You said its not a modern reasoning. 20th century is considered to be modernity, and pretty sure there are still doctors alive who worked in the 60s
I think you misread your own quote; what you quoted was not that doctors were still using that as the recommendation in the '60s but an allusion to a book regarding (to quote) "medical manias", The Anxiety Makers; every example from the book that your source quotes is from the 19th century: "Following Spitz and Hare, Comfort observed that punitive treatments for the vice introduced in the second half of the nineteenth century included[…]"
we can easily argue it’s about moral panic and conforming to societal standards more than about actual factual objective medical benefits
Except the first part would be speculative and not based upon any actual evidence; regardless the reasons parents do it, it is absurd to act like doctors and entire medical org.s are recommending…just because (even if their evidence for the recommendation is poor). My mother was a registered nurse: they have reasons they believe it should be offered within a medical setting and providing your own justifications for their motivations will not actually address why they are acting as they are; this is why – even if it agrees with our side – misinformation is bad as it paints our understanding of things on bad assumptions. Again, I would think we'd actually want to address why these decisions are greenlit rather than just feel smug that we know better but that's, apparently, too fine-grained a distinction.
You’re still just straight up wrong about “removing all risk of penile cancer”, yet you won’t admit that.
Because that was never the conversation, bud; and you still think this is a discussion about the efficacy of circumcision, apparently.
It was slight hyperbole but that's because I don't actually care about the details (as I said elsewhere, penile cancer is so rare as to make the former point – even if it were true – moot); the point was to refer to some of the medical information out there to draw attention to it because the original point of the conversation was that someone said the current reason for circumcision is antimasturbitory policy; which, again, is not true.
I'm not trying to cite that information in detail because it's only related to the main point that antimasturbitory policy is not the current defense for the practice. I'm not making an argument for circumcision; that is not the conversation.
I'll let you get back to the conversation you'd rather have where you describe your masturbation practices.