The Israel lobby is the network of pro-Israel groups in Washington. AIPAC is the biggest one.

Four days after the Lebanon war began, Nathan Guttman reported in the Jerusalem Post: "the American Jewish community has been demonstrating wall-to-wall support for Israel as it fights on two fronts." The lobby raised money for Israel, took out newspaper ads, monitored the media, and sent representatives to meet with legislators, administration officials, and media figures. Here are six incidents that show what that looked like.

One. At the start of the war there was a bipartisan effort to add language to the House resolution urging "all sides to protect civilian life and infrastructure." Nancy Pelosi, then House minority leader, and Senator John Warner, then chairman of the Armed Services Committee, favored the change. You would think such language would be unobjectionable. AIPAC wrote the original resolution and strongly objected. House Majority Leader John Boehner kept the language out. The resolution passed 410 to 8.

Two. Congressman Christopher Van Hollen wrote a letter to Secretary of State Rice on July 30 urging an immediate cease-fire. His letter said the Israeli response "has now gone beyond the destruction of Hezbollah military assets. It has caused huge damage to Lebanon civilian infrastructure, resulted in the large loss of civilian life, and produced over 750,000 refugees." He said the bombing "has transformed Lebanese anger at Hezbollah into growing hostility toward Israel and the United States." The lobby was furious. Van Hollen met with representatives from major Jewish organizations including AIPAC. He immediately apologized: "I am sorry if my strong criticism of the Bush Administration failures has been interpreted as a criticism of Israel conduct." Shortly after he went on a five-day visit to Israel sponsored by AIPAC affiliate the American Israel Education Foundation, accompanied by three pro-Israel activists and an AIPAC staffer. The leader of the Jewish Community Relations Council of Greater Washington said Van Hollen "needs to continue to reach out to the Jewish community." The ADL regional director said his response "doesn't undo the damage of the first letter." The point was to remind every other member of Congress what happens when you step out of line.

Three. Early in the war Bush gently warned Israel not to topple the Lebanese government he had helped put in power. The Forward reported on July 14 that "the Bush administration is being criticized by some Israeli and Jewish communal officials for calling on Jerusalem not to undermine the democratically elected Lebanese government." Abraham Foxman of the ADL said: "The administration and Western countries want to shore up the Lebanese government but it is a misguided policy to do so." After that criticism Bush stopped warning Israel about protecting the American-backed government in Beirut.

Four. Washington Post journalist Tom Ricks said on CNN during the war that "some U.S. military analysts" told him Israel "purposefully has left pockets of Hezbollah rockets in Lebanon, because as long as they are being rocketed, they can continue to have a sort of moral equivalency." The Committee for Accuracy in Middle East Reporting in America condemned his remarks. Former New York Mayor Ed Koch wrote to Post executive editor Leonard Downie saying the comments "are comparable to the age-old blood libel used by anti-Semites to incite pogroms in Europe." Downie wrote back: "I have made clear to Tom Ricks that he should not have made those statements." Ricks said: "The comments were accurate: that I said I had been told this by people. I wish I hadn't said them, and I intend from now on to keep my mouth shut about it."

Five. Pro-Israel groups ran a large-scale campaign against Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch for their reports. Alan Dershowitz: "Virtually every component of the organized Jewish community, from secular to religious, liberal to conservative, has condemned Human Rights Watch for its bias." The Jerusalem Post ran an op-ed titled "Ken Roth's Blood Libel." The New York Sun said Roth was partaking in "the de-legitimization of Judaism." Foxman accused Roth of "a classic anti-Semitic stereotype about Jews." Kenneth Roth is Jewish. His father was a refugee from Nazi Germany. Georgetown law professor Rosa Brooks wrote in the LA Times: "anyone familiar with Human Rights Watch—or with Roth—knows this to be lunacy. The notion that Roth is anti-Semitic verges on the insane. But what is most troubling about the vitriol directed at Roth and his organization is not that it is savage, unfounded and fantastical. What is most troubling is that it is typical. Typical, that is, of what anyone rash enough to criticize Israel can expect to encounter. In the United States today, it just isn't possible to have a civil debate about Israel, because any serious criticism of its policies is instantly countered with charges of anti-Semitism."

Six. On August 31 B'nai B'rith International sent a letter to UN humanitarian chief Jan Egeland, who had called Israel cluster bomb use "completely immoral." The letter accused him of acting "as an un-appointed moral arbiter with regard to disputed, unproven facts on the ground." A week later the Senate debated a bill to ban cluster bomb use in civilian areas and prohibit transfers to countries that refused the ban. AIPAC lobbied hard against it. The bill went down 70 to 30.

AIPAC president Howard Friedman sent a letter to supporters on July 30. He began: "Look what you've done!" Then: "Only ONE nation in the world came out and flatly declared: Let Israel finish the job. That nation is the United States of America—and the reason it had such a clear, unambiguous view of the situation is YOU and the rest of American Jewry."

Ehud Olmert said during the war: "Thank God we have AIPAC, the greatest supporter and friend we have in the whole world."

A resolution supporting Israel passes 410 to 8, and AIPAC wrote it. A congressman writes a letter urging a cease-fire, and he is forced to apologize and then takes a trip paid for by an AIPAC foundation. A president gently warns Israel, and Foxman shuts him up. A journalist reports what military analysts told him, and the newspaper editor apologizes to a former mayor and the journalist says he will keep his mouth shut. A human rights organization documents war crimes, and the response is to call the Jewish director a Nazi-style antisemite. A senator tries to ban cluster bombs, and AIPAC kills it 70 to 30. And the president of AIPAC writes to his donors and brags about it. Look what you've done. He said that. On paper. In 2006. And nobody in Congress blinked.

Source: The Israel Lobby and U.S. Foreign Policy, 2007, a book written by John Mearsheimer and Stephen Walt

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] 0 points 5 days ago* (1 child)

You appear to be talking about HRes 921 from the year 2006? Is this like a historical event archive community or something? You should probably find a way to add that to the title or the top of the post so people don't assume you're talking about the current congress or the incoming congress twenty years later.

  • source
  • hideshow 1 child comment