These vessels were not mere ships but floating palaces, complete with orchards, mosaics, brass roofs, and advanced plumbing systems, including hot and cold running water. This highlights the Romans’ ability to combine engineering with extravagant luxury, reflecting Caligula’s notorious reputation for excess.

    • 🤿 Early Underwater Archaeology and Diving Technology: The 1535 expedition marks one of the first documented uses of technology specifically designed for underwater exploration. Guglielmo de Lorena’s invention of a diving helmet—an early form of individual diving apparatus—allowed Francesco de’ Marchi to explore the wrecks in detail. Despite lacking modern air pumps or surface-supplied air systems, they ingeniously used weighted, inverted air buckets to refresh the diver’s air supply. This approach predates more advanced diving suits by centuries and exemplifies early human ingenuity in overcoming underwater challenges.

    • 🌊 Challenges of Salvage and Archaeology in Pre-Industrial Eras: The repeated failure of attempts to raise the ships in the 1400s and 1800s emphasizes the technical and logistical difficulties of underwater salvage before modern engineering. The ships had sunk into the lakebed mud, increasing their effective weight and making simple lifting techniques—like ropes and floating rafts—ineffective. These failed attempts underscore the limits of contemporary technology and the persistence of curiosity driving archaeological inquiry.

    • 🏞 Mussolini’s Political and Cultural Motivations: The Fascist regime’s decision to drain Lake Nemi in the late 1920s reveals how archaeology can intersect with political ideology. Mussolini sought to evoke the grandeur of ancient Rome and portray himself as a modern Roman emperor. By physically exposing and recovering Caligula’s floating palaces, the regime could claim a symbolic connection to imperial history. This episode illustrates how archaeology can be mobilized for nationalistic and propagandistic purposes.

    • 🏛 Preservation and Display of Ancient Artifacts: The construction of a museum dedicated to the ships was a pioneering effort in archaeological conservation. Moving the massive wrecks onto wooden cradles and protecting them from decay showed an early understanding of the importance of preserving cultural heritage. The museum’s opening on Rome’s birthday in 1939 further emphasized the symbolic importance attached to these artifacts.

    • 🔥 The Vulnerability of Cultural Heritage in Wartime: The destruction of the museum and the ships during World War II highlights the fragility of archaeological sites and museums in conflict zones. The ambiguity around whether the fire was caused by retreating German forces or Allied artillery underscores how cultural treasures can become collateral damage or targets in warfare, leading to irreversible loss.

    • 🛠 Enduring Legacy and Reconstruction Efforts: Despite the physical loss of the original ships, ongoing reconstruction projects and scholarly research continue to revive interest in Caligula’s mega yachts. This persistence reflects a broader trend in archaeology and heritage management to use modern technology and interdisciplinary approaches to reconstruct and interpret lost artifacts, ensuring their stories endure.

    Additional Context and Analysis

    The story of Caligula’s mega yachts and their underwater rediscovery bridges many eras—from the height of the Roman Empire to the Renaissance’s birth of science and technology, through to 20th-century nationalism and modern archaeological practice. Each phase of exploration reflects the technological and cultural context of its time, showing how human fascination with the past drives innovation and sometimes political agendas.

    The early Renaissance diving helmet represents a technological milestone. Using weighted inverted buckets to supply air was a clever workaround for the lack of pressurized pumps and reliable hoses. This method required precise coordination between surface support and divers and exposed the pioneers to significant risk, such as drowning if the helmet flooded or air ran out.

    The repeated attempts to salvage the ships, despite failures, demonstrate a persistent human curiosity to recover and understand the past. This persistence also highlights evolving attitudes towards underwater wrecks—from treasure hunting to scientific inquiry and cultural preservation.

    Mussolini’s involvement illustrates the complex relationship between archaeology and politics. By draining Lake Nemi, the regime not only achieved a remarkable engineering feat but also staged a cultural spectacle that linked fascist ambitions to the glory of Rome’s imperial past. However, this association also placed the artifacts at risk during wartime.

    The ultimate destruction of the museum and the ships during World War II is a poignant reminder of the vulnerabilities of cultural heritage. It also raises questions about responsibility and the consequences of war on history’s physical record.

    Finally, the ongoing efforts to reconstruct and study the wrecks emphasize the enduring importance of these ships as symbols of Roman innovation and extravagance. They remind us that archaeology is a continuous dialogue between the past and present, shaped by technology, politics, and human passion for discovery.

     

    Human trial data published in a major journal show that statins cause insulin resistance and deplete GLP-1 levels in humans. This should have been breaking news! Why is no one talking about it? Why don’t doctors know? Why aren’t patients being informed about the risks?

    For references and a written breakdown, see the StayCurious Metabolism Newsletter: open.substack.com/pub/staycuriousmetabolism/p/this-study-should-have-changed-medicineno

    Summary Provided By AI LLM NoteGPT.io

    Summary

    The video transcript discusses a significant yet underreported scientific study on statins, the world’s most profitable drug class, and their adverse effects on insulin resistance, type 2 diabetes risk, and especially GLP-1 levels in humans. While it is somewhat known that statins may increase diabetes risk, the study reveals a substantial and direct reduction of GLP-1—a hormone critical in glucose metabolism and the target of popular diabetes and weight loss drugs known as GLP-1 receptor agonists. This creates a paradox where a widely prescribed medication (statins) may worsen the biological pathway targeted by cutting-edge therapies. The research, published in Cell Metabolism in early 2024 but largely ignored in medical circles and media, involved human trials, mouse models, and microbiome analyses. It demonstrated that statins disrupt gut microbiota, specifically depleting Clostridium species responsible for converting bile acids into ursodeoxycholic acid (UDCA), a compound that supports GLP-1 production and insulin sensitivity. Supplementing with UDCA reversed the negative metabolic effects of statins in both mice and a small human pilot study.

    The speaker expresses frustration that these findings have not permeated clinical practice or medical education and critiques the healthcare system’s profit-driven incentives that hinder the adoption of simple, inexpensive, and effective adjunct therapies like UDCA supplementation. The video ends with a call to action for patients and clinicians to become aware of these findings, foster dialogue, and advocate for improved care that prioritizes patient well-being over pharmaceutical profits.

    Highlights

    • 💊 Statins, prescribed to 1 in 4 people over 40, significantly reduce GLP-1 levels by nearly 50%.
    • 🧬 Statins disrupt gut microbiome by depleting Clostridium bacteria, leading to lower production of beneficial bile acid UDCA.
    • 🐭 Mouse studies confirmed that statin-induced microbiome changes cause insulin resistance and reduced GLP-1, which can be reversed by UDCA supplementation.
    • 🧪 A small human pilot trial showed that UDCA supplementation improved blood sugar, insulin resistance, and restored GLP-1 levels in statin users.
    • 📉 Despite strong, peer-reviewed evidence published in Cell Metabolism, these findings remain obscure in medical education and clinical practice.
    • 💡 The healthcare system’s profit-driven incentives often suppress simple, effective adjunct treatments that are inexpensive and biologically sound.
    • 🔍 The video encourages patients and clinicians to share this information, question current practices, and prioritize patient-centered care.

    Key Insights

    • 🔬 Statins and GLP-1: A Hidden Metabolic Disruption
      The study reveals a novel and critical metabolic side effect of statins: a near 50% reduction in GLP-1 levels. GLP-1 is essential for stimulating insulin secretion and regulating blood glucose. This insight is particularly important given the simultaneous rise in GLP-1-based therapies for diabetes and obesity. The fact that statins undermine GLP-1 levels suggests a complex, counterproductive interaction between widely prescribed cholesterol-lowering drugs and modern metabolic treatments, which has been largely overlooked.

    • 🦠 Gut Microbiome as the Mediator of Statins’ Side Effects
      The research identifies how statins alter the gut microbiome, specifically depleting Clostridium species that convert primary bile acids into UDCA, a secondary bile acid crucial for maintaining insulin sensitivity and GLP-1 secretion. This mechanistic link between gut bacteria, bile acid metabolism, and systemic glucose homeostasis highlights the importance of microbiome health in drug side effects and metabolic diseases.

    • 🐁 Animal Models Confirm Causality and Reversibility
      Mouse experiments were pivotal in confirming that microbiome changes caused by statins directly lead to insulin resistance and GLP-1 reduction. Furthermore, reintroducing Clostridium or supplementing with UDCA reversed these effects, demonstrating that the metabolic damage is not permanent but modifiable. This reversibility opens the door for therapeutic interventions that could mitigate statin-induced diabetes risk.

    • 👨‍⚕️ Lack of Awareness Among Physicians Reflects Systemic Gaps
      An informal poll of physicians, including cardiologists, revealed widespread ignorance or uncertainty about statins’ effects on GLP-1. This knowledge gap underlines systemic issues in medical education and continuing professional development, where emerging but clinically relevant findings fail to reach frontline clinicians. It also underscores the challenge patients face in receiving fully informed care.

    • 💸 Profit Motive as a Barrier to Optimal Patient Care
      The speaker argues that financial incentives within healthcare prioritize drug sales and protocol adherence over patient-centered approaches that might include inexpensive supplements like UDCA. This misalignment results in inertia and silence around simple, safe, and effective solutions that could improve patients’ metabolic outcomes without additional costly medications.

    • 💊 UDCA Supplementation as a Promising Adjunct Therapy
      UDCA, available as a supplement and shown to restore GLP-1 levels and improve glucose metabolism in both animal models and a small human pilot, represents a low-cost, low-risk intervention. Its potential to counteract statin-induced metabolic harm is significant, especially given the prevalence of statin use worldwide. However, clinical guidelines have yet to incorporate this option, reflecting a gap between research and practice.

    • 📢 The Call for Patient and Clinician Empowerment
      The video ends with an urgent appeal for awareness, transparency, and dialogue. Patients should be informed and encouraged to discuss these findings with their healthcare providers. Clinicians and medical students should critically evaluate current practices, incorporate emerging evidence, and advocate for systems that prioritize holistic health over profits. This empowerment is essential for improving outcomes and restoring trust in medicine.

    Conclusion

    This video transcript conveys a compelling narrative that highlights an important but neglected side effect of statins—significant suppression of GLP-1 via microbiome disruption and bile acid metabolism alteration. The findings are robust, translational, and clinically meaningful, yet remain underrecognized in medical and public domains due to systemic inertia and profit-driven healthcare structures. The demonstrated benefit of UDCA supplementation offers a practical, evidence-supported strategy to mitigate adverse metabolic effects of statins. Ultimately, the video serves as both an educational resource and a call to action, urging healthcare stakeholders to bridge gaps between research, clinical practice, and patient empowerment for better metabolic health outcomes.

     

    There is a book called “On Being Certain”, by Robert A Burton who’s a neurologist, discussing how we know what we know. He postulates that the sense of “conviction” has less to do with objective reality and far more to do with “a feeling of knowing.” He also suggests that we are far less self-aware than we think we are.

    People see a different viewpoint and their body reactively brings up all the conditioning received from popular advice. Instinctively, they hit the downvote button, thinking that they are rightfully decreasing the noise of a dangerous idea and protecting the less aware.

    Most people aren’t interested in debate nor challenging the reality they find themselves in, or even the framing and interpretation of that reality.

    Is lemmy supposed to be better then other social media?

    How do we make lemmy a more thoughtful place? Or how do we create meaningful spaces on lemmy for thoughtful discussion of opposing views?

     

    In moderation has eased itself into the lexicon of all polite conversation when your trying to get someone to stop doing a bad thing, but you don't want to scare them with the prospect of totally stopping yet.

    • Drinking... in moderation
    • Smoking... in moderation
    • Recreational Drugs... in moderation

    Or when it comes from people in authority it just means "I'm not ready to have this fight, so I'll just say in moderation as a catch all so you wont get mad at me"

     

    There are now apparently over 1000 lawsuits pretaining to weight loss drugs such as Ozempic, Wegovy, Mounjaro, Retatrutide etc. These drugs have serious issues because of the way they work - not the side effects, but the INTENDED effects and the corresponding mechanism of action. In this video I break the entire pathway down so you can understand what they are actually doing to your body.

    summerizer

    Summary

    The video provides an in-depth explanation and critical analysis of GLP-1 (glucagon-like peptide-1) receptor agonists, a class of drugs commonly prescribed for weight loss and diabetes management. The speaker expresses personal skepticism and caution about these drugs, highlighting potential risks, lawsuits, and adverse effects on bodily functions, especially the digestive system. The video breaks down the biochemical pathway of how GLP-1 drugs interact with smooth muscle cells in the gastrointestinal tract, focusing on the receptor activation mechanism and subsequent intracellular signaling that leads to reduced muscle contraction and impaired peristalsis. This biochemical interference results in slowed digestion, delayed gastric emptying, and prolonged feelings of fullness, which explain the drugs’ appetite-suppressing and weight loss effects. However, the speaker warns that these effects come at the cost of disrupting essential cellular functions, particularly calcium signaling, which is vital for muscle contraction and overall cell health. The drugs effectively inhibit intestinal motility, which can cause severe complications, including cases where patients require colostomy bags due to intestinal failure. The speaker emphasizes that obesity and metabolic diseases are primarily caused by dietary habits rather than a deficiency of GLP-1 or related hormones. Therefore, relying on these drugs without proper education about nutrition and lifestyle changes leads to unsustainable outcomes, including weight regain after drug cessation and potential muscle and bone loss. The video concludes with a call for better patient education rather than pharmaceutical dependency and hints at future videos covering other related drug receptors such as GIP and glucagon receptors.

    Highlights

    • ⚠️ GLP-1 drugs interfere with smooth muscle contraction in the digestive tract, reducing peristalsis and delaying gastric emptying.
    • 💊 These drugs work by activating GLP-1 receptors, triggering complex intracellular pathways that reduce calcium availability necessary for muscle contraction.
    • ⚡ Signal amplification inside cells via cyclic AMP and protein kinase A is central to the drug’s mechanism of action.
    • 🚫 Reduced intestinal motility can lead to serious complications, including intestinal failure requiring colostomy.
    • 🍽️ Weight loss from GLP-1 drugs is largely due to induced starvation and appetite suppression, not addressing root causes of obesity or diabetes.
    • 📚 Sustainable metabolic health requires education and dietary changes, not just pharmaceutical intervention.
    • 📉 Use of GLP-1 drugs without lifestyle change risks muscle and bone loss, and weight regain after stopping medication.

    Key Insights

    • 🧬 Biochemical Mechanism of GLP-1 Agonists: GLP-1 receptor agonists bind to transmembrane GLP-1 receptors on smooth muscle cells, activating a G-protein coupled receptor pathway. This causes dissociation of G-protein subunits, leading to activation of adenylate cyclase, which converts ATP to cyclic AMP (cAMP). Elevated cAMP acts as a secondary messenger to activate protein kinase A (PKA), which phosphorylates target proteins affecting calcium dynamics crucial for muscle contraction. This detailed pathway explains how GLP-1 drugs cause physiological effects on the gut.

    • ⚙️ Inhibition of Muscle Contraction via Calcium Modulation: Activated PKA phosphorylates myosin light chain kinase (MLCK), inhibiting its activity and preventing the formation of actin-myosin crossbridges essential for muscle contraction. Additionally, calcium channels are inactivated, and intracellular calcium is sequestered into the endoplasmic reticulum, drastically reducing cytoplasmic calcium levels. Since calcium is fundamental for muscle contraction and many cellular functions, its reduction severely impairs smooth muscle activity, explaining the clinical effects on peristalsis.

    • 🚦 Physiological Consequences: Reduced Peristalsis and Delayed Gastric Emptying: The biochemical interference results in slowed movement of food through the digestive tract (reduced peristalsis) and relaxation of sphincter muscles like the pyloric sphincter. This causes delayed gastric emptying and prolonged gastric distension, leading to increased satiety and appetite suppression. While this explains the effectiveness of GLP-1 drugs for weight loss, it also highlights the unnatural disruption of normal digestive physiology.

    • ⚠️ Potential Serious Side Effects Including Intestinal Failure: Chronic inhibition of intestinal motility can lead to severe complications. The speaker notes reported cases where patients have required colostomy bags because their intestines stopped functioning properly, effectively "dying." This raises concerns about the long-term safety of GLP-1 agonists, especially when used outside urgent clinical scenarios.

    • 🍽️ Obesity and Diabetes Root Causes are Dietary, Not Hormonal Deficiencies: The video emphasizes that metabolic diseases are primarily caused by poor dietary choices, not a lack of GLP-1 or similar hormones. Thus, treating these conditions by simply administering GLP-1 agonists without addressing nutrition is akin to masking symptoms rather than curing the underlying problem.

    • 📉 Weight Loss Through Pharmacological Starvation is Unsustainable and Harmful: GLP-1 drugs induce weight loss by suppressing appetite and slowing digestion, which essentially puts the body into a state of starvation. This not only causes loss of fat but also muscle and bone mass. Without behavioral and dietary education, patients are likely to regain weight once treatment ceases, perpetuating a cycle of drug dependence and health risks.

    • 📚 Importance of Education and Lifestyle Interventions Over Medication Alone: The speaker advocates strongly for patient education on nutrition, particularly low-carbohydrate diets that modulate insulin and glucagon balance. Such education can prevent and treat metabolic syndrome sustainably. The use of drugs should be limited to extreme cases where immediate intervention is necessary, rather than routine treatment for obesity or diabetes.

    Conclusion

    This video critically examines the biochemical and physiological effects of GLP-1 receptor agonists, revealing that while they can induce weight loss by suppressing appetite and slowing digestion, they achieve this by disrupting essential cellular calcium signaling and smooth muscle function. This disruption can lead to severe digestive complications, including intestinal failure. The speaker emphasizes that metabolic diseases are fundamentally caused by diet rather than hormonal deficiencies and that sustainable health requires education and lifestyle change. The video serves as a cautionary message against the overuse and overreliance on GLP-1 drugs without a comprehensive understanding of their mechanisms and long-term consequences.

     

    summerizer

    What Is Fallout: New Vegas’ Unemployment Rate?

    Thumbnail

    The video explores the fictional economy of New Vegas in the game Fallout: New Vegas, focusing on an unemployment rate survey of various NPCs, revealing that the area has a 0% unemployment rate while discussing the nuances of economic indicators in a non-traditional economy.

    Key Points

    Survey Methodology

    The creator outlines a direct survey method involving a detailed walk-through of New Vegas to catalog NPCs, their employment status, and roles within the economy, aiming to determine the city's unemployment rate.

    Employment Overview

    Upon surveying several buildings including casinos and shops, it becomes clear that most employment is casino-related, with all known residents holding jobs, leading to the assertion of a 0% unemployment rate.

    Role of Robots and Soldiers

    The survey deliberately excludes certain non-sentient beings like police robots from unemployment counts and clarifies that nearby soldiers, while employed, are not permanent residents of New Vegas.

    Comparison with Real Economy

    The presenter discusses that a 0% unemployment rate may sound good but in the context of Fallout: New Vegas, it indicates a lack of diverse employment opportunities and potentially poor quality of life, emphasizing the importance of understanding economic context.

    Tourism Impact

    The video reveals that a significant portion of the New Vegas population consists of tourists, drawing a parallel between the game’s economy and real-world Las Vegas, where around 55% of visitors are tourists.

    Critique of Unemployment as an Indicator

    Finally, the video critiques the usefulness of the unemployment rate in gauging economic health in New Vegas, suggesting alternative metrics to better capture residents' quality of life and economic stability.

     

    Carnivore Resources

    YouTube Carnivore

    Science Based, Factual Discussions:

    Experience, testimonials:

    Nutritionists/Coaches:

    Lifestyle/Influencers:

    Mini-Series on all aspects of the Meat science, heath, nutrition, and environment

    Books Carnivore

    Websites Carnivore

    Excellent resource with many references on all things carnivore, may have to click around, recommend

    Ketogenic Resources

    Carnivore is a subset of Ketogenic eating, so all of the benefits for keto also apply here

    YouTube Ketogenic

    Science Based, Lectures:

    Websites Ketogenic

    Science, Guides, Recipes , Hard Science, highly recommended

    Keto Virtual Health Program - monitoring, medication titration, coaching, excellent

    Books Ketogenic

    Feel free to add any suggestions below.

     

    In this talk, Dave Feldman shares new updates from the Keto-CTA study, comparing results across four independent CT imaging analyses: Cleerly, QAngio, HeartFlow, and semi-quantitative reads by expert readers. He addresses the controversies around LDL-C, ApoB, plaque progression, and regression, revealing why certain datasets conflict, and presents compelling evidence showing verified plaque regression in a subset of participants.

    chapter timestamps

    0:00 – Intro & welcome
    0:34 – Disclosures & background on the Keto-CTA study
    1:01 – Study design & lean mass hyper-responder criteria
    1:45 – CT scans, imaging methods & data acquisition
    2:10 – Semi-quantitative vs quantitative analysis explained
    3:06 – Timeline of analyses & initial expectations
    3:29 – First Cleerly results & early concerns
    4:11 – Shared findings: baseline plaque & lack of LDL/ApoB association
    5:21 – Paper publication & critics’ reactions
    6:07 – Prespecified methodology: why QAngio matters
    6:59 – Social media debates & misinterpretations
    7:33 – The “limited contrast” argument emerges
    8:33 – Breaking down claims about “all high LDL”
    9:42 – Visualizing the actual LDL spread
    11:01 – LDL variability: 49 mg/dL to 591 mg/dL
    12:30 – Problems with the “limited exposure” critique
    13:08 – Revisiting the lipid hypothesis: dose-dependent effects
    14:07 – Are these the “healthiest” participants? Context & caveats
    15:14 – Participant risk factors: CAC scores, A1C, glucose, hs-CRP
    16:33 – Why Dave reduced public debates for a time
    17:01 – Issues discovered in Cleerly’s dataset
    18:13 – Introducing HeartFlow: a blinded independent analysis
    19:05 – Why a fourth analysis was critical
    20:02 – Record-breaking multi-analysis study design
    20:34 – Preliminary results warning
    21:04 – Non-calcified plaque volume % change: conflicting findings
    22:00 – Absolute vs relative change: why it matters
    22:28 – Total plaque volume & percent atheroma volume
    23:17 – How HeartFlow & QAngio compare to reference studies
    24:40 – Top-level observations & agreements
    25:07 – Plaque regression: the star of the show
    26:14 – Direct verification of regression by Dr. Budoff
    27:00 – Red flags in Cleerly’s data: no negative values
    28:33 – The “noise floor” problem explained
    30:28 – Why multiple analyses were necessary
    31:15 – Every imaging study shows regression — except Cleerly
    32:02 – Statistical implausibility of Cleerly’s results
    32:37 – Final conclusions on regression evidence
    33:29 – Does regression imply safety for lean mass hyper-responders?
    34:11 – No association of LDL/ApoB with plaque presentation or progression
    35:02 – What’s next: study extension & Triad study
    35:38 – Reflecting on six years since Keto-CTA’s conception
    36:32 – Acknowledgments & closing remarks
    

    summerizer

    Summary

    The speaker, an engineer and founder of the Citizen Science Foundation, presented a detailed overview of the ketoCTA study, which investigates the effects of a ketogenic diet on cholesterol and coronary plaque development. Initiated in 2015, the study followed 100 individuals who exhibited increased cholesterol levels after adopting a ketogenic diet, a phenomenon the speaker termed "lean mass hyper-responder" (LMHR). These participants were selected based on specific cholesterol criteria (LDL ≥190, HDL ≥60, triglycerides ≤80) and underwent coronary CT angiography (CTA) scans at baseline and after one year (totaling 200 scans).

    The study employed multiple methods of analyzing the scans: semi-quantitative expert reviews, and various quantitative analyses using AI and algorithms, including platforms named Clearly, Qangio (the prespecified methodology), and HeartFlow. Early results revealed notable discrepancies between the different analyses, particularly with the Clearly platform, which showed no instances of plaque regression—a finding at odds with both the other analyses and established scientific knowledge that some plaque regression is expected even in healthy populations.

    The speaker emphasized the broad variation in LDL cholesterol levels among study participants, ranging from very low to extremely high (including cases of homozygous familial hypercholesterolemia), countering criticisms that there was insufficient LDL variability (“limited contrast”) to assess LDL’s impact on plaque progression. Despite the large spread and high LDL levels, none of the analyses demonstrated an association between LDL cholesterol or ApoB levels and the progression or presence of coronary plaque in this cohort, challenging aspects of the lipid hypothesis within this specific group.

    The speaker also addressed social media critiques and the challenges faced during the study, including delays and disagreements over data analysis and interpretation. Due to concerns over the Clearly analysis, a blinded quality control review was requested but not completed, leading the team to commission an additional independent analysis via HeartFlow. The HeartFlow and Qangio analyses showed close agreement and revealed instances of plaque regression in some participants, which was independently verified by expert readers.

    The talk concluded with a balanced message: while some participants showed plaque regression despite high LDL levels, this does not imply that being a lean mass hyper-responder guarantees low cardiovascular risk. The cohort was generally healthier than average but included individuals with various risk factors and pre-existing conditions. The study’s findings are preliminary, with ongoing efforts to analyze further data and extend the study. The speaker expressed gratitude to the research team, contributors, and participants and highlighted the significance of this milestone in the journey that began nearly six years ago.

    Highlights

    • 🩺 Study of 100 keto diet adopters with elevated cholesterol tracked over one year using coronary CT angiography.
    • 🧬 Multiple independent methods analyzed the same 200 scans, revealing discrepancies between analysis platforms.
    • 🔍 No association found between LDL cholesterol/ApoB levels and plaque progression in this cohort.
    • 📊 Study population demonstrated an exceptionally wide range of LDL cholesterol, including extreme familial hypercholesterolemia.
    • 🔄 Evidence of plaque regression verified by multiple analyses and expert readers, contradicting one major analysis (Clearly).
    • 🛑 Challenges with data quality and analysis led to commissioning additional independent review (HeartFlow).
    • ⚠️ Regression does not guarantee low cardiovascular risk; cohort includes individuals with varying health statuses.

    Key Insights

    • 🧪 Multi-modal imaging analysis reveals complexity and variability in plaque progression assessment:
      The ketoCTA study uniquely employed four independent analyses on the same set of 200 coronary CT scans, including semi-quantitative expert reads and three AI-driven quantitative platforms (Clearly, Qangio, HeartFlow). This multi-layered approach highlighted how different methodologies can produce divergent results, particularly in measuring plaque regression or progression. It underscores the importance of using multiple analytical tools and blinded quality controls to validate imaging studies, especially in novel cohorts.

    • 📉 Plaque regression occurs even among individuals with high LDL cholesterol:
      Contrary to the dominant lipid hypothesis narrative, multiple analyses in this study documented regression of coronary plaque in a subset of participants, including those with LDL levels comparable to familial hypercholesterolemia. This finding challenges the assumption that high LDL universally predicts plaque progression and cardiovascular risk, suggesting that other factors may modulate atherosclerosis in lean mass hyper-responders or ketogenic dieters.

    • 📈 No correlation between LDL cholesterol/ApoB and plaque progression in this cohort:
      Despite the large variability of LDL levels (ranging from under 50 to nearly 600 mg/dL), the study found virtually no association between LDL or ApoB and either the baseline plaque burden or the change in plaque volume over one year. This lack of correlation, consistent across multiple analyses, suggests that LDL cholesterol may not be the sole or primary driver of atherosclerosis progression in this specific population, prompting a re-examination of the lipid hypothesis in diverse metabolic contexts.

    • ⚖️ Wide LDL cholesterol variability refutes the “limited contrast” critique:
      Critics argued that the study’s participants all had uniformly high LDL, limiting the ability to detect dose-response relationships. However, the data showed a broad LDL distribution with a standard deviation of 84 mg/dL and a range from 49 to 591 mg/dL—arguably the widest spread in any prospective imaging study to date. This diversity provides a strong test of the LDL-plaque relationship, reinforcing the study’s conclusions.

    • 🔍 Importance of absolute versus relative changes in plaque measurements:
      The speaker pointed out a critical methodological issue: relying solely on relative percent changes in plaque volume can be misleading. Absolute changes provide a clearer picture, better aligned across different analytical platforms. This distinction is crucial for interpreting imaging results and for understanding the biological significance of plaque dynamics in clinical research.

    • 🛑 Data quality and transparency are vital, especially amid scientific controversy:
      The Clearly platform’s refusal to conduct a blinded quality control review after concerns were raised highlights challenges in data transparency and scientific rigor. The study’s response—to commission an additional independent analysis with HeartFlow—demonstrates a commitment to robust science and the value of independent validation, particularly in contentious areas like keto and lipid research.

    • ⚠️ Plaque regression does not equate to cardiovascular safety:
      The study emphasizes that even with documented plaque regression, lean mass hyper-responders are not guaranteed protection from atherosclerotic cardiovascular disease. The cohort was healthier than average but included individuals with diabetes, obesity, hypertension, and high coronary artery calcium scores. This nuanced view cautions against oversimplified conclusions and underscores the need for ongoing research into risk stratification and mechanisms beyond cholesterol levels.

    Conclusion

    This presentation offers a comprehensive and transparent look at the ketoCTA study’s progress, challenges, and preliminary findings related to cholesterol, ketogenic diets, and coronary artery plaque. It highlights the complexity of interpreting advanced imaging data, the need for rigorous multi-method validation, and the evolving understanding of lipid biology in cardiovascular risk. The findings challenge conventional lipid dogma in this unique population, while also acknowledging limitations and the necessity for further research.

    view more: ‹ prev next ›