And even a perfectly executed process would run into a math problem: It takes two-thirds of the Senate to convict a president in an impeachment trial, meaning Democrats would need at least 11 Republicans to join them for a conviction — a threshold they failed to clear even in the days after the Jan. 6 riot.
Raskin noted the tricky “constitutional arithmetic,” and he’s not alone.
“Is the Senate going to convict? You need to weigh that in and whether to proceed,” said Rep. Zoe Lofgren (D-Calif.), who served with Thompson and Raskin on the Jan. 6 committee. She was also an impeachment manager in 2020, when Democrats sought to remove Trump on grounds he threatened to withhold foreign aid to Ukraine unless president Volodymyr Zelenskyy agreed to investigate his political enemies.
“I think we need a national conversation,” Lofgren added.
I've posted similar before, sorry if anyone is annoyed, but:
This is the problem with how traditional democrats think: They value strategy and not tactics. Instead of trying to make the best decision each moment to move towards a goal, they give up unless they can chart a clear path from where they are to the goal.
Yes, it's accurate you don't have a reliable way to get 11 GOP votes for impeachment. That is not a reason not to impeach. Instead, ask, "Is the goal worthy? Is it impossible to get there?" If the answers are, respectively "yes" and then "no," move forward. Plan the next move and take it.
When you have an impeachment investigation in the House, you create political pressure and the game board changes. When you present that evidence, the game board changes. When you have a historic blue wave, and GOP politicians realize they have to choose between protecting Trump or themselves, the game board changes. When the public sees evidence and our president doing criminal things in a trial rather than a news story, polling changes and the game board changes.
When it comes to a vote in the Senate, it will not be the same calculus everyone is using to doom impeachment right now. And it may still fail. But Democrats need to stop basing everything on political calculations that depend on perfect information and strategic planning, and instead just start.
MAGA Republicans flooded the zone with absolute shit for every year they have been in power, and it worked - because there's a limit to how much the opposition can respond to, and it least it keeps them on the defense. So why can't Democrats flood the zone with justice, accountability and legislation that helps people? Do it because it's the right thing to do, because the Constitution needs to not be a list of suggestions if the country is going to survive this. Let the details work themselves out as it goes, it is not the end of the world to try to do something valuable and failing.
And as posted elsewhere, they can avoid subverting other Democratic priorities by scheduling impeachments as a block. Every complaint/objection is surmountable if people care to try.


all 63 comments