According to the Murdoch owned right-wingnut rag (WSJ) 69% in favour leaves 31% neutral or not in favour - 31% is NOT just under half, it's just under a third. Lying shitsacks.
post
Ok I'll admit I didn't get that at first what the fuck dude how'd you look at the stats and get that positioning from over 50% support
Not what that means
A Siena University poll showed that 30% of New York voters like the DSA and 47% don’t have a favorable view of them.
Edit: Worth noting, though, this is NY State likely voters. NYC is 49% support. 32% not support.
https://sri.siena.edu/wp-content/uploads/2026/08/SNY0826-Release-Crosstabs_Corrected.pdf
“New Yorkers”?
As in the entire State? A state that has large red rural areas? Polling people that aren’t even Mamdani’s constituents?
Some of the poll info is from the New York Post, an unapologetically right wing rag that has no problems trash talking the left.
It's New York, I am sure a non trivial amount of people don't care about him at all. And then what's left over are his actual supporters.
Ofcourse, the headline is obviously using the statistics in bad faith in an attempt to spin this in their favor.
Or another words, it is propaganda. Which I think is effective in every language although my sample size is limited.
The actual implication of the headline is that over half do support him. Non-support includes those apathetic and against. Saying "almost less than half lack support" means "more than half do support." The other less than 50% is shared by "no opinion" and "against."
Americans are irrationally anti-communist, that strategy is being used because it works.
Hey the Banana Republic is revolting! COMMUNIST! Here comes the American warships to stop communism in the name of the capitalist overlords with taxpayers money. Isn't that sosialism for the rich?
Everyone gets called communist. And when everyone's communist, no one is.
Is it a stupid move? Calling anything left of hunting the poor for sport "liberal" and anything left of giving the 1% all the money "communism" seems to be working extremely well for the right-wing. Perhaps we are dropping the ball by not giving an actual extreme left perspective in politics to balance things out.
Their mandate is merely resounding but not thunderously overwhelming yet? Great reporting.
SUBSTANTIAL AMOUNT OF NEW YORKERS UNHAPPY WITH MAMDANI!
MAMDANI IN TROUBLE! LESS SUPPORT FOR HIS POLICIES THAN EXPECTED!
MAJORITY OF NEW YORKERS NOT SUPPORTIVE OF MAMDANIs opponents
That’s less than more than 50%.
Source?
I hate to be the guy saying "Simpsons did it", but this exact same joke was used to highlight how dumb someone was.
In 1995.
Does someone read this and go "oh no %50 don't support Madani so I should quench all my positive feelings for him." Maybe they do and that is why they produced this excrement piece of a headline.
The title says almost half of New Yorkers aren't supportive of DSA.
Now:
- that means majority of New Yorkers are supportive
- "aren't supportive" implies that people who are apathetic are also included in that group
- there's also suggestion they might have counted people from New York State instead of New York City, but I don't believe that
People just want to see their bias confirmed. They read this and think 'see, i knew he wasn't as popular as they say'.
Reminds me of the old joke about second place, because of all the losers, you’re first.
So, a better title would be "Over half of New Yorkers are supportive of democratic socialism"?
Without seeing the data, we can't say that, there could be undecided in there that still means most don't support it. I'm going to look into it but I'm wondering if they are using the term New Yorkers to mean those from New York state or you know...just lying.
Edit: yup, they mean ny state and there are plenty of brainwashed people outside of city limits.
Huh, funny that all the other comments from this crosspost are over two weeks old. Why is that OP?
are you also being creative with english? 17 days is 2.4 weeks :p
Could it be that OP cross posted a two week old post to a different community today? No, it couldn't be that simple...

top 33 comments