Hi,

Christmas is coming, and we've had repeated requests for a digital picture frame, that would allow us to send pictures to older relatives from our home devices. I guess there is no alternative to wifi and cloud here, since we live far away from one another, and don't want to bother with sending SD ou USB drives through traditional mail.

We've looked around, but all we see are suggestions for building our own frame, self hosting, or keeping the device offline, which does not work for us, since we don't have enough time or resources to dig those options.

So far i see 3 potential candidates:

  • Frameo seems to be an option, but there is not much details about the 'privacy' of their frame
  • Pix-Star states that despote end to end encryption, pics are stored on the servers and the app maintenance is outsources.
  • Aura but there is no end to end encryption: it's TLS for transfer and AES-256 for storage, plus they use AWS which I would like to avoid if possible.

Any help is appreciated,

all 18 comments

sorted by: hot top controversial new old
[–] 54 points 1 day ago (1 child)

The P in IOT stands for privacy, the S for security

  • source
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] 8 points 1 day ago

    i would've also suggested a self hosted solution (immich, immich-frame on frameo, tailscale) but also have you looked at Skylight? not sure what they use for their backend (it also involves a subscription to use as photo frame, which is likely more a negative than positive)

  • source
  • [–] 7 points 1 day ago

    I use immich frame with a local immich instance.

    I use kiosk mode on Ubuntu for the client

  • source
  • [–] 19 points 1 day ago (3 children)

    Get one where you can load images via USB and don't connect it to the internet.

    Or diy one, also a nice project.

  • source
  • hideshow 3 child comments
  • [–] 8 points 1 day ago (2 children)

    That is what all digital frames used to be like. I had one at my desk at work for a long time... until someone stole it from my desk. In the end, it wasn't private either. Seriously though, who the fuck steals your frame with pictures of your family on it?

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 2 child comments
  • [–] 6 points 1 day ago

    I'm not even sure you need to self host anything. Used Surface Go devices go for around £30-40, seem to be quite Linux friendly and have plenty of power to be used as a photo frame.

    Then you just need to start a slideshow from the Pictures directory (or any other) on boot.

    If you need to add photos without sending physical SD cards, you can use SSH over wireguard, maybe pull them from Dropbox or something, but I think the simplest solution would be syncthing.

  • source
  • [–] 3 points 19 hours ago

    You gotta recognize what you’re asking about and work from there.

    Your relatives aren’t gonna have a separate vlan for smart devices, they’re not gonna accept anything that needs complex authentication or security permissions. They will take the shortest, straightest, quickest route to grandchildren pictures in the living room updated in real time.

    You can protect yourself and your family by making sure the pictures they get are already public. Have a friends and family only Facebook account with few if any connections and have the device pull from that or something similar.

    That means you’re gonna be careful about the pictures in their stead.

  • source
  • [–] 3 points 1 day ago (1 child)

    I have read Frameo's policies when somebody I knew bought one. Not surprisingly, it was horrid. I don't remember the details, but sure as hell wasn't going to use their app to do anything. You can also email in photos as a better option, but "better" is really relative here. You're not going to find anything privacy friendly.

    Maybe you can find a semi-respectful app that displays a screensaver on the tv, pulling from a photo gallery. That's a big maybe, and it probably won't be private but it could be better.

  • source
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] 1 point 8 hours ago

    I’m really confused by this comment because from my reading, Frameo goes a long way toward ensuring privacy. Your photos never touch their servers and they actually keep updating their software. I’ve never heard anything about email as an alternative route. The company is based in Denmark, where the GDPR and respect for privacy is taken seriously (despite the politicians), so I tend to believe their claims without evidence to the contrary.

    Frameo is actually software rather than a frame manufacturer… maybe your acquaintance bought a knockoff? I did the same due diligence when my mom got one and was actually pleasantly surprised.

  • source
  • parent
  • [–] 2 points 9 hours ago*

    If it a simple display without internet, where you can load your images via USB, than there isn't any privacy problem, more than with an traditional photo frame. The only privacy hole is if you buy it with credit card.

  • source
  • [–] 2 points 1 day ago

    Hi Dop, I recently set up a DIY digital picture frame using Immich Kiosk. Hardware: Raspi Zero 2 W, Waveshare 10,1", a simple IKEA frame for $5 and an individual mat. DietPi is running on the Raspi and I wrote script so it starts Chromium in Kiosk mode upon launch. Works reasonably well.

    I also am pondering the question whether and how to set one of those up for relatives outside my household/network. In principle, it should be easy enough to add a Wireguard connection to the script so they connect to your network. Then you (and/or someone else in your household who uses Immich) can just add pictures to a (possibly shared) file and decide which pictures they see. I had also thought about giving one of my relatives an outdated iPad but am not sure whether that is wise given that it no longer receives security updates. It should be said that I am anything but an expert on this or any other IT issue.

  • source
  • [–] 2 points 14 hours ago

    Micropc + monitor. Get a domain and roll your own project from infinity of packages available in your favorite distro's repo. At worst it sucks but you learned something, at best you publish your project and others get to use your project

  • source
  • [–] 2 points 15 hours ago*

    I don't have one yet but have been dying to get my hands on it. I am planning to try ImmichFrame with it. Maybe you could set up theirs to connect to your server with ImmichFrame and auto update. Maybe have a shared album on Immich everyone can put a photo in.

    https://www.waveshare.com/rpi-zero-photopainter-acce.htm?sku=33137

  • source
  • [–] 2 points 13 hours ago

    I've actually been planning to eventually get a small touchscreen panel and combine it with an old Raspberry Pi 3B that has been collecting dust for a while and put immich frame on it and maybe a few other functions like displaying video from my doorbell cam or something through my home assistant server. Then 3D print a case for it and probably also integrate the Home Assistant Voice speaker's hardware to save some end-table room (small house). That would essentially replace the old Nest Hub I used to have which was always my favorite picture frame+ before Google went 100% evil.

  • source
  • [–] 1 point 22 hours ago*

    I got a Blaupunkt frame that also acts as a calendar.

    Basically there's a server in Ireland (Whale Framely) that holds all of my photos and pings my CalDAV server every 5 minutes for updates.

    While I can't guarantee that they're respectful of privacy, the network traffic appears to be the bare minimum to deliver the advertised features. The device itself doesn't appear to be snooping on my LAN or chatting to ad servers or anything like that.

  • source