The problem is that this movement has exist for decades and failed to develop a large enough voter base to consistently win elections, that’s why they had to fall in line with trump, because they couldn’t stand on their own.
The biggest mistake people make when talking about MAGA is to treat it as a movement, it’s a coalition of disparate groups, it has no singular unifying belief other than “trump will do what my group wants”. But ultimately, none of the groups wanted the same things, most of their policy goals were antithetical to each other and ultimately wildly unpopular.
They’re easily defeated by simply inflaming the fault lines between such groups before they can win elections. This was the biggest failure in 2016 and 2024, treating trump’s base as a cohesive mass that could be “won over” or deradicalized on a few points, when really arguments that might work for one just bounce off the others as irrelevant.