Gratuitous "the".
post
isn't china struggling with deflation nowadays, though? they can afford things perfectly well, they just don't do it
(correct me if i'm wrong i know fuck all about economics)
It‘s not going well for the average Chinese worker in recent years from what I‘ve heard. The pandemic and crumbling real estate market followed by countries diversifying their economies away from China (albeit slowly) and Trumps arbitrary trade war aren‘t good prospects for China. Xi Jinping‘s rhetoric in speeches went from „prosperity for all“ before the pandemic to „prosperity in moderation“ to essentially saying people shouldn‘t expect anything at all in his „eat bitter“ speech last year and that was before tariffs. Order books are empty and unemployment is rising just like it is in many places of the world right now to be honest. These are economically turbulent times and export economies are struggling when nobody can afford shit.
Needs text alternative.
In terms of average purchasing power for the bottom half of their populations
Interesting graphs. China does have a lot of very poor provinces, even if high number out of official poverty levels. PPP income per capita is much higher in China than US and growing significantly.
PPP national income per capita in USA > 3-fold that in China
where China beats USA is personal wealth of the less wealthy as mentioned before
economic inequality
China has many more socialized services and their income level is far less indicative of overall quality of life
It has honestly been a long time since I heard someone in the west suggest the chinese economy is struggling at all - i thought maybe something meaningful had happened in the last week or something that changed that picture
An interesting question is which of these 2 numbers is most important. The PPP income measurements could be flawed if the poorest half of Chinese have been able to accumulate double the wealth as poorest half of Americans.
Even if "attitudes towards savings" are different/a factor, being able to survive while hoping for the upward mobility that savings/wealth provides is more likely than not, a sign that poorer half of Chinese are better off than poorer half of Americans, despite the standard measures of PPP income.
This post is misinformation.
Statistical Communiqué for 2024 on national economics by the National Bureau of Statistics of China:
"In 2024, the per capita disposable income nationwide was 41,314 yuan, an increase of 5.3 percent over that of the previous year or a real increase of 5.1 percent after deducting price factors"
Tell me how growing your disposable income by 5% a year is "not being able to afford anything"
41,314 yuan
So, in average they had 5k dollars to spend on everything that isn't food and rent... And you are proposing they are rich?
When you can get a fucking delicious and nutritious bowl of noodles and vegetables for 5 yuan or a metro/bus ride for 3 yuan in the USA let me know.
How much money do you think the median American takes home these days with cost of living and suppressed wages? -2000 in credit card debt once the budget gets tallied?
23k dollars:
Umm do you want to break those numbers down for the bottom 75% or earners? Or the median? I believe that is just the billionaire holding up the statistic that the Fed is presenting. Also, those numbers were in billions representing the whole country not an individual in thousands…..
I'd expect the Chinese numbers to be way more skewed than the US ones. Too bad we can't rely on their statistics.
Either way, both numbers are for the average. The US one is for September, when it was still reliable; the Chinese one is certainly a gross overestimation, but for December, and we don't know if it moved up or down from there yet.
My aunt and uncle went on a state sponsored trip and got the impression that they have a stronger middle class than we do. From what I can piece together I’d tend to agree. But ya I guess we’ll know for sure with more hindsight.
Gotta love the two biggest economy’s in the world and you can’t find/trust good data
they have a stronger middle class than we do
They official numbers are worse than the US:
https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/gini-coefficient-by-country
The problem is this is an easy thing to lie about, so their official numbers are certainly complete fabrications. And they still weren't bold enough to fabricate something that put them above the US.
This is my gripe with tankies. One of the most salient points of 1984:
“It was now impossible for any human being to prove by documentary evidence that the war with Eurasia had ever happened.”
“Oceania was at war with Eurasia: therefore Oceania had always been at war with Eurasia.”
All war is fake except the class war.
It's been so fun seeing USians freak out at the remote prospect that they might have to live like people in other countries do. USians on Reddit spent the entire 2023 complaining about prices of Doordash delivery, and then they're also irked that games cost 60$ now. But cooking at home for a couple days instead of ordering pizza again? Not an option. “Ooh we have to work all day, we don't have time for cooking.” Well guess how people eat in other countries? They cook at home after work. Boo fucking hoo.
It's very funny how consistently ignorant you people are while you're putting on your "me smart and better than those silly Ameridumbs" act
all 54 comments