If the lobby were the path to peace, then the presidents who listened to it most should have made the most peace. The opposite happened.
The two presidents who made the greatest contribution to Middle East peace were Jimmy Carter and George H. W. Bush. Carter brokered the Egypt-Israel treaty at Camp David in 1979. Bush Sr. pressured Israel over the loan guarantees in 1991 and 1992, which opened the way for the Madrid Conference that brought Arabs and Israelis to the table for the first time.
And why were they able to do it? The authors quote the former Israeli foreign minister Shlomo Ben-Ami.
"Carter had yet another vital advantage. A rare bird among politicians, and especially among residents of the White House, he was not especially sensitive or attentive to Jewish voices and lobbies... As it turned out, it was this kind of President—George [H. W.] Bush in the late 1980s is another case in point—who was ready to confront Israel head on and overlook the sensibilities of her friends in America that managed eventually to produce meaningful breakthroughs on the way to an Arab-Israeli peace."
Read that again. From an Israeli foreign minister. The presidents who ignored the lobby are the ones who made peace. The presidents who listened to the lobby did not. Ben-Ami is not some critic of Israel. He was a key participant at Camp David in 2000. He served as Israel foreign minister. He is saying this on the record.
that is the proof that destroys the lobby's whole story. The lobby says it protects Israel. It says without the lobby America would abandon Israel. But look at history. Carter made the only Arab-Israeli peace treaty that has lasted. He did it by ignoring the lobby. Bush Sr. brought the Arabs to the table by pressuring Israel. He did it by confronting the lobby. Every president who listened to the lobby, from Clinton to Bush Jr., promised peace and delivered occupation. The lobby does not produce peace. It produces the exact opposite. And the people who made peace are the ones the lobby fought. That is not a coincidence. That is the whole answer in one comparison.
Source: The Israel Lobby and U.S. Foreign Policy, 2007, a book written by John Mearsheimer and Stephen Walt