You're surprised you got bullshit from the bullshit machine?
post
- it's free
- runs on a wider range of hardware
- is more customizable
- can run much windows software with wine or proton
- has a large ecosystem of native software
- much of it free and open source
The advantage of Mac is it's more widely used and thus more widely supported (for things that are supported at all). You can just buy an apple computer from a trusted source and it'll work. Linux doesn't quite have that yet. If more people move to Linux , you'll find better drivers and stuff.
It runs on generic hardware so you don't have to pay the Apple tax.
Fair point, but also, the M4 Mac mini is $500 for a pretty competitive chip, 16GB RAM, and 256GB on-chip SSD. You can beat that with a PC (and probably get a bit bigger drive, like 500GB, and you'd be able to upgrade), but you wouldn't save that much money. The Windows license puts it over; of course, the idea is you get someone to sell you one without a Windows license and install Linux. But if they aren't including Windows, they aren't selling in enough bulk to get the price down. There are a bunch of little computers from China that are competitive, but do you trust them? Up to you, I guess.
The other option, I went over in my top-level comment, is to find a gently used office PC that can't be upgraded to Windows 11, like a 7th gen i5. It's not gonna be competitive, performance wise, against that M4 Mac mini, though, but you might get it for like $100 from eBay or something, so maybe it's fine.
To add to your point, not only does it run on "generic" hardware, it runs on "whatever" hardware.
I'm a recovering Apple user, and the Apple tax is absolutely a thing.
Yeah, the hardware lasts. In my little office I currently have a 2011 MacBook Pro running Arch(btw), a 2014 Mac mini running Mint, an M1 mini, and an M2 Air. That '11 Pro refuses to die. However I'm under absolutely 0 illusions that I'll get the same lifespan from the M1 and M2. The hardware may well last as long, but them being effectively locked down right to macOS means that when Apple decide they're done, they're done. I could run Asahi on them, but that comes with a bunch of annoying compromises that aren't the fault of the Asahi devs, but are as a result of Apple trying to lock down the Mac platform in the same way they have iOS.
And sure, the entry level hardware can be cheap. The M4 mini is an astonishing deal. But they're betting on locking you in with iCloud Drive subscriptions, and the like. Then, after a few years, when your Mini goes obsolete, you'll either upgrade to a new one or have to spend a bunch of time trying to work out how to shift your online storage to another provider.
And not to mention things that they've branded that are commonly available for free elsewhere. "Buy into the Apple ecosystem to get Universal Control!" or just install Deskflow on the shitty old ThinkPad you already have, because the function of the software is exactly the same. "Apple's Continuity stuff is super neat!" Aye, and so is KDE Connect. Which is free and runs on any device this side of Charles Babbage's Difference Engine.
You pay a lot for Apple hardware, and yeah, that money gets you great hardware, but the value proposition is getting slimmer every year.
Well, if you have an old Mac (like Intel era), I think Linux would be a good target if your Mac isn't supported anymore. I'm not sure what Linux distros run on Apple Silicon. Linux being a bit lighter weight would mitigate some of the issues Mac guys have with certain Intel Macs (overheating). And certainly breathe new life into the machine.
I'm not quite sold on Mac Studio. For high end, I don't want something that's all on one chip and can't be upgraded. But that's what Apple Silicon is all about. Just seems like someone who needs that much computer would be better served by a different kind of machine. For cheap consumer grade computers, Macs are kinda hard to beat, but at every price point, there are other options. Hard to say what the best is. It would depend on the user.
Personally I find the MacOS interface to be horrendous. Window management is bad. The Mac apps are always opening my files instead of the third-party ones I designated as default. It's messy.
Other than that my primary concern with MacOS is that you can only run it on insanely expensive, irreparable, unupgradeable, disposable hardware.
Are you sure you properly designated default apps?
- get info on the file
- change preferred app
- make sure you check the box indicating change for all
Edit: then close the info panel, of course.
I dunno what you mean.There's nothing in the settings that will solve my problems with MacOS or I would have just made them already.
There's also the shitty "Gatekeeper" that says "no, we don't recognize this software, you can't install it" and you have to go into the terminal and disable it, only to have it re-enable itself at a later time. I've also had it refuse to turn off Bluetooth. Anytime my computer tells me "no", it makes me fuckin irate.
It's only saving grace is that Apple has not yet filled it with a bunch of ads and tracking.
That's incorrect. They cannot be adjusted. You should really do some research about settings menus.
No, they can't be adjusted. I don't need a tutorial.
https://support.apple.com/guide/mac-help/choose-an-app-to-open-a-file-on-mac-mh35597/mac
Number 1 search result, contains instructions for multiple versions, I checked that it’s accurate with the last four major releases.
You should read comments before you reply to them:
The Mac apps are always opening my files instead of the third-party ones I designated as default.
No, they can’t be adjusted.
I know you said you don’t need a tutorial right after that, but the context of you saying that was another user explaining that it can be changed but they didn’t have time to provide you tech support.
I happened to be in a position where I could quickly get the information they weren’t able to, so I did.
If you wanna know anything else just lmk.
I already had the information but thank you.
What kinds of window management changes would you like to make? Iirc you can make some decently radical adjustments using brew but I’m not extremely knowledgeable about them because I like to keep it normal.
I want it to stop hanging up when I drag windows from one monitor to the other.
When I switch screens I want it to switch when I click on it and not click, wait, and click again.
I want the dock to disappear and stop consuming screen real estate, but I also want it to come back up when I need it.
I need the red x to actually close the window instead of just minimizing it.
All of these things sometimes happen and sometimes don't, with seemingly no reason, which is the most frustrating part, and this inconsistent behavior spans iOS as well.
For reference I'm running Sequoia on a 2017 iMac.
I want it to stop hanging up when I drag windows from one monitor to the other.
That might be caused by a few things, such as the virtual arrangement of screens, but it's not typical.
When I switch screens I want it to switch when I click on it and not click, wait, and click again.
Also unusual. Something odd about your setup.
I want the dock to disappear and stop consuming screen real estate, but I also want it to come back up when I need it.
Dock hiding is a basic setting. It could work better because I can trigger it showing by accidentally mousing to that edge. The Dock is kind of for beginners, and limited in functionality though, it won't anticipate your needs. I advise moving to the left side and shrinking it.
I need the red x to actually close the window instead of just minimizing it.
It closes the window, not minimizes. That's a misclick, or a broken app. On one-window apps it also quits the app.
All of these things sometimes happen and sometimes don't, with seemingly no reason, which is the most frustrating part, and this inconsistent behavior spans iOS as well.
Again, your experience is unusual in these specific respects, so I suspect you are importing habits from other OS's.
All of these things are typical, as I have confirmed them with other users/devices.
Dock hiding is a basic setting
The problem is not that I don't have it on, the problem is that it does not work properly.
The Dock is kind of for beginners
Excuse me, what!? 😂
It closes the window
It doesn't.
your experience is unusual
These are all very typical complaints I've seen shared by other users. Apple does not need you to come to their defense.
First, I hate Apple nearly as much as MS, and I am defending the common experience rather than company.
The dock does what it's designed to do; "properly" needs to be defined. It is crappy, limited software and since it is mouse-oriented, slow and inefficient and merely one way to do things like open apps. Use spotlight or the app switcher with the keyboard instead and save time. (Spotlight has its own problems but is still much better than the dock!)
If the red button doesn't close the window, the app isn't using the developer interface guidelines. Also, try Command-W, it might work better for you.
Also, switching desktops (screens as you said) is trackpad oriented and one smooth gesture , no delay. Using a mouse is more clicky, yes, but normally no delay. Keyboard commands might be what you want here? Also, are you using oddball apps that are fighting the OS?
Regarding your sample set of experiences, I believe you, but trust that my sample set is unusually large due to doing user support for a long time, and few users with a healthy typical install of the OS overall have those complaints:
- setting default apps normally works consistently
- red button closes window on mainstream macOS apps, rarely otherwise
- dragging windows is pretty smooth between monitors (I have to demonstrate this after showing people how to arrange monitors)
The dock does what it's designed to do
Then it is, as I said, a terrible design.
Use spotlight or the app switcher
No. I want to use the mouse. It's faster, easier, and more intuitive. Why do you want to suggest alternatives rather than just acknowledge that it's broken?
If the red button doesn't close the window, the app isn't using the developer interface guidelines
I...don't care whose fault it is.
In the version before sequoia you can choose to uncheck “draw window contents while dragging”, that will make it only draw an outline until you release the drag. In my experience that setting stops a lot of slowdown and hanging when moving between monitors.
I can’t say for sure, because idk which 2017 you have or what monitor you have, but it may also be related to the monitor not supporting the same dpi or colorspace as the built in does. In those circumstances a hang when moving windows between screens comes from the video card swapping resources in and out furiously to show everything.
I don’t know what you mean when you say “switch screens.” Like in Mission Control or switching workspaces?
The last two that you’re talking about can be alleviated by hotkeys. Option command d toggles the dock, option q quits and option command esc force quits. Make sure you have the correct program up front before you do this.
If you absolutely cannot live without clicking the red button and knowing the program closed, there’s a bunch of little programs out there that change the behavior to what you want. I don’t recommend this though, because you’ll feel lost when working with a computer that isn’t your specific customized device.
What’s kinda funny switching between windows, macs and different Linux systems is that the windows and Linux gui elements act mostly the same but the hotkeys are all different and the mac and windows hotkeys are mostly the same but the gui elements act real different.
My apologies for not having definitive links and answers like above, I’m not in front of a million computers at the moment and you can’t trust what you just read online.
uncheck “draw window contents while dragging”, that will make it only draw an outline until you release the drag
It already does that.
what monitor you have, but it may also be related to the monitor not supporting the same dpi or colorspace as the built in does
I mean that would make sense if it wasn't intermittent. It's also not a problem I have with any other OS.
I don’t know what you mean when you say “switch screens.” Like in Mission Control or switching workspaces?
Like I'm working on one screen and then switch to the other.
Option command d toggles the dock
I don't want to use a keyboard shortcut, I just want it to work correctly the way it does in GNOME.
Thank you.
LLMs don't "understand" anything. They are predicting what text matches your prompt. If you don't understand what an AI is saying, it's not saying anything
Macos doesn't solve the ownership or customisation of OS problem that windows also has.
Mint does. Don't like how macos does something? Too bad.
Don't like how mint does something? Someone likely already has a package to fix it.
The problem is asking a fundamentally subjective question in a way that presupposes it to be objective truth.
If you instead asked,
What are some advantages that Linux Mint and macOS have over each other?
…you might get more useful answers—from people, that is. AI will just give you what you think you want to hear.
Mint is FOSS and free of hardware restrictions, so if you don't mind having to teach yourself how to fix the odd issue here and there, it's probably the better option. That said, macOS is definitely a more seamless and full-featured experience (whether that matters to you is personal preference). I use it plenty at work, it's pretty nice for the average user. Personally, I switched from Windows to Mint years ago, but now I'm on KDE Neon because I needed Wayland support and fell in love with KDE Plasma in the process. Mint/Cinnamon should be stable on Wayland within the next year or two though, so that's cool.
The way AI works, it's likely to pick up on your style. I.e. if you ask with slang words or spelling mistakes, it's going to answer very colloquially. And this translates to meaning... Once you ask "stupid" questions, it's going to mistake that for a creative writing assignment. And I think your question is a bit alike »What's better, oranges or papayas?« That's just a weird question and you'll get a weird answer. Linux and MacOS are very different things. Used by different people for different tasks. None of them is "better" without any context given.
My wife and some relatives? Along with countless other people... We have a zero electronics devices with fruit on them -policy, in this household. But we do provide Lightning cables for guests... I mean MacOS doesn't even run on a Thinkpad without several stunts and a day of work involved... You need to patch the UEFI, do something to the graphics, patch the ISO, or happen to have the exact right model. And it violates the terms and conditions. So MacOS isn't really an alternative, is it?
Whatever people do on computers... Surf websites, do emails, online-shopping, organize documents, vacation pictures, paperwork, type letters, draw diagrams, watch videos, do video conferences, stuff related to hobbies... I mean she isn't a programmer or designer by trade or anything like that, but computers are just useful tools for a lot of things.
Nah. She doesn't. And I think the days of Blogs and personal websites are mostly a thing of the past. These days people doomscroll on Instagram. But I have some fond memories of the good old times as well. I used to have friends (of different genders) who would write publicly about technology, sugar-free recipes, I knew someone who did styling videos on Youtube. But that toned down as we all grew older and got other things to do, and the internet changed as well.
Me too. I guess the internet is going to change soon anyway. AI Slop is going to displace a lot of things. And these cooking recipes don't really work. So there will be a demand for genuine, human content. And the only way to tell is if you have some connection to the creator. So we might see a revival of human connection online. At least that's what I hope will happen... And seems lots of people are fed up with social media as well.
Well, each one has pros and cons. *UNIX (I'm including *Linux and *BSD only, since masOS is technically uses a Unix-like kernel and *BSD code) systems tend to provide more control to the user, as they are Libre Software; however, the code can be rather clunky (especially in GNU + systemd + Linux distributions), and is much less secure.
What is Libre Software?
Libre Software is one in which you have the following freedoms:
- Run the program for any purpose
- Study the program by any means
- Modify the program code in any manner
- Distribute the program at any price
Depending on the Libre Software license, there can be conditions:
- In any copies which you distribute, you must provide credit to authors of which code you used, and keep the license notice (example: Expat license)
- If any patented techniques are on the code, you must provide rights to them (example: Apache 2.0 license)
- Any code on the program is also licensed under it, and you must pass down the same freedoms and obligations; this can be either per-file (example: MPL 2.0), or more commonly, for the entire program (example: GPL 3.0 or later), although exceptions can be made for other programs using it as a library (example: LGPL 3.0 or later)
- There must not be any system (e.g. DRM) preventing people from replacing the program with a modified version of it (example: GPL 3.0 or later)
- Network use can also be considered conveying (example: AGPL 3.0 or later), in which case you must also pass down the rights & obligations
macOS, on the other hand, is much more restrictive, but comes with much better security (the best out of any desktop OS).
while you're probably looking for some very tangible reasons in a bullet list of how its better, there's really one foundational reason and everything else is a distant second.
Linux (mint or otherwise) is your OS that you use on your hardware. Period. It's not going to tell you how to use it, what is allowed, what is right, or anything of that nature. It's yours. Have at it.
If you have a desktop/laptop, you run Linux.
If you have a Mac, you run OSX.
Im not sure where you’re going with this OP, unless you’re looking for purchasing advice. It’s kinda like asking if a car or truck tire is better, with the answer being “well, do you have a car or a truck?”
Apple abandons macOS* updates after a computer is over 7 years old or so.
At that point Mint or similar distros are your primary option for running a secure OS on excellent but aging hardware.**
Sleep/wake, battery management, and trackpad don't work quite as well, and you usually have to install the Broadwell wifi driver manually, and the camera will be fussy, but otherwise it is the better OS for an old Mac.
* (no longer called OSX since they left v.10 behind a long time ago).
** you can force a later macOS onto older models, but it's not very stable.
Ignore the downvotes. Mint or Debian or Fedora can be great on Macs earlier than 2016.
I currently have it installed on a 2008 iMac and a 2012 MacBook Pro.
I also have ZorinOS On a MacBook Air that works great, and Debian on a MBPro 2014, and am about to install Fedora on another MBPro, 2013. Those are mostly server experiments, though.
Yes, I wind up with a lot of old macs that I am reluctant to recycle!
Well, the next question is “what do you do when you drive?” Cars and trucks have wildly different roles they’re good at.
So basically, what do you want your computer to be good at doing? That dictates your hardware purchase and the OS you will end up using.
Why is my chainsaw better than my accord?
It’s not a good question.
In my experiemce it's not. Unless you've not got Mac hardware, in which case it's your only choice from those two options.
Now, how is Mint better than macOS on older Macs?
Well. I used OCLP to run Sequoia on my 2014 Mac mini. It ran, but it was a dog egg. The fan was basically a continuous jet engine. So I used it to dip my toes in Linux and put Mint on it. 100% improvement. Mint doesn't mind only having 8Gb RAM, and doesn't really give a shit what it runs. It's modern and up to date and not growing new security holes with every month that passes. Running Mint, that little computer has become the hub of my homelab. Sure, there's better hardware for the task, but the best gear is the gear you've got, right?
However, if my M2 MacBook could run Mint, I'd still be running Sequoia on it, because there's a swathe of shit that macOS does out of the box that it's taken me a year of using Linux to give up trying to emulate with any level of success.
But not macOS 26 though. Oh Jesus fuck no. I've tried it on the M1 mini I have and it's fucking awful.
Recommendation: you can get a decent used laptop from eBay or Craigslist and install mint on it. Cost would be under $200.
You should ask the AI what the advantages are of Linux Mint over macOS. You should then ask the reverse and compare the pros and cons from both angles.
Note that the AI is just going to aggregate Reddit posts and dress up the language a bit. But you should get good information.
As a macOS user typing on a Mac mini (M2 Pro) running macOS 26.2 Tahoe, I will say that Linux is better for gaming via Proton. We have the Game Porting Tool Kit (GPTK) but this is not really user facing. We have paid options like CrossOver, and there used to be a free option called Whisky, but it's been discontinued. Linux is kind of awesome for gaming and like, most games run on Linux now. (I choose to game on Xbox and Switch, but that's beside the point.)
I think macOS is a slightly more polished product, but the trade-off for Linux is, you can run it on more hardware (like if you have an ageing PC and you don't want to get a Mac — or, if you can find a decent PC for the price of an M4 Mac mini, which goes for $500), and you have more control over the software. For example, it just came up again in the Windows communities that Windows 11 can't move its taskbar to the sides or the top like it's done since Windows 95 through Windows 10. macOS has a menu bar that is stuck on the top always (always has been) but it has an application dock on the bottom that can move to the left (but not the right, nor can it sit on or under the menu bar at the top). In Linux, not only can you put your system bar wherever you want it, I think you can customise it to have more than one (like you can go macOS and have a menu/system bar and dock, but you can put them where you want them).
I personally wouldn't choose Linux over macOS, but if I did, I would start with Ubuntu. Personal preference. And, while I wouldn't trade my MacBook, I could use Linux on the desktop. I wouldn't hate it. I like my Mac, but if I got ahold of an older PC, like something a company was getting rid of because it can't run Windows 11 (say, a 7th generation i5 with 16GB of RAM would be nice), I'd wipe the drive and put Linux on it. I would not try to make it a Hackintosh (I'm honestly not gonna do the work). Coming from an office, it would likely be sold without a drive. So I'd get a cheap SATA SSD (like 500/512GB) and put Ubuntu on it.
Bold reply in r/Linux.
Interesting response. I'm not subbed the the Linux community; Lemmy is small enough, I just browse /all. Still, even among Linux users, there's no best. You got the Arch guys, the Mint guys, the Ubuntu guys, and everyone in between, and hashing out which options are best has got to be an interesting part of it. So if you add Windows and macOS into the mix, you're not really changing the conversation. Just more pros and cons to toss around. Saying things like "proprietary" and "Apple tax" are reductive and don't really get anyone anywhere. Like who gives a shit. Really. Though I think a lot of people agree paid Linux and proprietary Linux is seldom good. Like Lindows/Linspire. Nobody liked that shit. There's a new one that's paid, or it's free but has paid options, apparently it's pretty popular? I forget the name right now. Marketing itself as a better alternative to Windows. And I get it. Support options and all that. It's a good idea. But the Arch guys aren't buying it, and I suspect the Mint and Ubuntu guys aren't interested, either. But a Windows guy who, that's all he knows? Maybe it's a nice first step to something else.
Oh, I fully understand what you said, the diatribe wasn't required. I just thought it was weird, just walking into a chili cook-off telling everyone you don't like chili.
Only I don't dislike chili (Linux). What you're saying is that someone who likes beans in their chili wouldn't be welcome at a chili cook-off because beans don't belong in chili in your opinion, and your opinion should be the law of the land.
Or are you saying a person can only attend a chili cook-off (or a discussion about Linux) if they eat chili every day (or use Linux)? Can someone who is merely interested in the subject not partake, Your Holy Imperial Majesty?
top 72 comments