you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] -2 points 20 hours ago (4 children)

I see it as the same thing. If I don’t like seeing it why wouldn’t I want it removed?

(What’s motte and bailey 😭)

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 4 child comments
  • [–] 5 points 20 hours ago (1 child)

    It seems like you're being serious, rather than belligerent (which is how i originally read your tone), so sorry for being a little rude.

    Here's the thing. When it comes to public spaces, we can't really dictate everything to our own preferences without stepping on other people's toes. I'm guessing you would agree that conservatives saying that they don't want gay couples to hold hands in public are being unreasonable. Just because something makes some people uncomfortable doesn't mean it should be removed or destroyed.

    If you want to complain about seeing too much nudity in art or that you wish it wasn't in places you frequent, I think those are completely valid. It's when you want to take things away from others that it gets into dicey territory (and is why your opinion is getting called conservative)

    A motte & bailey fallacy is when you state a controversial opinion, and then when pressed, retreat to a reasonable position while pretending they're the same. In this case, "destroy statues with nudity" (controversial) and "i don't like seeing them" (reasonable). I don't think you did this on purpose, but it's a cognitive tactic that we can all fall into and should look out for.

  • source
  • parent
  • hideshow 1 child comment
  • [–] -1 points 19 hours ago

    Tbh I live in the mountains so “guy with his shirt off” didn’t even occur to me till someone else mentioned it. My difference is that statues aren’t people, so there really isn’t anything distinctly wrong with removing them. Sorta in the same vein as like replacing a tree in a park because oak is better than poplar, just changing the environment to preference. Whereas banning gay couples from affection obviously affects humans directly. Or mandating an amount of clothing

    And I mean yeah of course I mean the local area. A nationwide ban on all nudity sounds kinda dumb when I don’t plan on being in 99% of America 😭 I just don’t wanna see a dudes chest which is why I live in a cold place where that can’t really happen. Nudity in movies is also a tough question tbh, and is kinda case by case. A lot of movies will add a generally worthless sex scene or topless woman to appeal to a certain demographic. Others actually have a reason for that sort of thing as a metaphor. In either case I don’t like seeing it, but in the latter I can understand its purpose and appreciate its meaning

    Fallacies and all that like debate tier stuff just give me an auto cringe response from like redditors and shit lmao. Though I don’t really agree that those are two separate arguments. “Destroy all statues because I don’t like seeing them” would be my complete argument, though vastly simplified for dramatic lemmy reading. As you can see above the larger nuance is more like “I don’t like seeing nudity and will advocate for the removal of statues and decrease in meaningless nudity in media in my local area” but that’s like a big mouthful (and also maybe the motte and bailey 😔)

  • source
  • parent