you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] 5 points 12 hours ago (1 child)

Islam is and has always been a philosophically diverse religion. There have always been fundamentalists, there have always been progressives. What people are talking about is that in recent times the fundamentalists were funded and supported so they'd kill the socialists, which is factually true. It doesn't matter to this question whether there's continuity between fundamentalists (there is, but so is there with other streams of Islam).

Your comment about imperial centers also makes no sense when you look at history. Egypt and Mesopotamia were both imperial centers for thousands of years, and that's just the two biggest (there were also other very important and powerful power centers in the neighborhood). Even if you move the clock forward a lot, after the Romans conquered the Mediterranean, there were still the Persians to their East, and there were other powerful kingdoms in between and near them.

There were countless polities in South and Southeast Asia. That you don't know, and only know of China, doesn't make these any less real. Read more, learn more.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] 0 points 21 minutes ago*

    I think I did not make this clear. Two powerful imperial centres do not tolerate each other at the same time for long. They end up in conflict. During periods of weakness they are exploited by the strong and during periods of strength, they are the ones doing the exploiting. Where and who they are matters little. Empires rarely completely annihilate their rivals, they subjugate them. You do get cases like the Romans annihilating Carthage, or Islam annihilating the Zoroastrians. But mostly, it's a cases like Britain dominating India, or Japan subjugating Korea.

    Regarding Islam, they did have progressive periods and more fundamentalist ones. Just like the Christians. I see that Islam is trending progressive since the Arab spring. But they still have a long way to go, given that most of their societies still treat woman as inferior or at worst, property. Then on the opposite side you see Christian and Jewish nationalism rising again in the west. Which is driving Israel's aggressive expansionism and the erosion of human rights in those countries in favour of right wing fear mongering.

    The solution can only be a more connected world based on socialist secular humanism. It's effectively why a wars between rivals like France and Germany is impossible today. Similarly between Korea and Japan. Their economies are integrated with mostly free trade and cultural exchange.

  • source
  • parent