https://signal.org/blog/protecting-your-privacy/
Signal's post rather than a Reuters retelling
https://signal.org/blog/protecting-your-privacy/
Signal's post rather than a Reuters retelling
I thought Signal introduced that already in the aftermath of the Windows Recall announcement.
Reuters is straight up considering my browser a bot and not letting me read the article, and the title sounds nonsensical.
Can someone answer, why would they even do that? What's the point of restricting screenshots? As if it isn't trivial to go around such app level restrictions in the first place.
https://signal.org/blog/protecting-your-privacy/
Just read it straight from the source.
From the article:
GETTING AROUND PROTECTIONS Agents that can take actions on behalf of users are billed as the next big wave of AI technology, capable of surfacing relevant information from across different apps and executing time-saving tasks like answering emails, booking appointments and making online purchases autonomously, without direct instructions. However, that reach can get around the protections that apps like Signal build for themselves. Reuters reported earlier this week that Meta's (META.O), opens new tab Muse agent was able to bypass its own official "Connector" tool to access Signal messages on both an Apple computer and a phone using Google's Android system. In both cases, Muse used broad operating system-level permissions granted during the app's initial setup to pull in the messages, using those authorizations in ways a user might not anticipate. On Apple's macOS, for instance, it used a combination of the computer’s accessibility and screenshot tools, repurposing settings Apple offers for people with disabilities to navigate over to Signal, take screenshots of chats there, extract text from those pictures and reproduce the messages inside the Muse app. An operating system update from Apple this week effectively closed that specific pathway, but also introduced a new set of permissions aimed at agents that offers similar capabilities paired with additional user warnings. Meta said in response to Reuters' reporting that agents need to see and interact with people’s computers in order to work on their behalf, and that Muse can access other apps only via permissions users explicitly grant. Signal said that developers should have straightforward ways of opting their apps out of such data processing by AI assistants entirely, specifically mentioning screen reading, notifications and other file system access. The service, owned by a non-profit foundation, promises its users a secure messaging experience by limiting the data it stores on its own servers, eschewing ads and offering end-to-end encryption, meaning it cannot access and read the conversations conducted on its app. AI systems that scan people's screens can undermine those protections by pulling the messages out of Signal's secure environment and into whatever other servers the agent is using, it said in the post.
Insane that there are people out there that woulg give an LLM unrestricted access to their devices..
Wow! Honestly I am not big fan of reading gigantic responses 😊
They are dicks now, they tookoil money and now want a subscription. Fuck reuters.
Interesting (and mildly horrifying) thought: if these AI systems integrate all our private communications and personal files we get really close to a collective-consciousness.
Muse agent was able to [..] access Signal messages on both an Apple computer and a phone using Google's Android system. In both cases, Muse used broad operating system-level permissions granted during the app's initial setup to pull in the messages, leveraging those authorizations in ways a user might not anticipate.
Meta's Muse seems to behave a lot like malware.
Is the threat model malware taking screenshots on the phone? Clunky solution to an impossible problem.
Yes, except the malware is your operating system. The article also mentions that they thought the solution was incomplete and were asking for more options.
A large portion of the tech industry seems to have gone mad. Tearing down privacy and security protections, giving up decarbonation goals, taking so many backward steps just to facilitate and increase AI use. Sorry for the rant, it's hard not to when things are so insane.
It's possible to change it back, they just changed the toggle for everyone and notified them about why.
Signal markets itself as privacy focussed, so this is a good step IMO. The average person might not realize it
all 18 comments