I’m playing FFIX right now so I wonder if this is why my impression of BD is so different.
I definitely disagree on it being satire or even unserious. Yes, there’s comic relief and superficially it looks childish but it’s a retreat in style similar to FFIX and you can see they corrected every weak point from that one:
- Battles are faster, class and B/D mechanics are much more engaging, random encounter rate is adjustable. I don’t think I played any FF derivative that was more fun to play.
- They went more chibi in the art style at least in part out of necessity because FFIX character faces were a pixelated mess at 240p PSX display resolution, which is the same number of horizontal lines as 3DS.
- Comic relief is just simply better executed, FFIX jokes are cringe for lack of a better word. Ringabel isn’t that much more cheesy or over the top womaniser than Edgar from FFVI. You go to the moon like in every other FF.
To me BD is classic FF concept taken where it made sense. The only major difference is that the story took second seat to gameplay but I don’t think that’s what FF was about traditionally even if FFVI happened to be one of the best JRPG stories told.