The pictures imply a specific definition of "perfect," and if we're just going by the pics then that sword stick trumps the smooth rock.

BUT if we get to choose the definition of "perfect" then I'm pretty sure the coolest "rocks" I can imagine finding would trump the coolest "sticks" I can imagine finding.

It will always be the stick.

Rock. Keep it on a shelf forever. Maybe polish it up a bit.

Sticks can be lightsabers, great swords, staves, walking sticks, katanas, guitars, hockey sticks/golf clubs, and hundreds of other things.

A rock is a rock.

Rock!
You can hold onto it as a paper weight for reat of your life or carry it around in your pocket - knowing you have the perfect rock!

i have room to keep the rock, where would i even put the stick

Rock as adult. Stick as child.

Depends on how stingy we are being about the definition of rock. If it can't be entirely formed of carbon as like a giant diamond worth a few hundred million I can then sell, I'm going stick.

rock is this true ?

Rock. It will last through the ages/random moves. Its small and portable but substantial enough to be satisfying. My only concern is id be afraid id try to skip it across a lake and lose it.

Rock. I just think it's neat.

Rock 183%

Rock is easier to carry; less fragile too.

STICK! STICK! STICK!

Perfect rock is perfect for throwing, but then you don't have it anymore

My intrusive thoughts would take over if I ever held that rock and I would absolutely YEET it.

Stick is king

Perfect stick

hit rock as far as I can with stick

I'd skip the shit out of that rock, but I'd take a cool stick cause my dog would also appreciate it

The rock because in dirty for what I did to one like it. I took it from a gorgeous beach and lost it the next day, dooming it to suburban hell somewhere when it fell out of an unzipped pouch.

Or it escaped.

Leave everything but trash other people dropped

Is the stick for sale? Name your price!

I could enjoy the stick a lot for a day but the rock I could put on my desk and enjoy it a little every time I see it.

Wait, wait. Does that rock keep bears tigers away?

Edit: Remembered the scene wrong.