Nobody cares about recognition start sanctioning Israel.
post
Hey, no need to hurry with these pointless (in short term) actions. I'm sure palestians won't mind another month of genocide to be recognized which will change exactly nothing for them.
Again, all these countries will recognise it in September because that's when they can make it official at the UN. It's not delayed because fun.
And again, this small decision doesn't exonerate them from taking other ones until then.
This is a good thing and shitting on it is what is pointless.
Shit on the governments for not taking other actions, not for taking this one.
But the government is distracting public with such actions. Let me put it like this: Imagine your house is on fire, a fireman, which provided and provides fuel to the arsonist, strolls by and tells you that by next week they will pour a glass of water on your house.
This announcement is de facto recognising a Palestinian state, they will have to wait until September to de jure recognise the state (thankyou CK2 for explaining that distinction.)
That's a terrible comparison. I get your point, and as I said, you can shit on them for selling weapons, you can shit on them for not doing anything to stop the genocide.
But shitting on them for making the decision to recognise the state of Palestine is like shitting on the government for increasing the budget of the fire department, because it's not helping your house burning down right now.
Asking palestinians to disarm without any guarentee to stop isrsel occupation is so ridiculous and dangerous. We won't fall from western propaganda like you
I never supported that, did I?
The countries you believe that they really believe in a two state solution support that
Again, I didn't support anything else than the decision to recognise the state of Palestine, I have no idea what you're trying to argue with me about
I have no idea what you're trying to argue with me about
I am arguying the idea that conditional recognition of palestine is possible. The conditions onñy help israel occupation and hurt palestinians rights like the right for an army to protect itself
I still don't know what you're talking about. Countries are going to recognise the state of Palestine in September, they're not expecting anything for it.
The PA made commitments themselves. And they're not exactly heavily militarized anyway.
Carney literally said there is conditions
What is he going to do if his conditions aren't respected? Unrecognise Palestine?
All these conditions are just a way to alleviate the wrath of the US.
What's happening is that France took the initiative, and now countries are timidly following. Saying there are conditions is a political move, as no one can guarantee nothing.
But this article isn't even about Canada.
I was right the same bs Canada , France and UK said
Albanese said Australia had sought and received assurances from Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas that Hamas would play no role in any future Palestinian state.
Other conditions include a commitment to demilitarize and to hold general elections, abolish a “system of payments to the families of prisoners and martyrs,” and governance and education reform, as well as “international oversight to guard against the incitement of violence and hatred,” Albanese said.
https://www.cnn.com/2025/08/11/australia/australia-palestinian-state-september-intl-hnk
Israel the occupier get to keep it's army but the occupied should stay demilitarized and be administrated by the same countries who are complicit with Israel genocide.
France, Canada and u.k was all caught lying about stopping the arms sale to Israel why the hell would i still believe them at anything. Those countries doesn't give a damn about a Palestinian state they always keep talking about the occupying force right to self defense , never Palestinians. They never call illegal settlers terrorists and refuse to acknowledge that Israel itself are the one who are arming the settlers and defend their crimes
It's a pacifier for people like you, you get to relax and say look they're finally doing something, but they're doing nothing of value. Palestinians don't want a state on the ruins of Gaza or the ghettos that remain in the West Bank, we want a free Palestine from the river to the sea, for all regardless is religion.
Anything short of fully dismantling the occupation, reparations, and the right of return for all the refugees that want to return is just the current situation with extra steps.
Why are they all fucking saying September?
Something to do with the UN schedule.
It's a mutually agreed deadline for Trump to stop screwing around with tariffs and torching international agreements.
If he doesn't reverse or change his policy by then, all these shill countries will stop following US foreign policy demands.
Notice how these are all significant military partners and customers of the US as well (UK. France, Germany, Australia, etc).
They prepare the plan with israrl and the collaborators to meet thr conditions that carney mentionned. Basically we get rid of hamas , we let the palestinians autority have fake control on gaza and the west bank then let israel continue occupation
The same BS as Canada , France and UK said
Albanese said Australia had sought and received assurances from Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas that Hamas would play no role in any future Palestinian state.
Other conditions include a commitment to demilitarize and to hold general elections, abolish a “system of payments to the families of prisoners and martyrs,” and governance and education reform, as well as “international oversight to guard against the incitement of violence and hatred,” Albanese said.
https://www.cnn.com/2025/08/11/australia/australia-palestinian-state-september-intl-hnk
Israel the occupier get to keep it's army but the occupied should stay demilitarized and be administrated by the same countries who are complicit with Israel genocide.
Cool! Now do something to stop the endless slaughter. Oh, you won’t do that, and you have no intentions of doing that, and this is just lip service to those dumb enough to fall for it.
A little late, no? And why wait until September?
Gotta let those Zionists do a little more genocide I guess.
It's in the first paragraph, the timing of the next general meeting
conspiracy hat on Gotta wait till their funding gets cleared to some terrorist group and they commit some heinous crime against the west, without any trace.
Then they back down, everything goes back to the way it was and they seem like good people for their cult. conspiracy hat off
The way of the west.
I dont get it. Why do the all want to do this in months? Is it to let israel demolish it first?
Progress is progress, but this won't make people forget about the arms deals that they signed during the conflict and then lied about (eg: Elbit).
https://www.crikey.com.au/2024/06/07/labor-albanese-lying-israel-gaza-elbit-systems/
all 37 comments