People say the two-state solution is impossible. Maybe it is. But then what? The authors of this book lay out the three alternatives. None of them are good. And the people who oppose two states never say which one they actually want.

The first alternative is ethnic cleansing. Israel could expel the Palestinians from its pre-1967 lands and from the Occupied Territories. That would preserve Israel Jewish character through an overt act of expulsion. The authors say some Israeli hard-liners, including Deputy Prime Minister Avigdor Lieberman, have advocated variants of this approach. Their verdict is blunt. To do so "would be a crime against humanity and no genuine friend of Israel could support such a heinous course of action." They add: if this is what opponents of a two-state solution are advocating, they should say so explicitly.

The second alternative is a binational state. Instead of separate Jewish and Palestinian states, all of Mandate Palestine becomes one democratic state where both peoples have equal political rights. A handful of Jews and a growing number of Israeli Arabs have suggested this. But the authors say the practical obstacles are daunting, binational states do not have an encouraging track record, and this option means abandoning the original Zionist vision of a Jewish state. There is little reason to think Israel Jewish citizens would accept it.

The third alternative is apartheid. Israel continues to increase its control over the Occupied Territories but allows the Palestinians limited autonomy in a set of disconnected and economically crippled statelets. The authors say Israelis bristle at the comparison to white rule in South Africa. But that is the future they face if they try to control all of Mandate Palestine while denying full political rights to an Arab population that will soon outnumber the Jewish population in the entirety of the land.

And apartheid is not a long-term solution either. It is morally repugnant. The Palestinians will continue to resist until they get a state of their own. This will force Israel to escalate repressive policies that have already cost it significant blood and treasure, encouraged political corruption, and badly tarnished its global image.

My analysis is this is the question the lobby never answers. Every time someone says make a Palestinian state, the lobby says no, it is too dangerous, the Palestinians are terrorists, there is no partner. Okay. So then what is your plan? Expel them? That is a crime against humanity and even the authors say no genuine friend of Israel could support it. One binational state? That destroys the Jewish state. Apartheid? That is South Africa. And we all know how South Africa ended. So the lobby has no plan. It just says no to the only plan that works and pretends the other options do not exist. That is not a strategy. That is a stall. And the price of that stall is paid by Palestinians every day and by Israel in the long run.

Source: The Israel Lobby and U.S. Foreign Policy, 2007, a book written by John Mearsheimer and Stephen Walt

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] 1 point 5 days ago*

If the two state was such a good solution, you wouldn't see the same countries who is arming israel claiming to support it. It is frustrating when people keep talking about what about the colonizers oppressors right to an ethnostate? They used to say the same thing about SA to justify apartheid

  • source