The last paragraph feel more like the authors opinion, which is a bit weird on an Android website.
I agree with the EU on this one though, I hate walled gardens and the EU is doing good work.
The last paragraph feel more like the authors opinion, which is a bit weird on an Android website.
I agree with the EU on this one though, I hate walled gardens and the EU is doing good work.
Never mind the privacy implications. Could you imagine if a rogue actor got into the system-level of your iPhone, disguised as an AI assistant?
I don't see the point here. Assistants are inherently untrustworthy. They are unreliable, and can be taken over vy hostile actors. Or, from Apples perspective, by the user.
You can't let users jailbreak their phones using siri prompt injection, and you can't let siri perform any system actions or exfiltrate data without confirmations because it could go rogue or be taken over by some prompt smuggled into it by a hostile actor.
If you have to safeguard it anyway, and it is untrustworthx anyway, you already have to make it withstand everything an untrustworthy 3rd party implementation could do.
Interesting take, I agree it should be that way (i.e. sandboxed up the wazoo). Apple might even have done the sensible thing, but we'd have to trust them, which we can't, because closed source and megacorp that can't be trusted if they see dollar signs. Also, if they had, why complain about giving 3rd parties equivalent access, except maybe to spank the EU for having the temerity to hold them to higher standards. On balance, I expect critical vulnerabilities incoming.
Sir you are fundamentally misunderstanding this issue. By putting an Apple logo on it, this tech is completely different and all problems are now magically solved. Buy the thing, consumer!
Could you imagine if a rogue actor got into the system-level of your iPhone, disguised as an AI assistant? That would be a huge headache and nightmare.
How about we let the users decide if they want to keep the default or not? These fucking companies are always using the privacy and security cqrd to push their walls and get full control of the devices we buy. And, of course, fucking media companies just serve as speakers for them.
Here is Apple’s statement. They designed an API called “Trusted System Agent “ but the EU rejected it.
https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2026/06/due-to-dma-siri-ai-delayed-in-eu-for-ios-27-and-ipados-27/
Well, they at least rejected letting Apple release without "Trusted System Agent" and a pinky promise it would be implemented in a year and a half...
"Designed" but did not implement. Pretty much says everything you'd need to know.
“There was a problem loading the page…”
Yeah; I won’t allow your shitty advertising. That’s the real provlem.
Could you imagine if a rogue actor got into the system-level of your iPhone, disguised as an AI assistant? That would be a huge headache and nightmare.
What is AI if not a rogue actor? Seems to me like Europe not getting Siri AI is Apple threatening them with a good time.
Of course, Apple doesn’t want to give up that much access to a competitor. Never mind the privacy implications. Could you imagine if a rogue actor got into the system-level of your iPhone, disguised as an AI assistant? That would be a huge headache and nightmare.
This article seems rather a bit biased. Apple didn't give their reasoning for it, and it seems presumptuous for Maxham to provide that reasoning, when it's unfounded.
It also doesn't seem like that big of an issue. Just have the assistant program run through the same permissions as a regular app, rather than as a system app, where you have to set the permissions you want to give it.
It also wouldn't be Apple's fault, any more than it would be their fault because you saw on Facebook that your iPhone had wireless charging, and stuck it in the microwave. People should be allowed to break their own devices. That's part of the risks of owning something, where things can just break if you use it wrong.
Apple? The company who fucked with their users/customers phone batteries from afar so they would have to purchase new products? That Apple?
I'm constantly being told by Apple fanboys that Apple is the only pro consumer silicon valley company in operation.
That’s not actually what happened. It’s kind of the opposite actually.
"AI cloud" and "super private" in the same sentence? 🤣🤣🤣
They designed the AI cloud to be super private.
HA! This is gold, I can not think of two words put together that implies less privacy. Well maybe "fucking stage".
do I trust their words? do I trust their security? do I trust their competency? why would I trust them over any other 3rd party that would actively need to compete to provide a better service if Apple complied with the DMA?
Apple has no right to imposed their own monopoly on the markets that their products create, vertical integration is a disgrace and harmful
Everyone here sucks, or whatever the term is in the "Am I the asshole?" threads when everyone is in the wrong.
Apple knows what the EU regulations are and as a company that wants to do business in the bloc, they have to abide by their rules. Also, China and the Middle East are stricter and Apple happily kowtows to them. And of course Apple bends over for the US regime as well. So what's different about doing it for the EU?
On the other hand, there's a reason there are no major companies operating out of the EU. The EU is where innovation goes to die. Like the US, it's tech rules made by people who neither understand nor love tech. EU does fight for their citizens, but the fact remains that the EU is also hurting its citizens here. Apple doesn't have to play ball, they can take their ball and go home, and still sell a lesser product to the EU for the same money. Apple is not going to take a loss here. Only people losing will be those living in the EU.
Apple says the EU wanted too much of your personal data. The EU didn't respond to that. All they really said was "Apple wanted a blanket exception and that is not an option." Apple still gets to wear its privacy hat, and the EU look like arseholes.
Also, I didn't read Apple's message as "blaming the EU." It was more that they just said due to the way things are over there, Siri AI will not be available there. Sure, they chose their words carefully, but my read on it was "it is what it is," not "it's all their fault." More of an "agree to disagree" kind of thing. Like "they want X, we want Z, we tried Y for a while but they won't budge and honestly we don't want to either, so this is what happens next." Now the citizens of the EU can just roll over and take it, or they can contact the EU leadership and whatnot and tell them they want less regulation. Who knows.
The EU is where innovation goes to die.
This is such bullshit. There are three principle reasons why the EU does not grow as many tech giants: 1. Venture capital is hard to cone by in the EU, 2. The language barriers and 3. The not-quite-finished-single market, with many countries not aligning their laws to the EU framework. 1 and 3 are actively being addressed and 2 is a disappearing issue as the younger generations aee all fluent in English.
To your point however, innovation has always been one of the strong suits of the European continent, much more so than monetization which is not a synonym.
I'm not going to argue the point. I will say however, that I am eagerly awaiting the smartphone from the EU. I don't recall if Finland is in the EU or not. I think they joined at the start of the Ukrainian crisis. Or maybe not. I'm not sure. I know they have Nokia and Nokia has done some interesting things. There's also Jolla, I think out of Sweden. I'm not ignorant to what currently exists, at least not completely. And I generally like the things the EU does. But if they can't produce a tech company that can exist under their bureaucracy, I think that says a lot about how much they should extend to American companies.
On the other hand, there's a reason there are no major companies operating out of the EU.
Yeah who's ever heard of Audi, niche car company that they are.
There's also that big particle accelerator who do you think paid for that? Private equity?
Like the US, it's tech rules made by people who neither understand nor love tech.
So if this were true the US would also be the land where innovation goes to die. Which actually on that point there are plenty of scientists that are leaving the United States because of its almost fearful attitude to intelligence.
Why choose Audi out of all the possible examples? At least go with VW
VW, Audi, Škoda, Fiat, Seat... Those are just some of the european car brands.
And then Siemens, CAF, Ansaldobreda, Alstom... all really important train manufacturers (apparently Škoda also makes trains, TIL)
Siemens is also a really big multinational that makes a lot of stuff, including industrial systems and bleeding edge science equipment and healthcare machinery.
Airbus is another massive company, which builds aircraft, spacecraft and it's also a "defence" contractor (fuck Airbus)
Speaking about space, the ESA (European Space Agency) is one of the most important space agencies, and it has built and launched some really important satellites. It has also made science equipment and parts for many joint NASA-ESA missions, and it has even built some of the modules of the ISS. Among some of the cool things the ESA has done is the Galileo satellite constellation, that provides worldwide geopositioning at higher precision than the US-built GPS constellation. It also helped NASA build the first space telescope, and it provided some parts and equipment for the Hubble Space Telescope.
Some people mentioned the CERN before. A world class research project, that currently has plans to be expanded, and that was built in collaboration by many countries in the EU. It's an impressive thing to research about.
Europe also has really good infrastructure, and it currently houses the world's longest road tunnel, the world's longest railway tunnel and the world's longest foot/bike tunnel. It has one of the best rail networks in the world, and it also holds the 3rd, 4th and 5th place in train speed records (and it still holds first place in stock/unmodified train speed records, according to wikipedia)
It also has some really important semiconductor companies, like NXP, Infineon and STMicroelectronics. Even ASML, the company that manufactures the machines that make all of the chips used in the US (yes, even Nvidia's, Intel's and AMD's chips) is a European company.
Europe also has some of the biggest telecoms, like Deutsche Telekom, Orange and Telefónica, and it's home to some phone brands, like Fairphone.
As a honorable mention, Linus Torvalds, who initially made Linux, the system most of the US (and the world) runs on top of, is european.
I saw an Audi driver on the road the other day. I thought, that's a nice car, it probably cost as much as my home.
Then I realised he hadn't opted for the turn signal subscription. Shame, that. Guess he's really not as affluent as he'd have you believe.
/s if it wasn't obvious.
That said, I've been following smartphones for over 20 years and I've never heard of Audi making one. But maybe you know something I don't. Because I'm curious as to why in a conversation about Apple (and by extension other phone makers) and you bring up Audi. Do they make a phone? Educate me.
Unclear what Apple could even do here.
The obvious answer would be, let people take the risk if they so chose. But the EU also demands security, so that isn't much of an option. It makes no sense.
What risk? I have an android and can select my agent if I want one.
People need to stop mystifying tech and excusing anti consumer products. What is the risk if I choose a different agent? Do they allow me third party keyboards or sms clients?
What risk?
That this is even a question, shows the problem with leaving it all to users.
We'll have to wait and see how Google responds to these demands. Android has been traditionally more open, but has recently been closed down more; not least because of EU demands for more security. It will be interesting.
Your comprehension skills are dogshit. The EU is moving to break down walled gardens...which is why Apple cant put Siri on the market here. In your comment it is responsible for both locking down and preventing locking down.
More security does not necessitate closing ranks. What risk being a question is something you clearly misunderstood on every level.
In your comment it is responsible for both locking down and preventing locking down.
As I wrote, it makes no sense.
Your asertion makes no sense because it isnt based in reality.
You ae failing to grasp that I am saying both canr be true. You are also not making the case that both are, rather laying blame for both without understanding either.
Umm, so what. You want restrictions because part of the population is low IQ and tech illiterate? The fuck do I care, buy yourself a flip phone if you can't deal.
If you are "at risk", you probably shouldn't be near a computer or the internet.
Sheesh. I don't agree with the EU locking down Android. But I don't see either how it makes sense to punch this huge security hole into Apple's Walled Garden. Their customers expect, and pay for, a lot of hand-holding.
You have to give your ID to watch porn for your security. You can't install unapproved apps for your security. Using a VPS is illegal for your security. Companies need to keep detailed information on you for your security. Can't have anything encrypted for your security.
Every shit decision lately has been for our security but mostly just seems to be about killing competition or destroying privacy.
As if they couldn't just solve it by putting a dev mode, but that would hinder profits which is the real reason for all this. The ones that want apple to hold their hand and lead them around like a child can just not use it.
The EU is the reason that people use browsers other than Chrome, they've also the ones that forced Microsoft to allow browsers other than internet explorer in the first place so they're also the reason Chrome exists. All good things in their time.
There has been no risk from removing walled gardens. If any person is not comfortable for any reason about using any AI other than the included one then they are of course free not to make any changes. This is about choice and ensuring customers have choice. Meanwhile here is Apple acting as if the concept of an API is a revolutionary idea.
Eh, I do get your logic and it makes some sense but they literally do it already for MacOS. Apps request access to os level controls and you have to go in and say yes this app has access to control my computer.
MacOS doesn't fall under the same DMA requirements, so that's why it still gets Siri AI in the EU.
I've been wondering if this would be more dangerous than installing random apps. It might be. But they don't let people install just anything on iPhones. "Proper" computers are traditionally more open.
Oh come on. That's a pathetic attempt at fanboying.
My God that was an incredibly whiny article I'm upset that I have to read that. Here's the only bit that actually has any substance to it. Emphasis is mine.
Given the serious risks to users, Apple designed a solution called Trusted System Agent — an intermediary that would allow virtual assistants to safely access the same features and capabilities as Siri AI for devices in the EU. Apple also shared a plan to launch Siri AI in the EU while gradually rolling out this new solution over an 18-month period. The European Commission said no. In fact, the European Commission did not agree to any of Apple’s proposals.
So Apple asked if they could just launch anyway and then maybe possibly introduce compliance in a year and a half. Yeah right of course the EU rejected that.
If Apple needs 18 months to introduce a proposed solution then what they can do is they can release the new Siri in 18 months with the proposed solution implemented. I'm sure if they come to the EU with that that will be accepted, which I'm sure the EU told Apple.
If Apple needs 18 months to introduce a proposed solution then what they can do is they can release the new Siri in 18 months with the proposed solution implemented.
So you're agreeing with me?
Your reading comprehension needs some work.
Apple need to release Siri AI with this API when the API was released not before
Sorry, your English isn't always quite clear.
You're saying that they will have to create that security layer that you call API, before releasing a modified Siri AI in the EU. Right? Which means that you don't see either what Apple could have done to roll this out now in the EU.
EU demands security theater. They are attempting to force backdoors into all of these APIs and systems (including locally run AI) for the nanny state. Very unfortunate.
You get the EU is not a single unified entity. It's not a government, they don't have any reason to want to spy on their citizens because they don't have citizens because they're not a government.
Unless I misread it, they are denying the security theater approach and insisting that if it's rolled out, it must include the safeguards, not just saying they promise to have them ready in the next 18 months. Meanwhile other countries seem to be okay with implementing this before the safeguards are in place.
I'll just patiently wait for the next wave of 0days exploiting it.
How the fuck do they get backdoors in locally run anything? Its local, it doesnt have anywhere to remotely access from. I guess they could break in and try my logins
top 67 comments