Image of accused.
post
That's...not a simple mistake. Like...what was the plan after the liver came out? It sounds like the guy legitimately believed it was a spleen...
I'm guessing there were some red flags ignored by the hospital prior to this
There's some reddit analysis of the report: https://www.reddit.com/r/medicine/comments/1g6v1jg/florida_ahca_report_on_dr_thomas_shaknovsky/
Yeah this guy should have been removed from surgery a long time before this happened. Whoever kept him on should be in prison.
Reading that is just insane. The surgeon wrote a fictional surgery report where he stated that he converted the laparoscopy into a normal surgery because the spleen was enlarged and then during the removal of the spleen there was an aneurysm that burst and the patient bled to death because of that. A pathologist was sent the liver in a box labeled "spleen" which he noticed instantly that it wasn't a spleen.
When they autopsied the patient the Medical Examiner found that the spleen was still inside the patient, basically untouched and there was no sign of the aforementioned aneurysm. The Medical Examiner also found that the liver was missing and that it has been cleanly dissected off the diaphragm which they stated that it was quite hard to learn how to do. They stated "Essentially the liver was autopsied out of that man". They noticed that there was no evidence of suturing or clamping and the surgeon just dissected the Inferior Vena Cava. The medical examiner also found that the spleen of the patient weighed 420 grams while a typical liver is between 1800 and 2800 grams, they also said that the largest spleen they have seen weighed 800 grams, still nowhere close to the weight of a liver.
They interviewed the nurses and other OR staff and one of them states that at one point a different surgeon walked in and stated: "that looks like the liver to me" and the operating surgeon just said "no, that's the spleen".
I appreciate you calling out the system even more than the individual. This is certainly a sentinel event.
Thanks for sharing that was an engrossing read. Like most of these situations it looks like there was significant system failure leading up to the event. You’re absolutely right he should have been removed long before this.
"You're going to laugh about all of this when I explain it..." runs out of room
I read the report the level of incompetence is insane. There were multiple medical staff who were concerned about the surgeon and facility's capabilities to handle such a non-routine procedure. Multiple people noticed that there was a high chance of complications and NONE of them stepped up to argue against the surgeon. The CMO was only called after the surgeon slapped the excised liver on the table... Multiple points of failure, and nobody did anything. Of course the surgeon is at fault. But, I can't believe nobody tried to stop it.
Guys come on this is a simple mistake! It is a Ron Burgundy type situation. He just removes whatever is in front of him... This time it was a liver. Could have been worse I guess
all 20 comments