Objectives: To investigate the relationship between markers of vitamin B12 status and brain volume loss per year over a 5-year period in an elderly population.

Methods: A prospective study of 107 community-dwelling volunteers aged 61 to 87 years without cognitive impairment at enrollment. Volunteers were assessed yearly by clinical examination, MRI scans, and cognitive tests. Blood was collected at baseline for measurement of plasma vitamin B12, transcobalamin (TC), holotranscobalamin (holoTC), methylmalonic acid (MMA), total homocysteine (tHcy), and serum folate.

Results: The decrease in brain volume was greater among those with lower vitamin B12 and holoTC levels and higher plasma tHcy and MMA levels at baseline. Linear regression analysis showed that associations with vitamin B12 and holoTC remained significant after adjustment for age, sex, creatinine, education, initial brain volume, cognitive test scores, systolic blood pressure, ApoE ε4 status, tHcy, and folate. Using the upper (for the vitamins) or lower tertile (for the metabolites) as reference in logistic regression analysis and adjusting for the above covariates, vitamin B12 in the bottom tertile (<308 pmol/L) was associated with increased rate of brain volume loss (odds ratio 6.17, 95% CI 1.25–30.47). The association was similar for low levels of holoTC (<54 pmol/L) (odds ratio 5.99, 95% CI 1.21–29.81) and for low TC saturation. High levels of MMA or tHcy or low levels of folate were not associated with brain volume loss.

Conclusion: Low vitamin B12 status should be further investigated as a modifiable cause of brain atrophy and of likely subsequent cognitive impairment in the elderly.

Paper - https://doi.org/10.1212/01.wnl.0000325581.26991.f2

Full paper on pirate science sites

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] 2 points 5 months ago (4 children)

Doesn't it depends on the place?

If farm animals are fed B12 supplements and plant foods fortified with B12 then it's less likely that you will be deficient.

Some studies found eating more vegetables protects from brain volume from decline.

There are many intellectual workers and smart people who are vegetarians like Indian chess grandmasters. I am not sure avoiding meat makes you stupid…

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 4 child comments
  • [–] 3 points 5 months ago* (last edited 5 months ago)

    I've only read the first paper so far, but here are my thoughts on it. It's titled:

    A cross-sectional study of nutritional status in healthy, young, physically-active German omnivores, vegetarians and vegans reveals adequate vitamin B12 status in supplemented vegans

    This is a study of 38 "healthy, young, physically active" German vegans, 37 vegetarians, and 40 omnivores in Freiburg, Germany. I'm not sure what population this is representative of besides the Germans being studied, due to the selection bias. Is there a randomized study?

    Our cross-sectional study was performed between December 2021 and May 2022

    The term is less than 1 year, so again it's not a great study for b12 deficiency. We know that the liver contains up to 2-5 years of vitamin B12 stores, so you'd hope that a study looking for deficiencies would at least be 2 years long.

    Single measurement of B12

    The study only assessed the plasma vitamin B12 level once. That means it can't inform on long term B12 status, whether a deficiency would occur over a period of time, or what we really care about which are hard health outcomes such as disease, changes in brain size, or all-cause mortality. It'd be interesting to see changes in B12 levels over time at the very least, but they only measured once.

    Clinical assessments

    Curiously, the study didn't assess anything clinically. You'd think that if they were looking for deficiency (or, in their words, "adequate B12 status") they'd assess for clinical signs of B12 deficiency, neurological status, or even absorption efficiency of B12, all of which are well measurable today.

    I'm not sure what to make of this study since they then overgeneralize their conclusion to all "healthy individuals", that 250 ug/day "supports adequate B12 status" when neither criteria was studied! We shouldn't extrapolate the results of any study, but perhaps especially not this one.


    Edit: I can't access the second paper, neither.

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] [S] 2 points 5 months ago* (last edited 5 months ago) (2 children)

    I can't read your second reference it is behind a paywall - did you read it yourself? Is the hazard ratio of this observational epidemiology greater then 6... i.e. is it a stronger signal then b12 ? Does this paper control for 100% plant based?

    If farm animals are fed B12 supplements and plant foods fortified with B12 then it’s less likely that you will be deficient.

    A cross-sectional study of nutritional status in healthy, young, physically-active German omnivores, vegetarians and vegans reveals adequate vitamin B12 status in supplemented vegans

    What does this have to do with the original theory? This is a whataboutism

    We know blood serum isn't a adequate way to measure b12 status

    https://doi.org/10.3390/jcm13082176 - Diagnosis, Treatment and Long-Term Management of Vitamin B12 Deficiency in Adults: A Delphi Expert Consensus

    The serum concentration of vitamin B12 is commonly used as a primary marker of vitamin B12 status. However, 30–40% of people with neurological or hematological symptoms related to B12 deficiency may have normal vitamin B12 concentrations

    Regardless of the whataboutism, it's demonstrated 50-80% of practicing vegans have deficient b12 from the original paper i posted, and read.

    There are many intellectual workers and smart people who are vegetarians like Indian chess grandmasters. I am not sure avoiding meat makes you stupid…

    The theory is about brain volume not intelligence, it makes no statements about intelligence, you added that assumption but it isn't in the papers.


    Also, this is point by point mic the vegans response to the book, are you a mic the vegan fan?

    Mic the vegan didn't address the mechanistic theory behind the smaller brain issue at all, so when you parrot him it doesn't add to the dialog.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] 3 points 5 months ago* (1 child)

    I didn't read the 2nd paper yet. I'm not able to open it. it's triggering recaptcha continuously. I'm trying to find an alternate link.

    This is a whataboutism

    I am not trying to attack your position in any way. I am just saying how it's possible to protect ourself from B12 deficiency regardless of what you eat.

    The theory is about brain volume not intelligence

    I agree. I went to cognitive function and intelligence because it matters more to me than size of the brain or it's volume. Some people just assume that bigger brain = better. My understanding is it's usually not the case.

    (But yes I admit I went on a tangent here)

    are you a mic the vegan fan

    not really it showed up when I searched the original paper and the book.

    it's demonstrated 50-80% of practicing vegans have deficient b12

    👍harsh reality

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] [S] 3 points 5 months ago*

    I am not trying to attack your position in any way. I am just saying how it’s possible to protect ourself from B12 deficiency regardless of what you eat.

    Sure, just be aware that serum b12 levels don't provide protection from b12 deficiency


    Here is the core theory:

    Impaired b12 has a 600% risk of diminished brain volume, vegans demonstrate significant impaired b12

    Mic the vegan didn't address any of that theory. Supplementation may be sufficient, but it hasn't been examined or demonstrated with respect to brain volume.

  • source
  • parent