Objectives: To investigate the relationship between markers of vitamin B12 status and brain volume loss per year over a 5-year period in an elderly population.

Methods: A prospective study of 107 community-dwelling volunteers aged 61 to 87 years without cognitive impairment at enrollment. Volunteers were assessed yearly by clinical examination, MRI scans, and cognitive tests. Blood was collected at baseline for measurement of plasma vitamin B12, transcobalamin (TC), holotranscobalamin (holoTC), methylmalonic acid (MMA), total homocysteine (tHcy), and serum folate.

Results: The decrease in brain volume was greater among those with lower vitamin B12 and holoTC levels and higher plasma tHcy and MMA levels at baseline. Linear regression analysis showed that associations with vitamin B12 and holoTC remained significant after adjustment for age, sex, creatinine, education, initial brain volume, cognitive test scores, systolic blood pressure, ApoE ε4 status, tHcy, and folate. Using the upper (for the vitamins) or lower tertile (for the metabolites) as reference in logistic regression analysis and adjusting for the above covariates, vitamin B12 in the bottom tertile (<308 pmol/L) was associated with increased rate of brain volume loss (odds ratio 6.17, 95% CI 1.25–30.47). The association was similar for low levels of holoTC (<54 pmol/L) (odds ratio 5.99, 95% CI 1.21–29.81) and for low TC saturation. High levels of MMA or tHcy or low levels of folate were not associated with brain volume loss.

Conclusion: Low vitamin B12 status should be further investigated as a modifiable cause of brain atrophy and of likely subsequent cognitive impairment in the elderly.

Paper - https://doi.org/10.1212/01.wnl.0000325581.26991.f2

Full paper on pirate science sites

all 17 comments

sorted by: hot top controversial new old
[+] 4 points 5 months ago (1 child)
  • [–] [S] 3 points 5 months ago* (last edited 5 months ago) (14 children)

    TLDR: association between brain volume loss and b12 deficiency, with low b12 having a 6x rate of worse volume loss

    This effect is the cornerstone of the "Why Vegans Have Smaller Brains" book- https://www.whyveganshavesmallerbrains.com/why-vegans-have-smaller-brains-book-references/

    Basically - vegans have demonstrated poor b12 outcomes (even when serum b12 levels are "normal"), b12 issues impacts brain size, therefor vegans have smaller brains.


    https://doi.org/10.3390/nu6083259 -

    Vegan Diet, Subnormal Vitamin B-12 Status and Cardiovascular Health

    metabolic vitamin B-12 deficiency is highly prevalent in vegetarians in Australia, Germany, Italy and Austria, and in vegans (80%) in Hong Kong and India, where vegans rarely take vitamin B-12 fortified food or vitamin B-12 supplements.

    Vegetarians and in particular vegans consume high amounts of fruits and vegetables, grains and nuts but their intake of vitamin B-12 is usually inadequate [43,44]. Subnormal vitamin B-12 status is prevalent (50%–70%) in vegetarians or vegans in Austria Germany, Italy, Australia, India and China [45,46,47,48,49,50,51,52]. There has been some controversy about the definition of vitamin B-12 deficiency because of variability in clinical manifestation. Metabolic deficiency, as evidenced by raised plasma homocysteine or methylmalonic acid, may be a more practical means of assessing compromised vitamin B-12 status. Serum vitamin B-12 levels less than 300 pmol/L are associated with a significant risk of metabolic vitamin B-12 deficiency in epidemiological studies [53]. Such metabolic vitamin B-12 deficiency was present in vegetarians/vegans in Australia, Germany, Taiwan, Hong Kong, Italy, and India [45,46,47,48,49,50,51,52]. Madry et al. have reported a significant decrease of serum vitamin B-12 from 285 pg/mL to 230 pg/mL (p < 0.0001) in omnivores changing to strict vegan diet for five years, consuming exclusively natural product, but not in those vegans consuming vitamin B-12 fortified products [54]. Regular intake of milk improved vitamin B-12 status and lowered blood homocysteine level in young Indian vegetarians [55], but has been avoided in most Chinese vegetarians. In studying the impact of poor intake of meat and dairy products on vitamin B-12 status in rural Chinese coalminers in Shanxi, Woo et al. have documented subnormal vitamin B-12 level (196 ± 104 pmol/L) in 207 coalminers, whereas vitamin B-12 levels were normal (477 ± 170 pmol/L) in southern Chinese omnivores consuming usual Chinese diets [56,57]. These data highlight the potentially detrimental impact of inadequate micronutrient intake on vitamin B-12 status.

  • source
  • hideshow 14 child comments
  • [–] 2 points 5 months ago (8 children)

    From the paper:

    Vitamin B-12 supplementation has a favourable impact on these vascular surrogates in Hong Kong vegans and in underprivileged communities in northern rural China.

    From the book synopsis:

    In these babies the brain atrophy can be reversed with vitamin B12 if it is picked up in time

    So your argument is that vegans should supplement B12? cool

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 8 child comments
  • [–] [S] 1 point 5 months ago (7 children)

    So your argument is that vegans should supplement B12? cool

    100% absolutely they should. Remember the second paper identifies 80% deficiencies in vegan populations (who I assume have been told to supplement already). Not all people metabolize supplements efficiently.

    But......even if the supplement does improve blood b12 levels that may not be enough

    https://doi.org/10.3390/jcm13082176 - Diagnosis, Treatment and Long-Term Management of Vitamin B12 Deficiency in Adults: A Delphi Expert Consensus

    The serum concentration of vitamin B12 is commonly used as a primary marker of vitamin B12 status. However, 30–40% of people with neurological or hematological symptoms related to B12 deficiency may have normal vitamin B12 concentrations

    Just a blood measurement doesn't guarantee b12 is sufficient.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 7 child comments
  • [–] 2 points 5 months ago (6 children)

    who I assume have been told to supplement already

    who then most likely don't as the paper itself calls out that:

    Madry et al. have reported a significant decrease of serum vitamin B-12 from 285 pg/mL to 230 pg/mL (p < 0.0001) in omnivores changing to strict vegan diet for five years, consuming exclusively natural product, but not in those vegans consuming vitamin B-12 fortified products

    which was probably a bigger problem 12 years ago when this paper was written as plant based milks and stuff were much less popular and weren't B12 fortified - imo vegan folk should still supplement B12

    on the B12 high blood levels but low absorption finding - this is def an issue but it's independent of diet - I would assume this actually works in favour of vegans because they would be more likely to take higher dose oral B12 irrespective of any underlying malabsorption mechanisms but obvs this my conjecture - tho your second paper does note:

    The use of high-dose oral B12 at different frequencies may be considered for long-term treatment. Prophylactic B12 supplementation should be considered for specific high-risk groups

    but yh tldr; take your vitamins kids

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 6 child comments
  • [–] [S] 2 points 5 months ago (5 children)

    who then most likely don’t as the paper itself calls out that:

    Sure, but the thesis that vegans have smaller brains is still mechanistically valid.

    which was probably a bigger problem 12 years ago when this paper was written as plant based milks and stuff were much less popular and weren’t B12 fortified - imo vegan folk should still supplement B12

    100% Vegans should supplement!

    Unfortunately most of the global vegan/vegetarian population are in that position economically not philosophically, they are unlikely to have access to fortified supplements.

    I would assume this actually works in favour of vegans because they would be more likely to take higher dose oral B12 irrespective of any underlying malabsorption mechanisms but obvs this my conjecture

    1kg of beef represents about 70kg of grass, so a person eating 0.5kg of beef a day is getting 35kg of concentrated gas and accompanying b12. Supplementing is a good idea, but it is hard to imagine it will keep up, and be as bioavailable as natural protein sources provide, especially when looking at economic vegans - focusing on getting one egg a day into everyone will have more impact then fortifying grain at scale.

    but yh tldr; take your vitamins kids

    100%

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 5 child comments
  • [–] 2 points 5 months ago (4 children)

    1kg of beef represents about 70kg of grass, so a person eating 0.5kg of beef a day is getting 35kg of concentrated gas and accompanying b12. Supplementing is a good idea, but it is hard to imagine it will keep up, and be as bioavailable as natural protein sources provide, especially when looking at economic vegans - focusing on getting one egg a day into everyone will have more impact then fortifying grain at scale

    wait are you actually arguing that it's cheaper to feed everyone half a kilo of grass fed beef or an egg a day than it is to fortify grains with B12? that's genuinely absurd

    also

    Supplementing is a good idea, but it is hard to imagine it will keep up, and be as bioavailable as natural protein sources provide

    good thing we dont have to imagine as we can look at empirical data:

    Vitamin B(12) in eggs seems to be poorly absorbed (< 9%) relative to other animal food products

    so a single large egg a day with about 0.6µg of B12 at 9% is highly inadequate - even more recent studies that found higher bioabsorbtion note: "An egg is confirmed as a good source of B12, supplying approximately 20% of the average adult daily requirement (RDA for adults = 2.4 μg/day)." - so you need a minimum of 5 eggs a day for proper B12 dosage

    on supplements:

    At a low dose of 2.3 µg, the mean bioavailability was 46.2 ± 12.8 (%, mean ± SD, n = 11). At a higher dose of 18.3 µg, the mean bioavailability was 7.6 ± 1.7 (%, mean ± SD, n = 4).

    so vegans should either take an extra B12 tablet at a different meal time to your regular multivitamin supplements - or just take a super poorly absorbed 1000µg one but still get 10µg via passive diffusion - either way it costs no more than 5c per full dose which is half the price of a single egg in a global majority country - and ofc large scale fortifications would be magnitudes cheaper than consumer tablets

    your B12 beef argument holds more water:

    The bioavailability of vitamin B(12) in healthy humans from fish meat, sheep meat, and chicken meat averaged 42%, 56%-89%, and 61%-66%, respectively](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/17959839/)

    assuming an average of 60% absorption at 500g with 1.1µg average per 100g a day - you're looking at 3.3µg which is plenty adequate

    HOWEVER 500g of beef a day is unattainably high - why do you think your second paper mentions B12 deficiency in rural Chinese farmers? meat and animal product consumption is an extremely western and high class pattern - for most of our agricultural history we've been consuming animal products in very low quantities because they take a lot of resources to produce

    we're currently using 4.8 billion hectares - 1.6 cropland and 3.2 pasture to produce calories for 8 billion people and we barely manage ~20g of beef per person per day (in a highly "efficient" grain-fed hyper-compact industrial farming system) - if we were to convert all of it to just grass-fed beef production it would exceed the total landmass of the Earth! it is phsycially impossible to feed 10 billion people with meat and animal products alone

    now if you want to argue for mass population culling so that everyone can eat a carnivore diet well that's a whole different argument...

    look I see you're super invested in your carnivore lifestyle and we live in a free world so you do you boo - but understand that the reason this is personally attainable to you is because we live in a heavily fossil-fuel subsidiesed world and you likely live in a region that has extracted so much resources from the global South that even suggesting everyone can live your lifestyle is an incredibly detached view of reality - I believe you're unlikely to internalise this anytime soon but I just hope you do so one day

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 4 child comments
  • [–] [S] 2 points 5 months ago* (2 children)

    1kg of beef represents about 70kg of grass, so a person eating 0.5kg of beef a day is getting 35kg of concentrated gas and accompanying b12. Supplementing is a good idea, but it is hard to imagine it will keep up, and be as bioavailable as natural protein sources provide, especially when looking at economic vegans - focusing on getting one egg a day into everyone will have more impact then fortifying grain at scale

    wait are you actually arguing that it’s cheaper to feed everyone half a kilo of grass fed beef or an egg a day than it is to fortify grains with B12? that’s genuinely absurd

    fortifying grains requires factories and infrastructure, and not all people can synthesize the cheap b12 fortifications biologically. chickes are decentralized, scale well, and can run by communities throughout the global south.

    so a single large egg a day with about 0.6µg of B12 at 9% is highly inadequate - even more recent studies that found higher bioabsorbtion note: “An egg is confirmed as a good source of B12, supplying approximately 20% of the average adult daily requirement (RDA for adults = 2.4 μg/day).” - so you need a minimum of 5 eggs a day for proper B12 dosage

    Good point, lets make sure everyone the option of 5 eggs a day! it will do wonders for health.

    so vegans should either take an extra B12 tablet at a different meal time to your regular multivitamin supplements - or just take a super poorly absorbed 1000µg one but still get 10µg via passive diffusion - either way it costs no more than 5c per full dose which is half the price of a single egg in a global majority country - and ofc large scale fortifications would be magnitudes cheaper than consumer tablets

    The egg a day will have more impact then just b12, for economic vegetarians there are more deficiencies to consider, but the appeal to industrialization doesn't scale and penetrate the global south.

    HOWEVER 500g of beef a day is unattainably high - why do you think your second paper mentions B12 deficiency in rural Chinese farmers? meat and animal product consumption is an extremely western and high class pattern

    I used a illustrative example of why animal foods concentrate b12 so effectively. 70kg of grass for every 1kg of beef.

    • for most of our agricultural history we’ve been consuming animal products in very low quantities because they take a lot of resources to produce

    Animals produce themselves! Remember we were hunters before we were farmers 10-30 thousand years ago. We have spent most of our history as humans without any farming at all.

    look I see you’re super invested in your carnivore lifestyle and we live in a free world so you do you boo -

    Thank you! I appreciate you

    but understand that the reason this is personally attainable to you is because we live in a heavily fossil-fuel subsidiesed world

    Ruminants are part of the natural biocycle, they don't need any fossil fuel inputs, they restore soil health, they are regenerative.

    and you likely live in a region that has extracted so much resources from the global South that even suggesting everyone can live your lifestyle is an incredibly detached view of reality - I believe you’re unlikely to internalise this anytime soon but I just hope you do so one day

    I don't think everyone can live my lifestyle, but we need to be raising up the economic vegetarians for basic humanitarian reasons, and it should be through access to animal sourced foods. A single egg a day to children in the global south will have huge impacts on health, cognitive function, and eventually economic independence.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] 2 points 5 months ago (1 child)

    Animals produce themselves! Remember we were hunters before we were farmers 10-30 thousand years ago. We have spent most of our history as humans without any farming at all.

    and during that time we were 10-15 million... that's why I said I'll leave the arguments for how you reduce the current population 500 times to yourself.

    and look I'm not against people in the global South having backyard chickens - but that isn't going to solve their nutritional issues in the near future - fortification infrastructure already exists - that's how we got iodized salt to 90% of the population

    I don't think everyone can live my lifestyle, but we need to be raising up the economic vegetarians for basic humanitarian reasons, and it should be through access to animal sourced foods. A single egg a day to children in the global south will have huge impacts on health, cognitive function, and eventually economic independence.

    but see that's literally my critique - you argue that you're just advocating for a single egg a day to help children in the global south (your motte) but your actual position is that the healthiest way to live is to be a full carnivore (your bailey argument) - one is fine and noble and the other requires population culling to 0.2% of current levels - this is not arguing in good faith

    anyways I'm getting janny chased out of here so I'll take my leave

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] [S] 2 points 5 months ago* (last edited 5 months ago)

    that’s why I said I’ll leave the arguments for how you reduce the current population 500 times to yourself.

    I refuse the premise of your position, there is no need to cull humanity - we can still work on improving health without chasing perfection and we are not slaves to the old 'population bomb' book

    but that isn’t going to solve their nutritional issues in the near future - fortification infrastructure already exists - that’s how we got iodized salt to 90% of the population

    The global population uses iodized salt? unicef says a billion people don't.... i would suspect this overlaps heavily with the economic vegetarian populations.

    but see that’s literally my critique - you argue that you’re just advocating for a single egg a day to help children in the global south (your motte) but your actual position is that the healthiest way to live is to be a full carnivore (your bailey argument) - one is fine and noble and the

    Allow me to clarify - b12 is best available in animal foods. Wishing for a future where more of the economic vegetarians has better and consistent access to animal sourced foods isn't a 'fall back'

    Being full carnivore for the vast majority of omnivores is very doable, they just drop their carbs and eat more animal fat. they don't need to increase the number of animals eaten, just stop throwing away the fat.

    other requires population culling to 0.2% of current levels - this is not arguing in good faith

    You have baked a premise into your argument I fundamentally disagree with. The carrying capacity for the earth isn't 200 million people. If you want to have a good faith argument lets select a single idea and drill down on it. So far we moved from (b12 deficiency->small brain, vegans are b12 deficient) - where we both agreed vegans must supplement, to our current egg and carrying capacity disagreements; the goal posts moved due to your own argumentation style. I'm happy to stay with b12 deficiency is bad and best avoided with animal sourced foods.

    update - Ahh, never mind, I see your true colours now. You are downvoting every post in this community........ Which tells me you arguing in bad faith all along

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 2 points 5 months ago* (last edited 5 months ago)

    Zeezee, let me gently remind you about the rules of this community:

    1. Be nice
    2. Stay on topic
    3. Don't farm rage
    4. Be respectful of other diets, choices, and lifestyles.

    You may believe in the reductionist view that fortifying grains (which all also contain toxins) with b12 is perhaps the more ecologically conscious decision, and I disgree. For example, are you aware that the synthetic form of b12 used in supplementation is cyanocobalamin, which must first be broken down into cobalamin and cyanide to be further converted to active forms of B12 that are usable by the human body? But that the natural form, methylcobalamin, does not break down into cyanide?

    At the same time, the natural form is also more bioavailable than the synthetic form of b12. Considering the subtle and deleterious effects of b12 deficiency, what do you think is the cost to society of the run-on health issues caused by consuming fortified grains instead of whole foods that contain b12?

    We understand your position and do not agree with what you are saying. It does not stem from a lack of knowledge or understanding. Perhaps it is rather the opposite. I hope that you continue to engage with us in good faith - your post is condescending and there is no call for such condescension in c/friendlycarnivore.

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 2 points 5 months ago (4 children)

    Doesn't it depends on the place?

    If farm animals are fed B12 supplements and plant foods fortified with B12 then it's less likely that you will be deficient.

    Some studies found eating more vegetables protects from brain volume from decline.

    There are many intellectual workers and smart people who are vegetarians like Indian chess grandmasters. I am not sure avoiding meat makes you stupid…

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 4 child comments
  • [–] 3 points 5 months ago* (last edited 5 months ago)

    I've only read the first paper so far, but here are my thoughts on it. It's titled:

    A cross-sectional study of nutritional status in healthy, young, physically-active German omnivores, vegetarians and vegans reveals adequate vitamin B12 status in supplemented vegans

    This is a study of 38 "healthy, young, physically active" German vegans, 37 vegetarians, and 40 omnivores in Freiburg, Germany. I'm not sure what population this is representative of besides the Germans being studied, due to the selection bias. Is there a randomized study?

    Our cross-sectional study was performed between December 2021 and May 2022

    The term is less than 1 year, so again it's not a great study for b12 deficiency. We know that the liver contains up to 2-5 years of vitamin B12 stores, so you'd hope that a study looking for deficiencies would at least be 2 years long.

    Single measurement of B12

    The study only assessed the plasma vitamin B12 level once. That means it can't inform on long term B12 status, whether a deficiency would occur over a period of time, or what we really care about which are hard health outcomes such as disease, changes in brain size, or all-cause mortality. It'd be interesting to see changes in B12 levels over time at the very least, but they only measured once.

    Clinical assessments

    Curiously, the study didn't assess anything clinically. You'd think that if they were looking for deficiency (or, in their words, "adequate B12 status") they'd assess for clinical signs of B12 deficiency, neurological status, or even absorption efficiency of B12, all of which are well measurable today.

    I'm not sure what to make of this study since they then overgeneralize their conclusion to all "healthy individuals", that 250 ug/day "supports adequate B12 status" when neither criteria was studied! We shouldn't extrapolate the results of any study, but perhaps especially not this one.


    Edit: I can't access the second paper, neither.

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] [S] 2 points 5 months ago* (last edited 5 months ago) (2 children)

    I can't read your second reference it is behind a paywall - did you read it yourself? Is the hazard ratio of this observational epidemiology greater then 6... i.e. is it a stronger signal then b12 ? Does this paper control for 100% plant based?

    If farm animals are fed B12 supplements and plant foods fortified with B12 then it’s less likely that you will be deficient.

    A cross-sectional study of nutritional status in healthy, young, physically-active German omnivores, vegetarians and vegans reveals adequate vitamin B12 status in supplemented vegans

    What does this have to do with the original theory? This is a whataboutism

    We know blood serum isn't a adequate way to measure b12 status

    https://doi.org/10.3390/jcm13082176 - Diagnosis, Treatment and Long-Term Management of Vitamin B12 Deficiency in Adults: A Delphi Expert Consensus

    The serum concentration of vitamin B12 is commonly used as a primary marker of vitamin B12 status. However, 30–40% of people with neurological or hematological symptoms related to B12 deficiency may have normal vitamin B12 concentrations

    Regardless of the whataboutism, it's demonstrated 50-80% of practicing vegans have deficient b12 from the original paper i posted, and read.

    There are many intellectual workers and smart people who are vegetarians like Indian chess grandmasters. I am not sure avoiding meat makes you stupid…

    The theory is about brain volume not intelligence, it makes no statements about intelligence, you added that assumption but it isn't in the papers.


    Also, this is point by point mic the vegans response to the book, are you a mic the vegan fan?

    Mic the vegan didn't address the mechanistic theory behind the smaller brain issue at all, so when you parrot him it doesn't add to the dialog.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] 3 points 5 months ago* (1 child)

    I didn't read the 2nd paper yet. I'm not able to open it. it's triggering recaptcha continuously. I'm trying to find an alternate link.

    This is a whataboutism

    I am not trying to attack your position in any way. I am just saying how it's possible to protect ourself from B12 deficiency regardless of what you eat.

    The theory is about brain volume not intelligence

    I agree. I went to cognitive function and intelligence because it matters more to me than size of the brain or it's volume. Some people just assume that bigger brain = better. My understanding is it's usually not the case.

    (But yes I admit I went on a tangent here)

    are you a mic the vegan fan

    not really it showed up when I searched the original paper and the book.

    it's demonstrated 50-80% of practicing vegans have deficient b12

    👍harsh reality

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] [S] 3 points 5 months ago*

    I am not trying to attack your position in any way. I am just saying how it’s possible to protect ourself from B12 deficiency regardless of what you eat.

    Sure, just be aware that serum b12 levels don't provide protection from b12 deficiency


    Here is the core theory:

    Impaired b12 has a 600% risk of diminished brain volume, vegans demonstrate significant impaired b12

    Mic the vegan didn't address any of that theory. Supplementation may be sufficient, but it hasn't been examined or demonstrated with respect to brain volume.

  • source
  • parent