Arafat died in November 2004. In January 2005 Mahmoud Abbas won a peaceful election that outside observers called free and fair. This was the best chance for peace in years.
Abbas recognized Israel. He renounced terrorism. He wanted a negotiated settlement. And Bush had just won reelection, so he was in the strongest political position of his presidency to help him.
Bush did almost nothing. Why? Because he had already committed to Sharon unilateral disengagement plan. That plan held no promise of a viable Palestinian state. The authors say Bush backing it doomed the Road Map from the start.
Sharon refused to negotiate. He made it impossible for Abbas to deliver anything to the Palestinian people. Ha'aretz columnist Bradley Burston wrote just before the January 2006 Palestinian election: "If it appears to you that Israel is Hamas campaign manager in next week elections for the Palestinian parliament, few would argue, especially in Hamas."
Hamas won. Now Israel had another reason not to negotiate. And the Bush administration was even less likely to push them to talk.
Then the Gaza pullout collapsed. Israel pulled out in August 2005 and then cordoned off Gaza. Palestinians could not lead a decent life. Rockets continued. A soldier was captured on June 25 2006. Three days later Israel reentered Gaza.
Olmert, who took over from the incapacitated Sharon, admitted it in January 2007. He told the Chinese news agency Xinhua that he had been confident unilateral withdrawal could solve the problem. He was wrong. Now, he said, "under the existing circumstances, it would be more practical to achieve a two-state solution through negotiations rather than unilateral withdrawal."
A moderate Palestinian leader gets elected. He recognizes Israel and renounces violence. Israel refuses to negotiate with him because Israel does not want a viable Palestinian state. The moderate leader loses credibility because he has nothing to show for his moderation. Hamas wins the next election. Then Israel says it cannot negotiate because Hamas is in power. They created the excuse they use. Every time a moderate appears, they kill the moderate path and then blame the Palestinians for the result.
Source: The Israel Lobby and U.S. Foreign Policy, 2007, a book written by John Mearsheimer and Stephen Walt
1 comment