In March 2007 the Arab League reissued its peace plan. The offer was big. Peace and normal relations with all twenty-two Arab states in return for Israel withdrawing from the Occupied Territories and the Golan Heights, a Palestinian state with East Jerusalem as its capital, and a negotiated solution to the refugee issue. The Saudis made clear it was a starting point, not a take-it-or-leave-it deal.

Olmert was not interested. He rejected any Israeli responsibility for the refugee issue. "I will not agree to any kind of Israeli responsibility for this problem. Full stop." He said the return of even one refugee to Israel was "out of the question." Ha'aretz editorial: "A realistic government would have rushed to embrace this willingness for recognition and reconciliation."

Condoleezza Rice tried anyway. She traveled to Jerusalem seven times in eight months. In early February 2007 she met fifteen major Jewish leaders and told them she would not pressure Israel and would not offer US suggestions on what a final deal might look like. The authors say this "greatly limited the secretary's effectiveness."

On February 19 she brought Olmert and Abbas together. Both refused to appear with her at the press conference. The New York Times ran an editorial titled "Charade in Jerusalem."

In late March she returned and raised the idea of serving as a mediator. Olmert flatly rejected it. She had to cancel the press conference. The Daily Telegraph headline: "Israel Snubs Condoleezza Rice."

Behind the scenes Elliott Abrams was working against her. He was the NSC official for the Middle East. He had help from two neoconservatives in the vice president office, John Hannah and David Wurmser. Journalist Jim Lobe reported that sources said Abrams was "working systematically to undermine any prospect for serious negotiations." Daniel Levy, a former adviser in the Israeli prime minister office, described the routine. When Rice got too active, Olmert aides Yoram Turbowitz and Shalom Turgeman were dispatched to Abrams, who would "enlist Cheney to keep the president in tow." Henry Siegman of the Council on Foreign Relations said every time the US looked ready to engage seriously, Abrams met secretly with Olmert envoys in Europe to reassure them.

Just before Rice arrived in February, Olmert let the media know he had spoken to Bush the day before and that "the prime minister and president see eye-to-eye." Ha'aretz reporters Aluf Benn and Shmuel Rosner wrote: "The message was unmistakable: What Rice had to say barely mattered."

Philip Zelikow was Rice closest adviser at State. He gave a speech in September 2006 linking the Palestinian issue to building an anti-Iran coalition. Pro-Israel groups attacked immediately. State distanced itself the same day. Rice assured Israeli foreign minister Tzipi Livni the two issues were separate. Zelikow left the next month. He was replaced by Eliot Cohen, a neoconservative.

Congress also blocked her. Bush approved $86 million to strengthen Abbas security forces. Congresswoman Nita Lowey held it up. Anthony Weiner wrote to Rice asking her to withdraw it. ZOA head Morton Klein said Bush "should be as tough on Abbas as he is on Hamas and al Qaeda." The amount was cut to $59 million with restrictions.

June 2007: Hamas preempted the whole thing and seized Gaza.

My analysis is this is how you sabotage a peace process without ever saying no. You do not reject the talks publicly. You send your guys to reassure the other side that nothing will happen. You block the money for the moderate. You get the president to say he sees eye-to-eye with the prime minister. And then you let the whole thing collapse and blame the side with less power. Rice traveled seven times. Seven trips. And Olmert would not even stand next to her at a press conference.

Source: The Israel Lobby and U.S. Foreign Policy, 2007, a book written by John Mearsheimer and Stephen Walt

1 comment

sorted by: hot top controversial new old
[–] 1 point 3 days ago

Yeah sure war criminal Rice support peace

  • source