Americans did not want war with Iran. The polls were clear. Late November 2006, just before the Iraq Study Group released its report: 75 percent of Americans said the United States "should deal with the government of Iran primarily by trying to build better relations." Only 22 percent favored "pressuring it with implied threats that the US may use military force."
The Iraq Study Group was a bipartisan committee of prominent Americans. In December 2006 it recommended that Bush negotiate with Iran rather than confront it. Its members understood that confronting Iran gave it powerful incentives to meddle in Afghanistan and Iraq. That was not in America interest.
The lobby went to work against it. The Forward reported that the release of the report "has produced an outpouring of protest from Jewish groups opposing its call for talks with Iran, Syria and the Palestinians." The Forward added: "insiders say that the real target of Israel anxiety is neither Syria nor the Palestinians, but Iran and its nuclear program."
Thomas Friedman of the New York Times, who is usually attuned to Israel concerns, remarked in early 2007 that Iran is a "natural ally" of the United States.
But the lobby kept pushing war. Retired General Wesley Clark was asked in early 2007 why the Bush administration seemed headed for war with Iran. He answered: "You just have to read what is in the Israeli press. The Jewish community is divided but there is so much pressure being channeled from the New York money people to the office seekers."
Clark was immediately smeared as an anti-Semite. The journalist Matthew Yglesias pointed out: "Everything Clark said is true. What is more, everybody knows it is true."
Scott Ritter was a former UN weapons inspector. In his 2006 book Target Iran he wrote: "Let there be no doubt: If there is an American war with Iran, it is a war that was made in Israel and nowhere else."
And the planning was already happening. James Bamford and Seymour Hersh separately described how many of the same people who planned the Iraq war devised the Pentagon plans for a military campaign against Iran. Douglas Feith, the undersecretary of defense for policy until August 2005, played a central role in developing the plans for striking Iran. Hersh in early 2005: "There has also been close, and largely unacknowledged, cooperation with Israel. Defense Department civilians, under the leadership of Douglas Feith, have been working with Israeli planners and consultants to develop and refine potential nuclear, chemical-weapons, and missile targets inside Iran."
In spring 2007 David Wurmser, who advised Vice President Cheney on Middle East affairs, gave a series of talks at the American Enterprise Institute. He said Cheney was unhappy with Secretary of State Rice and with President Bush for pursuing diplomacy at all. And that Cheney was interested in working with Israel to come up with a military strategy to eliminate Iran nuclear program that he could sell to the president.
75 percent of Americans wanted talks. The bipartisan Iraq Study Group wanted talks. A retired four-star general said the pressure was coming from Israel and New York money. A former UN weapons inspector said the war would be made in Israel. And a Cheney adviser was meeting with neocons to plan how to sell the president on a war with Israel. The American people did not want this. The American president was being pulled into it. And the lobby blocked every off-ramp. That is not democracy. That is a foreign policy run against the voters, by a lobby that does not even represent the community it claims to speak for.
Source: The Israel Lobby and U.S. Foreign Policy, 2007, a book written by John Mearsheimer and Stephen Walt