The core argument for the special relationship is that Israel is a vital strategic ally. The authors of this book say that argument is false. Here is their conclusion, in their own words.
"Although we believe that America should support Israel's existence, Israel's security is ultimately not of critical strategic importance to the United States." Then they explain what would happen if Israel were conquered. "In the event that Israel was conquered—which is extremely unlikely given its considerable military power and its robust nuclear deterrent—neither America's territorial integrity, its military power, its economic prosperity, nor its core political values would be jeopardized." Compare that to oil. "By contrast, if oil exports from the Persian Gulf were significantly reduced, the effects on America's well-being would be profound."
So they draw the line clearly. The United States does not support Israel because it makes Americans safer. "The United States does not support Israel's existence because it makes Americans more secure, but rather because Americans recognize the long history of Jewish suffering and believe that it is desirable for the Jewish people to have their own state." They are not saying Israel should be abandoned. They say there is a strong moral case. And the US should remain committed to coming to Israel's aid if its survival were ever in jeopardy. But Americans should do this because they think it is morally appropriate, not because it is vital to their own security.
For decades the lobby has sold Israel as a strategic asset. It is the shield of the Middle East. It is the frontline against terrorism. It is America's only real ally in the region. The authors look at that argument and say no. If Israel disappeared tomorrow, America would still be safe. America would still be rich. America would still be free. The only reason to support Israel is moral. That is a good reason. It is an honest reason. But it is a completely different reason than what the lobby has been telling the American people for forty years. And once you admit the strategic case is false, the whole conversation changes. Because then the question is not what Israel does for America. The question is what America owes Israel. And that is a moral question, not a military one. And the lobby does not want you to ask it that way.
Source: The Israel Lobby and U.S. Foreign Policy, 2007, a book written by John Mearsheimer and Stephen Walt